Do you buy Garnet/Dagger's Love for Zidane?

[The Fat Bioware Nerd]

I mean, do you think they sold it? "It," being Garnet and Zidane's love for each other.

[Ayen]

Yes. It's probably one of the better written love stories in the franchise.

[Moogles-Are-Awesome]

Totally

[Pumpkin]

Yep. It's one of my favourite FF romances

[Jinx]

I do. In any case, it's way better than Yuna and Tidus (which is a bad FF love story).

[Shiva95]

Yes. It came very naturally.

[Fynn]

Of course

[Midgar Mist]

It can be seen more clearly on his side, she's quieter about it so she can be hard to read. I guess its her Royal upbringing.

[Laddy]

Yes. They actually had conversations about stuff they were interested in and stuff. Y'know, the important things.

[blackmage_nuke]

I bought it until Dagger didn't pick up her damn jewelry in the end, that was overselling it a bit much.

[LovelessFirefly6]

Absolutely. The Ending of the game made me teary-eyed it was so cute. I love them together!

[Quindiana Jones]

I do. In any case, it's way better than Yuna and Tidus (which is a bad FF love story).

God damn. Talk about low standards for love! ;)

I find FFIX to have one of the most normal and natural love stories. It's fantastic.

[Loony BoB]

Yeah, they "sold" it well enough.

[Vincent, Thunder God]

FF 9 is one of those FFs I've never finished despite getting almost right to the end. And now whenever I replay it I can never get far enough to get close to finishing it. So I guess I'll have to reserve judgement until I get there, which will probably never happen. xD

[Cell]

Did I buy it?

Better than Yuna/Tidus?

HA HAAA HA HA HA HAAA HA HAHA HAAA HA HA HA HAAA HA HAHA HAAA HA HA HA HAAA HA HAHA HAAA HA HA HA HAAA HA HA

Yes. Yes, I did. It was very well written for an FF game, actually.

[maybee]

Yes ! Who doesn't ? People don't ?? :cry:

It's the best well- written Final Fantasy romance story within FF history.

It doesn't feel too sudden like Squall/ Rinoa, or teenage emotions gone wild like Yuna/ Tidus.

[Laddy]

I think what helps it is that both are pretty mature and good people when the story begins. They're introspective, they have established hobbies and interests, and they're overdramatic or prone to random bouts of selfishness. There's already an established sense of respect there when they meet, a casual flirtation and regard for others' well-being that later blooms into something more.

[Example]

I don't see why not. It's definitely one of the better written love stories in the franchise. It never feels forced and the two leads have actual chemistry between them, unlike Squall/Rinoa.

[Squall Leonhart Loire]

I don't see why not. It's definitely one of the better written love stories in the franchise. It never feels forced and the two leads have actual chemistry between them, unlike Squall/Rinoa.

There is not chemistry but it's sorcery!

[Example]

I don't see why not. It's definitely one of the better written love stories in the franchise. It never feels forced and the two leads have actual chemistry between them, unlike Squall/Rinoa.

There is not chemistry but it's sorcery!

Only if you believe a certain theory.

[Madame Adequate]

I buy it, I just don't really care about it, unlike Tidus x Yuna, which is one of the best romances in the series.

[Freya]

Yeah I think it developed form "hey cute princess" to oh I really like her!

[Jinx]

I buy it, I just don't really care about it, unlike Tidus x Yuna, which is one of the best romances in the series.

ew

[Peter1986]

I will say this:

the scene at the beginning of disc 3 when Zidane is starting to believe that he will never be able to meet Garnet again, and for this reason sits and looks bitter at a table at the bar in Alexandria and hardly pays any attention to anyone around him, felt extremely realistic.
This is very much like what a guy like Zidane would act in that situation in real life.

[daggertrepe]

Yes. It's realistic because she doesn't fall in love right away, but falls in love with who he is over time.

[Darth Ganon]

I will say this:

the scene at the beginning of disc 3 when Zidane is starting to believe that he will never be able to meet Garnet again, and for this reason sits and looks bitter at a table at the bar in Alexandria and hardly pays any attention to anyone around him, felt extremely realistic.
This is very much like what a guy like Zidane would act in that situation in real life.

Oh jeez, I forgot about that scene. I never thought I'd be able to relate to a Final Fantasy character before now.

[Krizzy]

I totally buy it! Zidane and Garnet are so adorable in every way, I bet Garnet never thought of falling in love with a petty thief. :lol:



I do. In any case, it's way better than Yuna and Tidus (which is a bad FF love story).

