LoTR/Hobbit Elimination Game

[Elskidor]

This isn't a Tolkien board so I'll keep the characters very limited. Who is your favorite and who is not? Vote once a day and reward 2 points against your favorite character and 2 against your weakest link. In the end the can be only one...but it doesn't have to be the Highlander!

5 - Bilbo
5 - Frodo
5 - Pippin
5 - Sam
5 - Merry
5 - Legolas
5 - Thorin
5 - Balin
5 - Elrond
5 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
5 - Aragorn
5 - Boromir
5 - Gandalf
5 - Radagast
5 - Saruman
5 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
5 - Wormtongue
5 - Theoden
5 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
5 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
5 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
5 - Smaug
5 - Balrog
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin

[Skyblade]

Books or movies? Because that definitely changes some of the characters and my opinions of them. I guess since you included Melkor, it would be books.

+2 to Eowyn, and -2 to Azog.

Also, shouldn't this be Wonder Square, since it's a game?

[fire_of_avalon]

+2 to Sam -2 to Balrog, moving thread to Wondersquare

[Laddy]

+2 Aragorn
-2 Radagast

No Tom Bombadil?

[Jinx]

++Eowyn
--Wormtongue

Interesting note: if you look at spell check for Wormtongue on Google Chrome, the only suggest is 'Rumormonger'. That's actually kind of cool.

[Agent Proto]

It would be easier if you guys included the listed with the addition and subtractions along with your votes to keep track. :D

5 - Bilbo
5 - Frodo
5 - Pippin
7 - Sam
5 - Merry
5 - Legolas
5 - Thorin
5 - Balin
5 - Elrond
5 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
5 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Radagast
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
3 - Wormtongue
5 - Theoden
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
5 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
5 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
5 - Smaug
3 - Balrog
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin

Gandalf +2, Sarumon -2, btw

[Elskidor]

5 - Bilbo
5 - Frodo
5 - Pippin
7 - Sam
5 - Merry
5 - Legolas
5 - Thorin
7 - Balin
5 - Elrond
5 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
5 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Radagast
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
3 - Wormtongue
3 - Theoden
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
5 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
5 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
5 - Smaug
3 - Balrog
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
5- Tom Bombadil

++ Balin
-- Theo


Books or Movies..whichever character you liked the presentation of better, I suppose. Tom Added. If you want I can add more characters within the next day or so, as long as it's not days upon days into the game.

[fire_of_avalon]

Maybe you should do it tournament style? Like NCAA tournament style. I dunno, I like this way! I also want to say I am so glad there are Eowyn fans because she and Sam are my favorites but Sam is just slightly more my favorite.

[Jinx]

Maybe you should do it tournament style? Like NCAA tournament style. I dunno, I like this way! I also want to say I am so glad there are Eowyn fans because she and Sam are my favorites but Sam is just slightly more my favorite.

I thought you were saying I'm your favorite. Then I got sad. :(

5 - Bilbo
5 - Frodo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
5 - Merry
5 - Legolas
5 - Thorin
7 - Balin
5 - Elrond
5 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
5 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Radagast
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
1 - Wormtongue
3 - Theoden
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
5 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
5 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
5 - Smaug
3 - Balrog
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
5- Tom Bombadil

++Pippin
--Wormtongue

[Loony BoB]

-- Legolas
++ Gollum

Not posting the numbers because if more than one person tries to track it then it can get incorrect very fast, as I've learned in past versions of these threads. :p

[Psychotic]

++Boromir
--Melkor, CHILDREN OF HURIN FUCK YOU MELKOR :colbert:

[Shorty]

++Smaug
--Eowyn

Who took points from the Balrog! He is a total badass!

[fire_of_avalon]

I TOOK POINTS FROM BALROG. YOU WANT TO FIGHT ME?

