ME:1 Kaidan or Ashley?

[The Fat Bioware Nerd]

Who did you save at the end of the mission on Virmire? Kaidan Alenko or Ashley Williams? Basically you had to leave one of them on Virmire to die.:(

[sinuosity]

Mate, you know damn well that nobody saved Kaidan.

[The Fat Bioware Nerd]

Mate, you know damn well that nobody saved Kaidan.


No, bros, before ho's?

[sinuosity]

Mate, you know damn well that nobody saved Kaidan.


No, bros, before ho's?

Haha, maybe if the bro in question was a bit more appealing! Certainly I would be shocked if more than 20% of players rescued Kaidan. I remember even less about Kaidan than I do about Jacob in ME2.

[The Fat Bioware Nerd]

Well, if I was a Commander John Shepard and I was in a romance with Liara T'Soni, I'd definitely leave Ashley Williams behind, because she ain't my girlfriend, God damn it! :mad2:

[sinuosity]

I suppose to be honest I don't remember much about Ashley either, other than she was a Republican :lol:

[Psychotic]

Always Ashley. That's not to say I particularly like her, but my choice is more about killing that moron Kaidan than saving her.

[The Fat Bioware Nerd]

I suppose to be honest I don't remember much about Ashley either, other than she was a Republican :lol:


Well, you can't leave both of them, out there. And if I was romantically involved with a blue alien chick, I'd choose to leave behind the person who isn't my girlfriend. Screw Ashley. Screw her hard. :mad2:

[Shauna]

Kaidan kicked it, yo.

[Wolf Kanno]

Kaiden, I never really cared for him. I didn't exactly hate him, except as a party member since his class was useless. Ashley was my love interest in ME1 since she was more interesting than Liara.

[Freya]

You guys are jerks. Kaidan is the best, waaaay better than ashley.

Leave ashley. She's lame.

[Slothy]

Kaidan was a tool.

[The Fat Bioware Nerd]

You guys are jerks. Kaidan is the best, waaaay better than ashley.

Leave ashley. She's lame.


I'm right there with ya. I don't like Ashley too much. I always leave her to do die especially if I'm romancing Liara T'Soni.

[Mr. Carnelian]

I actually do pretty much a 50/50 split on who I leave. I like both of them.

[Formalhaut]

I've only done one run-through ME, and the first time was Ashley, but only because her name was first in the alphabet, and I was doing a biotic classes sweep, so Kaiden was less useful.

In my next run doing Soldier, Infiltrator and Engineer, I'll pick Kaiden. I also plan to romance him in ME: 3, too. A shame you can't do anything in Mass Effect, but that's society for you.

[Del Murder]

I started with ME2 and the default was to save Ashley, so when I finally went back to ME1 to play my 'prologue' I had to save her to be consistent. Probably would have done that anyway.

[theundeadhero]

I saved Kaiden exactly once just to say I've done it. The rest of the time he doesn't make it no matter who I'm romancing. I always play femshep.

[DMKA]

I saved Ashley and have regretted it ever since.

She's screwed on my next playthrough though, and I don't mean in the good way.