PDA

View Full Version : The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Review



Ayen
12-09-2013, 03:27 PM
48935


First it was a book by J. R. R. Tolkien, then it was a cartoon, then it was blockbuster motion picture the likes the world has never seen and then it was a video game! And since we have the Hobbit The Desolation of Smaug to look forward to this Friday I thought now would be the perfect time to look at The Lord of the Rings game developed by Stormfront Studios and Hypnos Entertainment and published by EA Games for the PlayStation 2, Xbox, Gamecube and Game Boy Advance. Today I'll be looking at the PS2 port of the game.

The game takes scenes from the Fellowship of the Ring movie and then leads into events from the second movie that came out the same year. It starts right off with the opening monologue from the first film and transitions into the gameplay taking you right into it. If you want to set your options or go to the main title screen you'll have to pause the game and make your choices from there. Since the game wastes no time throwing you to the orks let's go over the controls.

Controls: Press square to defend! Chances are you're going to be raping the square button before long. X is a quick attack, triangle performs a more powerful attack with the intent of breaking enemy shields and circle lets you kick orks in the face.

R1 activates your ranged weapon and using the X button fires it. R2 lets your character jump back to get away from the enemy and L2 is a killing blow you can unleash to finish off your opponent. L1 is also another button you can use to parry attacks. You can move with either the D-Pad or the Analog Sticks.

The game starts off at the beginning of the first movie during the final battle against Sauron on Mount Doom in Mordor where you take control of Prince Isildur. On the second stage you take control of his heir, Aragorn armed with nothing but a sword and a torch protecting Frodo against the Nazgūl (black cloaked figures working for Sauron). It's not until the third level you get your choice of Aragorn, Legolas or Gimli. Each character has their weapons of choice, style and a level that is raised through experience point gain through fighting in each stage to buy new upgrades to help you on your journey. So it's kind of like an RPG, except not really.

Aside from their archive footage from the movies, Viggo Mortensen (Aragorn), John Rhys- Davies (Gimli), Orlando Bloom (Legolas), Elijah Wood (Frodo), and Ian McKellen (Gandalf) all reprise their roles for the game. We know they didn't have to considering they're big movie stars and they're probably already making millions off the movies on its own, but we love them all the more for it.

In case you couldn't figure it out yet the narrative follows our favorite Lord of the Rings trio through their journey from one to two with only a few of the other characters being seen during the earlier levels, Sam only presence being a voice and the other Hobbits not even being mentioned. Though you can also unlock Prince Isildur to play. Other than that not much else going on in term of main characters.

The game does a good job in following the events of the movies, which as far as I'm aware followed the books so everything is following everything else. Why am I taking the time to praise this? Because you'd be amazed at how many adaptions of other mediums into video games developers have gotten wrong over the years. The game begins with the battle of Mordor, introduces Aragorn to Frodo, forms the Fellowship and goes through the Caves of Moria, sees the Fellowship disbanded and eventually makes its end to Helm Deep getting progressively harder and harder with each stage. There is also some original content in the game that shows themselves in Plains of Rohan, Westfold and the Gap of Rohan level. The rest follows the movies with a few minor changes that are to be expected if you want to adapt a scene into a level.

The Skill Meter is where experience and upgrade points are gathered as you play. It reminds me a little bit of the Cool Meter in Devil May Cry. Ratings are set as Fair, Good, Excellent and Perfect. The higher the skill, the better the kill and the more points you earn as a result. This will also allow you to cause more damage to your enemies. To fill this up just avoid being hit and killing all those who stand in your way! You already know that's going to be easier said than done, unless you're a bawse. Then hats off to you.

Cons: The main drawback with this game is how it chooses to only follow the narrative of Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli instead of following any of the other characters and what they were doing at the same time. Something that they would come back and rectify with the release of Return of the King one year later. Another thing, that again they would rectify with the sequel, was the lack of a multiplayer mode. The only version of the game you could play with a friend was the Game Boy Advance version and that's a shame as they could have easily added a multiplayer to this even in the first two stages. Just add Elrond to the first stage and have the second player play Frodo in the second. There's no reason this game should be single-player, in some stages your traveling companions can be seen right there with you on screen.

Conclusion: If you're a hardcore fan of the movies and don't care for multiplayer, then I'd recommend the game. Overall it's not a bad action game and requires some amount of thought when picking which upgrade you want to continue on with. It stays true to the theme of the franchise, has the kickass music to go with it and a fair amount of stuff to unlock. Although the exclusive movie content isn't as much of a treat now since you can easily get all three movies if you haven't already. If not, it's still a fun action game and tells the story well enough for someone who hasn't seen or heard anything LOTR related to follow, but it's primarily a game for fans.

Final Score: 8/10

Elskidor
12-09-2013, 04:35 PM
I have owned this for years and years, but I have still never tried to play it and that's weird as a fan of action, games, fantasy and everything Tolkien related. I think this is the first time I've read a review or even heard anyone talk about this game. I guess I should give a try sometime, but I don't really like the sound of being stuck only in the narrative of Aragorn and company either though. It looks like it plays similar to Baldur's Gate or Champion's of Norrath, and I enjoy both of those games..Baldur's Gate more so.

Ayen
12-09-2013, 04:43 PM
You might be better off just skipping into Return of the King, then. Multiplayer, it follows everyone's narratives and after you complete the game you can repeat any stage with any character you wish.

That's funny, though. Considering it has a 'Best Action' sticker at the bottom right of my game case. Unless 'Publisher's Choice Awards' is any indication.