[Shorty]

You fight the Balrog when you take points from the Balrog :colbert:

[Elskidor]

5 - Bilbo
5 - Frodo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
3 - Merry
3 - Legolas
7 - Thorin
7 - Balin
5 - Elrond
7 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
7 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Radagast
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
1 - Wormtongue
3 - Theoden
7 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
5 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
7 - Smaug
3 - Balrog
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
5- Tom Bombadil

++ Thorin
-- Merry

[Jinx]

5 - Bilbo
5 - Frodo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
3 - Merry
3 - Legolas
7 - Thorin
7 - Balin
5 - Elrond
7 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
7 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Radagast
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
3 - Theoden
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
5 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
7 - Smaug
3 - Balrog
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
5- Tom Bombadil

++Eowyn
--Wormtongue

[Loony BoB]

5 - Bilbo
5 - Frodo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
5 - Merry
1 - Legolas
7 - Thorin
7 - Balin
5 - Elrond
7 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
7 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Radagast
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
3 - Theoden
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
5 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
7 - Smaug
3 - Balrog
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
5- Tom Bombadil

++Merry
--Legolas

[Elskidor]

5 - Bilbo
5 - Frodo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
5 - Merry
7 - Thorin
7 - Balin
5 - Elrond
7 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Radagast
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
2 - Theoden
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
5 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
7 - Smaug
3 - Balrog
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
5- Tom Bombadil

++ Boromir
-Legolas (Gone) -Theoden

[Jinx]

5 - Bilbo
3 - Frodo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
5 - Merry
7 - Thorin
7 - Balin
5 - Elrond
7 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Radagast
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
2 - Theoden
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
7 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
7 - Smaug
3 - Balrog
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
5- Tom Bombadil

++ Faramir
--Frodo

[Loony BoB]

++ Gimli
-- Frodo

5 - Bilbo
1 - Frodo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
5 - Merry
7 - Thorin
7 - Balin
5 - Elrond
7 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Radagast
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
2 - Theoden
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
7 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
7 - Smaug
3 - Balrog
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
5 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Tom Bombadil
-- Sarah Balrog

[Agent Proto]

5 - Bilbo
3 - Frodo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
5 - Merry
7 - Thorin
7 - Balin
5 - Elrond
7 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Radagast
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
7 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
7 - Smaug
3 - Balrog
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
5 - Tom Bombadil
+2 Frodo, -2 Theoden (bye bye)

[Jinx]

Why do y'all hate Theoden? :(

[fire_of_avalon]

You fight the Balrog when you take points from the Balrog :colbert:
I make the Balrog look like a frolicking baby goat.

[Shorty]

He just wants to be loved, foaface!

QUIN I THOUGHT WE WERE FRIENDS

++Smaug, --Radagast

[Elskidor]

5 - Bilbo
3 - Frodo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
5 - Merry
7 - Thorin
9 - Balin
5 - Elrond
7 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf

3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
7 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
9 - Smaug

5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

++Balin
-Ragagast-Balrog

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Frodo

5 - Bilbo
1 - Frodo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
5 - Merry
7 - Thorin
9 - Balin
5 - Elrond
7 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
5 - Galadriel
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
9 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
9 - Smaug
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

+Gollum +Merry
- Frodo (bye bye) -Galadriel

5 - Bilbo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
6 - Merry
7 - Thorin
9 - Balin
5 - Elrond
8 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
4 - Galadriel
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
9 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
9 - Smaug
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

*highfives BoB*

[Elskidor]

Why do y'all hate Theoden? :(

I like Theoden, just not as much as many other characters, and I don't wanna step on the toes of Eowyn fans or I probably would have began chipping a way on her life span before Theoden.

[Jinx]

To be fair, I don't think there's really any characters in LotR that I really actively dislike, except for maybe Frodo. Just some I like less than others. Theoden is a favorite of mine, though. But then...they all are! :3

[Loony BoB]

+Gollum +Merry
-- Galadriel

5 - Bilbo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
9 - Balin
5 - Elrond
9 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog
2 - Galadriel
9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
9 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
9 - Smaug
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Thorin
-- Galadriel

5 - Bilbo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
9 - Thorin
9 - Balin
5 - Elrond
9 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
3 - Saruman
3 - Azog

9 - Eowyn
5 - Eomer
9 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
9 - Smaug
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Eomer

5 - Bilbo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
9 - Thorin
9 - Balin
5 - Elrond
9 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
1 - Saruman
3 - Azog
2 - Galadriel
9 - Eowyn
3 - Eomer
11 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
9 - Smaug
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Shorty]

++ Smaug, -- Eomer

[Jinx]

-- Eomer

yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeah

The only reason I liked his character was because Karl Urban.

[Shorty]

Blech. I dislike both he and Eowyn.