I think Squall and Rinoa's love story is worse, the problem with Tidus and Yuna's is that it lacks screen time and thus development. These 2 love stories are forced and unnatural.

[MJN SEIFER]

Off topic, but to those who said that Squall and Rinoa felt forced, I don't think they did other than the usual "just met, now in a love story" kind of thing, but all the Final Fantasies I've played do that - Cloud and Tifa are the only ones I know who knew each other before the game starts, and even they didn't actually "know" each other that well when they were "childhood friends". I always thought Squall and Rinoa looked like it developed over time, and was also about Squall being more open as well, which I thought took a decent amount of time, given what the game could do in its time limit. They just had a lot of chemistry for me, even when Squall was still saying "Whatever." every five minutes.

I haven't played as much of Final Fantasy X as I'd like, but I wouldn't be surprised if Tidus and Yuna actually are a good couple, but the voice acting messed up the chemistry to some. I don't find the voice acting bad, aside from the odd moment (Yuna's "I'm so sorry" sounding particularly bad, in my opinion), but rather poorly put together. I would be very surprised if I was to hear that the voice actors/actresses recorded their lines together, as most of the time they all sound so disjointed with each other, like their not even in the same conversation. That may have hindered Tidus and Yuna, but I'll see what I think when I see more of their romantic moments.

[Krizzy]

I always thought Squall and Rinoa looked like it developed over time, and was also about Squall being more open as well, which I thought took a decent amount of time, given what the game could do in its time limit. They just had a lot of chemistry for me, even when Squall was still saying "Whatever." every five minutes.



Squall saying "whatever" every 5 minutes or so is one of the reasons I dislike the love story between him and Rinoa. He seems uncaring, then suddenly caring for a certain girl...

I can't even look at a smiling Squall! :shifty:

Ok, maybe I should play this again, it's been 15 years anyway, let's see if my opinion will change.

[MJN SEIFER]

I always thought Squall and Rinoa looked like it developed over time, and was also about Squall being more open as well, which I thought took a decent amount of time, given what the game could do in its time limit. They just had a lot of chemistry for me, even when Squall was still saying "Whatever." every five minutes.



Squall saying "whatever" every 5 minutes or so is one of the reasons I dislike the love story between him and Rinoa. He seems uncaring, then suddenly caring for a certain girl...

I can't even look at a smiling Squall! :shifty:

Ok, maybe I should play this again, it's been 15 years anyway, let's see if my opinion will change. I will respect your opinion if it doesn't, but here's some advice; pay attention to everything, try to see as many Squall and Rinoa scenes as you can (i.e. put them in the same party as much as possible) and pay attention to Squall's thoughts - he cares a lot sooner than people think he does, in my opinion.

Again, I will respect your opinion either way.

[Wolf Kanno]

I can't even look at a smiling Squall! :shifty:


75013

[Krizzy]

I will respect your opinion if it doesn't, but here's some advice; pay attention to everything, try to see as many Squall and Rinoa scenes as you can (i.e. put them in the same party as much as possible) and pay attention to Squall's thoughts - he cares a lot sooner than people think he does, in my opinion.

Again, I will respect your opinion either way.

Thanks, I'll do so. I think my opinion of Squall has change since I saw him dance in "world of final fantasy" :p


@ Wolf Kanno (http://home.eyesonff.com/member.php/25655-Wolf-Kanno)

Thanks for the attachment, Squall looks so menacing there, despite the smile haha :lol:

[Cell]

It's much better written VII, VIII or X's.

[Black Magic Shopkeeper]

Even though VIII was my first Final Fantasy (and the one to set my standards for romantic tropes in the franchise), I think I like Zidane/Garnet more than Squall/Rinoa. I dunno, there's just something... classic about it.

[Krizzy]

Even though VIII was my first Final Fantasy (and the one to set my standards for romantic tropes in the franchise), I think I like Zidane/Garnet more than Squall/Rinoa. I dunno, there's just something... classic about it.

Same here, VIII is the first FF I have played but I also didn't get impressed with Squall and Rinoa's romance, maybe because she's a little too easy to get and he's a little too uncaring.

I find Zidane and Dagger's love story much more adorable, I remember printing many pictures of them back then :)

[Cell]

Even though VIII was my first Final Fantasy (and the one to set my standards for romantic tropes in the franchise), I think I like Zidane/Garnet more than Squall/Rinoa. I dunno, there's just something... classic about it.

I just don't see Squall and Rinoa as a realistic couple. They're not that well matched.

[Krizzy]

I just don't see Squall and Rinoa as a realistic couple. They're not that well matched.

Not well matched in what way?