Jinx
12-09-2013, 04:44 PM
Or you can play The Third Age. Otherwise known as a good LotR video game.

Scotty_ffgamer
12-09-2013, 04:47 PM
I haven't read the review yet (don't have time before work), but I do want to say that I used to love playing The Two Towers on Gamecube. I would have friends over and we would play it pretty frequently. I enjoy Return of the King more, I think, but I don't have as many fond memories of it.

Also, I need to play The Third Age someday.

Ayen
12-09-2013, 05:06 PM
Or you can play The Third Age. Otherwise known as a good LotR video game.

Welcome to the third age (the third age) welcome to the third age (the third age)
Radioactive! Radioactive!

Never played.

Skyblade
12-09-2013, 05:13 PM
You might be better off just skipping into Return of the King, then. Multiplayer, it follows everyone's narratives and after you complete the game you can repeat any stage with any character you wish.

That's funny, though. Considering it has a 'Best Action' sticker at the bottom right of my game case. Unless 'Publisher's Choice Awards' is any indication.

Return of the King is, hands down, the better game. The mechanics are much more refined, there is multiplayer, there is a far larger incentive to replay (more characters, the ability to play through every missions with every character and do high-score chases for them all), and there are more features in general. You miss the first half of the story, but we all know the story anyway, don't we?

Pity it didn't have online multiplayer. I would love to kick orc butt with you guys.


Or you can play The Third Age. Otherwise known as a good LotR video game.

Eh... Yeah, I liked it, but it had its problems. The writing was a little on the ridiculous side (hey look, it's totally not-Gimli travelling with totally not-Aragorn). The combat was okay, but not great, and there were several systems that simply could have used more refinement.

Generally, I have more fun with Return of the King, and I am more likely to replay it.

Psychotic
12-09-2013, 05:32 PM
Oh Tori, I love you for reviewing this :love: I used to love the hell out of this when I was a teenager and played it all the time. I couldn't get enough. I think you've summed it up well - my main faults were multiplayer and the reduced cast, which RotK sorted out. It was bizarre having a five man fellowship - I would've loved to have been Boromir - and Isildur was just a reskin of Aragorn.

Another fault I could lay at its doors was lack of enemy variety. If I say to you "green orc with two axes" or "brownish orc with shield and helmet that covers most of his face" you will probably laugh and know exactly who I mean. I think RotK dealt with that well too.

Still, I had a blast wrecking everyone with Legolas and the "Bane" moves (counters) made me feel like such a badass too. The little snippets with the actors you could unlock were cool too.
Or you can play The Third Age. Otherwise known as a good LotR video game.Otherwise known as Final Fantasy X: LotR mod. You guys might not know this, but EA actually approached EoFF to promote TTA and even invited someone to go to an advance playthrough long before Square-Enix started doing it. Shlup even made a mini TTA spin off site on the back of it.

Either way, eh. Skyblade has it spot on - the characters were such rip offs of the main ones (hello Female Elf who loves a human, do you want to be friends with strong female Rohan fighter?) that you may as well have had the original characters and I don't know why they didn't. Unless they wanted to have an original story - which kind of falls flat when you think about it!

It was solid enough but I was disappointed I couldn't explore many places - exploring Helm's Deep was one of the things I enjoyed.

Having played what I believe to be every LotR movie spinoff game - TTT, RotK, Battle for Middle Earth I and II, The Third Age and Conquest, you may be surprised to know the actual best LotR game is... Lego Lord of the Rings. No word of a fucking lie. I absolutely loved it. It's full of whimsy and adventure. You have about 80 different characters you can play as and you can full on fucking free roam Middle-Earth. No word of a lie, you can literally walk from Bag End to Mount Doom. If they'd give it full on cinematic graphics and make the combat a bit more complex it would honestly be one of the best games ever.

Ayen
12-09-2013, 05:38 PM
Considering the Third Age is actually developed by EA and not just published by them none of that surprises me.

-not the biggest EA fan in the world-

Jinx
12-09-2013, 05:40 PM
Lego Lord of the Rings is fucking fantastic.

Elskidor
12-09-2013, 06:03 PM
From what I've seen and played of the Batman and Harry Potter Lego games I am not a fan. Sucks because my wife loves them, and wants to play them with me throughout Christmas break. I hope I start to get into them soon...

Ayen
12-09-2013, 06:19 PM
Not sure how I feel about the best LOTR game adaption being the lego adaption. Part of me wants to laugh, the other part just wants to cry.

Skyblade
12-09-2013, 06:39 PM
From what I've seen and played of the Batman and Harry Potter Lego games I am not a fan. Sucks because my wife loves them, and wants to play them with me throughout Christmas break. I hope I start to get into them soon...

I never played the Harry Potter version, and I have no intention of doing so (do not get me started on all the things wrong with Harry Potter), I did play LEGO Batman. It wasn't that good, definitely not among the tops of the LEGO series.

LEGO Lord of the Rings and LEGO Star Wars (specifically, LEGO Star Wars II: The Original Trilogy) are the two LEGO games that I really enjoyed. It's worth giving either of those games a try, if you can find a store doing a demo of it, or a friend who has it.

I'm also a big fan of Battle for Middle Earth (though I hate that BFME II took away unit combos), and War in the North (no mention of that one, Psy?) was pretty good too. Lord of the Rings online was gloriously atmospheric, but I think it was let down by its mechanics.