[Elskidor]

++ Thorin
--Galad

5 - Bilbo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
11 - Thorin
9 - Balin
5 - Elrond
9 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
1 - Saruman
3 - Azog
9 - Eowyn
1 - Eomer
11 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
11 - Smaug
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++ Faramir
-Eomer (buh bye), -Smaug

5 - Bilbo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
11 - Thorin
9 - Balin
5 - Elrond
9 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
1 - Saruman
3 - Azog
9 - Eowyn
13 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
5 - Nazgul
10 - Smaug
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Balin
-- Nazgul

5 - Bilbo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
11 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
9 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
1 - Saruman
3 - Azog
9 - Eowyn
13 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
3 - Nazgul
10 - Smaug
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Smaug
++ Balin
-- Nazgul

5 - Bilbo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
11 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
9 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
7 - Gandalf
1 - Saruman
3 - Azog
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
3 - Melkor
3 - Nazgul
8 - Smaug
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Shorty]

++Smaug, --Melkor

https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/7914255/Lucky%20Pumpkins%20(2013)/lp_jrgiw.png

[Freya]

I found it but I think i'ma let aanother claim it

[Shorty]

Claimed by Aulayna! (http://home.eyesonff.com/general-chat/152542-lucky-pumpkins-2013-a-3.html#post3323390)

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Nazgul

5 - Bilbo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
11 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
9 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
9 - Gandalf
1 - Saruman
5 - Azog
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
1 - Melkor
1 - Nazgul
10 - Smaug
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Smaug

5 - Bilbo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
11 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
9 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
9 - Gandalf
1 - Saruman
5 - Azog
9 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
1 - Melkor
1 - Nazgul
8 - Smaug
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

I'm not sure how Azog went from 3 to 5 based on previous posts so I'm going to deduct him back down to 3 before doing this...

++ Gollum
- Nazgul (bye bye) - Azog

5 - Bilbo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
11 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
11 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
9 - Gandalf
1 - Saruman
2 - Azog
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
1 - Melkor
10 - Smaug
5 - Fili
5 - Kili
5 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Shorty]

++Aragon
--Dwalin

[Elskidor]

Azog was my fault. Ooops. I was going to add to him before changing my mind and going for Gandalf, and I forgot to change it back.

++ Gandalf
-- Fili

5 - Bilbo
7 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
11 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
11 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
1 - Saruman
2 - Azog
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
5 - Sauron
1 - Melkor
10 - Smaug
3 - Fili
5 - Kili
3 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Raine]

How could you say bye to the Nazgûl :x

++ Pippin
- Saruman (byeeee) - Sauron (going very stereotypical here)

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
11 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
11 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
2 - Azog
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
4- Sauron
1 - Melkor
10 - Smaug
3 - Fili
5 - Kili
3 - Dwalin
7 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

More efficient way to do it is to edit the original post and have that as the baseline from which everybody else plays.

++ Tom Bombadil
-- Azog (YOU DIED)

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
11 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
11 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
4- Sauron
1 - Melkor
10 - Smaug
3 - Fili
5 - Kili
3 - Dwalin
9 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

I blame Loony BoB--Smaug is only supposed to have 8, not 10! I took him down two points yesterday! So, I corrected that.

++Faramir
--Thorin

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
9 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
11 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
9 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
9 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
4- Sauron
1 - Melkor
8 - Smaug
3 - Fili
5 - Kili
3 - Dwalin
9 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Boromir
--Faramir


5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
9 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
11 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
4- Sauron
1 - Melkor
8 - Smaug
3 - Fili
5 - Kili
3 - Dwalin
9 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++Gollum
--Dwalin

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
9 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
13 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
4 - Sauron
1 - Melkor
8 - Smaug
3 - Fili
5 - Kili
1 - Dwalin
9 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Tom Bombadil
- Melkor [First, he died.]
- Dwalin [Now, he dead.]

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
9 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
13 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
4 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
3 - Fili
5 - Kili
11 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Thorin

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
13 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
9 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
4 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
3 - Fili
5 - Kili
11 - Tom Bombadil

[Grim Reaper]

++ Tom Bombadil
- Melkor [First, he died.]
- Dwalin [Now, he dead.]


5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
9 - Thorin
11 - Balin
5 - Elrond
13 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
4 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
3 - Fili
5 - Kili
11 - Tom Bombadil

Zing.

