Which Tidus do you like better?

[FFfreak1]

http://i3.minus.com/iby8jxk7QyaILZ.pnglhttp://images.wikia.com/finalfantasy/images/archive/a/a1/20130322161414!Tidus_in_Zanarkand_Ruins.jpg

[Flying Mullet]

The one where he doesn't whine.

[FFfreak1]

The one where he doesn't whine.

Well if your dad treated you the way Jecht treated Tidus you would be the same way.

[Jinx]

I actually think he looks better in that second picture.

[Fynn]

He looks like Meg Ryan in both.

[maybee]

This Tiddes

http://stream1.gifsoup.com/view/179599/tidus-laughing-o.gif

Gasps. Beautiful.

[Jinx]

I think the re-do has made his face shape super feminine.

They also made his eyes soulless.

[Shauna]

It's the uncanny valley man, it's got him.

[Sephiroth]

The PS2 Tidus. I also like the PS2 Ansem more.

[Flying Mullet]

It's the uncanny valley man, it's got him.
I was wondering why I didn't like the PS3 version more and you nailed it.
Now I feel confident casting my vote in the poll. Nothing to see here. Really, nothing.</>

[Pumpkin]

PS2 Tidus.

[Hambone]

I can't say I feel strongly either way. I have a feeling that right now my gut reaction is to say that I like PS2 Tidus more, but I feel like that opinion is heavily influenced by my own nostalgia. I'm sure that if I sat down, played the HD remaster (when it finally comes out, that is), and had a chance to get used to PS3 Tidus, I'd like him just as much as PS2 Tidus.

[Pike]

He looks the exact same in both screenshots.

[Freya]

He has a squishy face in the top screenshot. I like the ps2 I believe if that's the bottom one.

[Elly]

the top one looks best... the detail is clearer on the cloths, the hairs not all straight edges and angles... the first one is a vast improvement over the second... overall i'd have to say i like the new textures way better than the originals...

[Aulayna]

PS2 one. PS3 looks like he has eyeliner on and the smirk is .... uuuurggghhh... He looks more metrosexual in the PS3 one too.