[Elskidor]

++Balin
--Faramir

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
5 - Elrond
13 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
4 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
3 - Fili
5 - Kili
11 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Fili

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
5 - Elrond
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
4 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
1 - Fili
5 - Kili
11 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Tom
- Fili [This was a triumph...]
- Sauron

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
5 - Elrond
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
9 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
5 - Kili
13 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Kili

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
5 - Elrond
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
11 - Gandalf
9 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
3- Kili
13 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Eowyn

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
5 - Elrond
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
13 - Gandalf
7 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
3- Kili
13 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Kili

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
5 - Elrond
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
13 - Gandalf
7 - Eowyn
19 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
1 - Kili
13 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++Gollum
- Kili (bye)
- Elrond

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
4 - Elrond
17 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
13 - Gandalf
7 - Eowyn
19 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
13 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Tom Bombadil
-- Gollum

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
4 - Elrond
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
11 - Boromir
13 - Gandalf
7 - Eowyn
19 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
15 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Boromir
-- Faramir

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
4 - Elrond
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
13 - Boromir
13 - Gandalf
7 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
15 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Tom Bombadil
-- Elrond

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
2 - Elrond
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
13 - Boromir
13 - Gandalf
7 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Tom Bombadil

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
2 - Elrond
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
13 - Boromir
13 - Gandalf
7 - Eowyn
19 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
15 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Eowyn

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
2 - Elrond
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
13 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
5 - Eowyn
19 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
15 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Tom Bombadil

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
2 - Elrond
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
13 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
5 - Eowyn
19 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
13 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Tom Bombadil
-- Faramir
-- Jinx
-- Jinx
-- Jinx

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
2 - Elrond
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
13 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
5 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
15 - Tom Bombadil
-6 - Jinx

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Tom Bombadil
-- Elrond [SENT BACK FROM WHENCE HE CAME]

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
13 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
5 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Boro
-- Eowyn

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
15 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
15 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
3 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
3 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

Re: -6 Jinx post. Faramir was amazing in the books and awful in the movies. I'm torn on how to vote for him. :(

++ Gimli
-- Sauron

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
15 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
15 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
3 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
1 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Shaibana]

am i suppose to copy and paste the list? becaus i am afraid that is going t be confusing if some1 reacts on this post the same time..

danm, you killed Kili :(

but anyway:
++ Merry
-- faramir


5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
9 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
15 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
15 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
3 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
1 - Sauron
8 - Smaug
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

I'm voting based purely on books. Considering the existence of Tom, a book only character, it would be unfair to do otherwise, I feel. I only downvoted Faramir out of spite. He's always been one of my favourite characters. xD

++ Tom Bombadil
- Eowyn
- Sauron [Name change to Isildur, plz.]

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
9 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
15 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
15 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
2 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
8 - Smaug
19 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

Sorry, Quinny. You know I must. :3

++Faramir
--TomBo

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
9 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
15 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
15 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
2 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
8 - Smaug
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

What the hell is up with all you people colouring in every line. :stare:

++ Gollum
-- Sam

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
17 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
15 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
2 - Eowyn
17 - Faramir
8 - Smaug
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

What the hell is up with all you people colouring in every line. :stare:


Uh...

++Faramir
--TomBo


5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
17 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
15 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
2 - Eowyn
19 - Faramir
8 - Smaug
15 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Tom Bombadil
-- Faramir

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
17 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
15 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
17 - Faramir
2 - Eowyn
8 - Smaug
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

Yeah, Faramir in the books was much better. I was not a fan of him in the movie. Opposite for Throin..I think PJ has fleshed him out 100% more likable of a character. I thought he was an ass in the book..and a wee bit cowardly for a king.

++ Gandalf
-- Eowyn

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
17 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
15 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
17 - Faramir
8 - Smaug
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

Lol, Quin adds 4 points to TomBo and you subtract 2 from someone who's already gone. xD

[Quindiana Jones]

My bad. Changed my vote to even it all out again. xD

[Elskidor]

I'm so confused. Is everything as it should be?

[Loony BoB]

It is now that I edited your post to fix Tom & Faramir to 17 as per Quin's adjusted votes. Just a lot of people replying at once, that's all. :)

[Jinx]

I'm so confused. Is everything as it should be?

You get two subtraction votes!

[Elskidor]

Ok, well that's good, lol.

[Psychotic]

++Boromir
--Smaug

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
7 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
17 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
17 - Faramir
6 - Smaug
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Shaibana]

++ Thorin
-- sam


5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
5 - Sam
7 - Merry
9 - Thorin
13 - Balin
17 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
17 - Faramir
6 - Smaug
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ TB
-- Smaug

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
5 - Sam
7 - Merry
9 - Thorin
13 - Balin
17 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
17 - Faramir
4 - Smaug
19 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Smaug

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
5 - Sam
7 - Merry
9 - Thorin
13 - Balin
19 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
17 - Faramir
2 - Smaug
19 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Smaug (back to the fiery chasm from whence you came!)

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
5 - Sam
7 - Merry
9 - Thorin
13 - Balin
19 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
19 - Faramir
19 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Thorin
-- Merry

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
5 - Sam
5 - Merry
11 - Thorin
13 - Balin
19 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
19 - Faramir
19 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Tom Bom-Bombadil
-- Bilbo

3 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
5 - Sam
5 - Merry
11 - Thorin
13 - Balin
19 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
19 - Faramir
21 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Sam

3 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
3 - Sam
5 - Merry
11 - Thorin
13 - Balin
21 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
19 - Faramir
21 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Ballin

3 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
3 - Sam
5 - Merry
11 - Thorin
11 - Balin
21 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
21 - Faramir
21 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Thorin
-- Sam

3 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
1 - Sam
5 - Merry
13 - Thorin
11 - Balin
21 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
21 - Faramir
21 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ TB (Tifa's Boobs?)
- Bilbo
- Sam [Boil him, mash him, stick him in a stew]

2 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
5 - Merry
13 - Thorin
11 - Balin
21 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
21 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Aragorn

2 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
5 - Merry
13 - Thorin
11 - Balin
23 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
21 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Thorin
-- Merry

2 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
15 - Thorin
11 - Balin
23 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
21 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Balin

2 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
15 - Thorin
9 - Balin
23 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
17 - Gandalf
23 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Merry

2 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
1 - Merry
15 - Thorin
9 - Balin
23 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
19 - Gandalf
23 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Shaibana]

++ Merry
-- tom Bombadil

2 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
15 - Thorin
9 - Balin
23 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
19 - Gandalf
23 - Faramir
21 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Balin

2 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
15 - Thorin
7 - Balin
23 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
19 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir
21 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ TB
-- Bilbo [Off to sea.]

9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
15 - Thorin
7 - Balin
23 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
19 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Balin

9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
15 - Thorin
5 - Balin
23 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
19 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++Gandalf
--Gimli

9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
15 - Thorin
5 - Balin
23 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
17 - Boromir
21 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Psychotic]

++Boromir
--Tom Bombadil (making hobbits get naked and cavort for his amusement. Shame on him :colbert:)

9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
15 - Thorin
5 - Balin
23 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
21 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir
21 - Tom Bombadil

[Shaibana]

-- faramir
++ Thorin

9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
17 - Thorin
5 - Balin
23 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
21 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir
21 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Tom Bombadil [Being an eternal being with ultimate authority over his own domain that supercedes the main antagonist of the story; Priceless.]
-- Balin

9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
17 - Thorin
3 - Balin
23 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
21 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Balin

9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
17 - Thorin
1 - Balin
23 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
7 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
21 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++Gollum
--Aragorn

9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
17 - Thorin
1 - Balin
25 - Gollum
7 - Gimli
5 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
21 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Gimli

9 - Pippin
3 - Merry
17 - Thorin
1 - Balin
25 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
5 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
23 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Tom Bombadil
- Balin [So much for a rrroyal welcome.]
- Merry

9 - Pippin
2 - Merry
17 - Thorin
25 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
5 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
23 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir
25 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Aragorn

9 - Pippin
2 - Merry
17 - Thorin
27 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
3 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
23 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir
25 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Thorin

9 - Pippin
2 - Merry
15 - Thorin
27 - Gollum
5 - Gimli
3 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
23 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir
25 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Thorin
-- Gimli

9 - Pippin
2 - Merry
17 - Thorin
27 - Gollum
3 - Gimli
3 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
23 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir
25 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Tom Bombadil
-- Merry [I don't remember enough about him to create a suitable comment. :|]

9 - Pippin
17 - Thorin
27 - Gollum
3 - Gimli
3 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
23 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir
27 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Gimli

9 - Pippin
17 - Thorin
27 - Gollum
1 - Gimli
3 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
25 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir
27 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Aragorn

9 - Pippin
17 - Thorin
29 - Gollum
1 - Gimli
1 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
25 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir
27 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Thorin

9 - Pippin
15 - Thorin
29 - Gollum
1 - Gimli
1 - Aragorn
19 - Boromir
25 - Gandalf
29 - Faramir
27 - Tom Bombadil

[Shaibana]

ill just put them out of their missery. OFF WITH THEIR HEADS!

- gimli
- aragorn
++ pippin


11 - Pippin
15 - Thorin
29 - Gollum
19 - Boromir
25 - Gandalf
29 - Faramir
27 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

We're basically heading towards the finals now. :smash:

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Thorin

11 - Pippin
13 - Thorin
29 - Gollum
19 - Boromir
25 - Gandalf
31 - Faramir
27 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

Yeah, basically the battle of the last few.

++ Gandalf
-- Faramir

11 - Pippin
13 - Thorin
29 - Gollum
19 - Boromir
27 - Gandalf
29 - Faramir
27 - Tom Bombadil

[Shaibana]

+ Thorin
+ Pippin
-- tom Bombadil

12 - Pippin
14 - Thorin
29 - Gollum
19 - Boromir
27 - Gandalf
29 - Faramir
25 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Thorin

12 - Pippin
12 - Thorin
31 - Gollum
19 - Boromir
27 - Gandalf
29 - Faramir
25 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

Minor adjustment, someone got double points removed accidentaly it appears.

12 - Pippin
12 - Thorin
31 - Gollum
19 - Boromir
27 - Gandalf
29 - Faramir
25 - Tom Bombadil

[Shaibana]

yeah sure.. accidently :P haha

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Faramir

12 - Pippin
12 - Thorin
31 - Gollum
19 - Boromir
29 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir
25 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Thorin
--Elskidor

12 - Pippin
10 - Thorin
31 - Gollum
19 - Boromir
29 - Gandalf
29 - Faramir
25 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++Gollum
--Thorin

12 - Pippin
8 - Thorin
33 - Gollum
19 - Boromir
29 - Gandalf
29 - Faramir
25 - Tom Bombadil

[Shaibana]

++ Thorin
-- Tom bombadil

12 - Pippin
10 - Thorin
33 - Gollum
19 - Boromir
29 - Gandalf
29 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Faramir

12 - Pippin
10 - Thorin
33 - Gollum
19 - Boromir
31 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Hollycat]

++Gandalf
--Boromir

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
--Thorin

12 - Pippin
8 - Thorin
35 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
33 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Thorin

12 - Pippin
6 - Thorin
35 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
33 - Gandalf
29 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Thorin

12 - Pippin
4 - Thorin
35 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
33 - Gandalf
31 - Faramir
23 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
--Tom

12 - Pippin
4 - Thorin
35 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
35 - Gandalf
31 - Faramir
21 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
--Tom

12 - Pippin
4 - Thorin
35 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
37 - Gandalf
31 - Faramir
19 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Thorin

12 - Pippin
2 - Thorin
37 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
37 - Gandalf
31 - Faramir
19 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Thorin [Bye bye!]

12 - Pippin
37 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
37 - Gandalf
33 - Faramir
19 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Pippin

10 - Pippin
39 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
37 - Gandalf
33 - Faramir
19 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Pippin

08 - Pippin
39 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
39 - Gandalf
33 - Faramir
19 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--TomBo

8 - Pippin
39 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
39 - Gandalf
35 - Faramir
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Shaibana]

++ pippin
-- tom

10 - Pippin
39 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
39 - Gandalf
35 - Faramir
15 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++Gndalf
--Pip

6 - Pippin
39 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
41 - Gandalf
35 - Faramir
17 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--TomBo


6 - Pippin
39 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
41 - Gandalf
37 - Faramir
15 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Pippin

4 - Pippin
41 - Gollum
17 - Boromir
41 - Gandalf
37 - Faramir
15 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

TomBo just couldn't keep up without my support. Shame nobody except me loves him. Poor Lumpy. :(

++ Faramir
-- Boromir

4 - Pippin
41 - Gollum
15 - Boromir
41 - Gandalf
39 - Faramir
15 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

To keep solidarity with Quin :heart: (He was my next on the list, anways)

++Faramir
--Boromir

4 - Pippin
41 - Gollum
13 - Boromir
41 - Gandalf
41 - Faramir
15 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++Gollum
--Pippin

2 - Pippin
43 - Gollum
13 - Boromir
41 - Gandalf
41 - Faramir
15 - Tom Bombadil

I actually really like Tom, but I just really like Gollum that little more. Would be happy with a Gollum vs. Tom final!

[Quindiana Jones]

Literally any of the top five could win, and I would have no problem. All excellent characters.

Pippin for sudden surprise victory, though. :up:

[Loony BoB]

Always liked Merry that little bit better, but really they need each other to really shine.

[Elskidor]

I have not really sat down and thought who my top 3 characters would be. It use to be Gandalf, Gollum and Galadriel I think. But Galadriel and the other Elves have such a big issue with not being able to show emotion well that she never returned me that love, so I just had to quit her. I'm ready to see Desolation of Smaug...like yesterday!

++ Gandalf
--Pippin


43 - Gollum
13 - Boromir
43 - Gandalf
41 - Faramir
15 - Tom Bombadil

[Shaibana]

you killed pippin :(

- gollum
-Tom
++ gandalf

42 - Gollum
13 - Boromir
45 - Gandalf
41 - Faramir
14 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Tom

42 - Gollum
13 - Boromir
47 - Gandalf
41 - Faramir
12 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Boromir

42 - Gollum
11 - Boromir
47 - Gandalf
43 - Faramir
12 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
--Bombadil

42 - Gollum
11 - Boromir
49 - Gandalf
43 - Faramir
10 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Boromir


42 - Gollum
9 - Boromir
49 - Gandalf
45 - Faramir
10 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++Gollum
--Faramir

44 - Gollum
9 - Boromir
49 - Gandalf
43 - Faramir
10 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
-Gandalf
-Boromir

44 - Gollum
8 - Boromir
48 - Gandalf
45 - Faramir
10 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Tom

44 - Gollum
8 - Boromir
52 - Gandalf
45 - Faramir
2 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

Elskidor, I corrected Gandalf's number. You added 4 instead of 2.

44 - Gollum
8 - Boromir
50 - Gandalf
45 - Faramir
2 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

lol thanks...and by the looks of it Tom got subtracted by 8.


44 - Gollum
8 - Boromir
50 - Gandalf
45 - Faramir
8 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
-Boromir
-Gandalf

44 - Gollum
7 - Boromir
49 - Gandalf
47 - Faramir
8 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

This is like Sophie's Choice. :(

++ Gollum
-- Faramir

46 - Gollum
7 - Boromir
49 - Gandalf
45 - Faramir
8 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

You might want to update your list again, BoB. Seems we posted at the same time. :)

[Loony BoB]

Fixed!

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Tom

46 - Gollum
7 - Boromir
51 - Gandalf
45 - Faramir
6 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Tom

46 - Gollum
7 - Boromir
53 - Gandalf
45 - Faramir
4 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
-Boromir
-Gandalf

46 - Gollum
6 - Boromir
52 - Gandalf
47 - Faramir
4 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++Gollum
--Faramir

48 - Gollum
6 - Boromir
52 - Gandalf
45 - Faramir
4 - Tom Bombadil

[Quindiana Jones]

Hell no is Tom going out before Boromir. :colbert:

48 - Gollum
4 - Boromir
52 - Gandalf
45 - Faramir
6 - Tom Bombadil

[Night Fury]

++ Gandalf
-- Boromir

48 - Gollum
2- Boromir
54 - Gandalf
45 - Faramir
6 - Tom Bombadil

[Shaibana]

+ faramir
+ gandalf
-- gollum

46 - Gollum
2- Boromir
55 - Gandalf
46 - Faramir
6 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Gandalf

46 - Gollum
2- Boromir
53 - Gandalf
48 - Faramir
6 - Tom Bombadil

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Faramir

48 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
53 - Gandalf
46 - Faramir
6 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Tom

48 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
55 - Gandalf
46 - Faramir
4 - Tom Bombadil

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Tom

48 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
57 - Gandalf
46 - Faramir
2 - Tom Bombadil

[Jinx]

I am on my phone, so the person after me will have to do my adding and subtracting. Sorry! :shobon:

++Faramir
--Gandalf

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Faramir
-- Tom Bombadil [NONE OF YOU DESERVE THIS :mad2:]

48 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
55 - Gandalf
48 - Faramir

[Loony BoB]

++Gollum
--Faramir

50 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
55 - Gandalf
46 - Faramir

[Shaibana]

--Gollum
++ Gandalf

48 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
57 - Gandalf
46 - Faramir

[Jinx]

QUIN. YOU DROPPED THE BALL. I ASKED THE NEXT PERSON TO ADD IN THE TOTALS I PUT YESTERDAY. WHICH MEANS THAT FARAMIR SHOUL'VE BEEN AT 50 WITH YOU. I adjusted and added two extra points to Faramir, as well as the two from today's vote.

++Faramir
--Gandalf

48 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
55 - Gandalf
50 - Faramir

[Elskidor]

--Faramir
++Gandalf

48 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
57 - Gandalf
48 - Faramir

[Elskidor]

--Faramir
++Gandalf

48 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
59 - Gandalf
46 - Faramir

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Gandalf

48 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
57 - Gandalf
48 - Faramir

[Loony BoB]

++Gollum
--Gandalf

50 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
55 - Gandalf
48 - Faramir

[Elskidor]

-- Fara
++Gandalf

50 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
57 - Gandalf
46 - Faramir

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Gandalf

50 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
55 - Gandalf
48 - Faramir

[Loony BoB]

++Gollum
--Gandalf

52 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
53 - Gandalf
48 - Faramir

[Elskidor]

-- Fara
++Gandalf

52 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
55 - Gandalf
46 - Faramir

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Gandalf

52 - Gollum
2 - Boromir
53 - Gandalf
48 - Faramir

[Quindiana Jones]

I'm gonna go ahead and increase my kill count further. :D

++ Faramir
-- Boromir [SUCK IT DENETHOR.]

52 - Gollum
53 - Gandalf
50 - Faramir

[Loony BoB]

Elski, it may be worth doing that GRAVIJA thing again. xD

++ Gollum
-- Gandalf

54 - Gollum
51 - Gandalf
50 - Faramir

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Gandalf

54 - Gollum
49 - Gandalf
52 - Faramir

[Elskidor]

--Faramir
++Gandalf

27 - Gollum
26 - Gandalf
24 - Faramir

[Elskidor]

Alrighty, I split them down the middle.

[Loony BoB]

:up:

[Elskidor]

There is also a Final Fantasy Elimination game going on if anyone wants to join in. It had a stronger start, but the participation died off quicker. If you wanna join it's here http://home.eyesonff.com/general-final-fantasy/152472-final-fantasy-elimination-game.html , if not I may try to bump it up in a month or so.

[Shaibana]

-- gollum
+ gandalf
+ faramir

25 - Gollum
27 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Faramir
-- Gandalf

25 - Gollum
25 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Gandalf

27 - Gollum
23 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Gandalf


27 - Gollum
21 - Gandalf
29 - Faramir

[Elskidor]

--Faramir
++Gandalf


27 - Gollum
23 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Faramir

29 - Gollum
23 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir

[Elskidor]

++ Gandalf
-- Faramir

29 - Gollum
25 - Gandalf
23 - Faramir

[Denmark]

++ Faramir
-- Gandalf

29 - Gollum
23 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir

[Loony BoB]

++ Gollum
-- Faramir

31 - Gollum
23 - Gandalf
23 - Faramir

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Gollum


29 - Gollum
23 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir

[Quindiana Jones]

++ Faramir
-- Gollum

27 - Gollum
23 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir

[Jinx]

This is a real nail-biter, guys.

[Elskidor]

-- Faramir
++ Gandalf

27 - Gollum
25 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir

[Elskidor]

This is a real nail-biter, guys.


Yeah, well we have the top three. Once it gets down to that I've seen these types of games go on forever and ever until people just get tired of voting or newcomers join in.

[Elskidor]

-- Faramir
++ Gandalf

27 - Gollum
27 - Gandalf
23 - Faramir

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Gandalf

27 - Gollum
25 - Gandalf
25 - Faramir

[Jinx]

++Faramir
--Gollum

25 - Gollum
25 - Gandalf
27 - Faramir


...guys, I think we should call it a good game and just call these guys our winners. We're getting nowhere. xD

[Elskidor]

That works for me if it works for y'all.

[Jinx]

I'm okay with it. It just seems like we'll be going around in circles forever...xD

[Elskidor]

Ok then good game, lol. Post pictures of winners or something and celebrate? I dunno, but I am glad people participated. That was kinda cool that it actually made it nearly 2 months. Congrats to the winners, and so long and farewell to the fallen, and thanks!

[Shaibana]

Lol idd, this is going to take on for ages :P

[Quindiana Jones]

How many people did I kill off in total?

BoB; spreadsheet?