PDA

View Full Version : Best Comic Book Female Tournament



Colonel Angus
05-30-2017, 08:31 AM
Inspired by Pumpkin's, maybee's & Mr. C's tournaments, as well as the upcoming Wonder Woman movie, here is a tournament for best female comic book character.

The first group will go until a couple of days, June 1st/when I "close" the round.

Wonder Woman

72309

vs

Tigra

72310

Mystique

72311

vs

Witchblade

72312

Black Cat

72313

vs

Starfire

72314

Elektra

72316

vs

Spider Woman

72315

maybee
05-30-2017, 04:05 PM
Wonder Woman

Witchblade ( not a big fan of the other girl )

Black Cat

Elektra

WarZidane
05-30-2017, 06:31 PM
Tigra
Witchblade
Starfire
Spider-Woman

Sadly out of my choices I predict only Witchblade winning :p

KleinerKiller
05-30-2017, 06:49 PM
Wonder Woman
Witchblade
Starfire
Spider-Woman

Colonel Angus
05-31-2017, 11:27 PM
Bump! I'll probably end this portion tomorrow afternoon/evening (US time)! Thanks to everyone who's voted so far! If anyone hasn't voted but still wants to vote, please do! #NeedMoreVotes

Depression Moon
06-01-2017, 09:03 AM
Wonder Woman
Mystique
Starfire

Colonel Angus
06-02-2017, 07:16 AM
Closing out the first bracket. Big thanks to all who participated. :thumb: My votes are:

Wonder Woman
Mystique
Black Cat
Spider-Woman

The first totals are:

WW 4-Tigra 1
Witchblade 3-Mystique 2
Starfire 3- Black Cat 2
Spider Woman 3- Elektra 1

The 2nd bracket is:

Storm

72348

vs

Thor

72349


Batwoman (Kane)

72350

vs

Jubilee

72351


Black Canary

72352

vs

Donna Troy

72353


Susan Storm

72354

vs

Lady Blackhawk

72355

I'll close this one probably late on the 3rd or on the 4th, since I'll be busy the next couple of days.

KleinerKiller
06-02-2017, 08:20 AM
Thor
Batwoman
Black Canary
Lady Blackhawk

Bubba
06-02-2017, 01:08 PM
Storm
Jubilee
Black Canary
Lady Blackhawk

Vermachtnis
06-02-2017, 09:53 PM
Thor
Jubilee
Black Canary
Lady Blackhawk

WarZidane
06-03-2017, 08:04 PM
Storm
Batwoman
Black Canary
Susan Storm

Depression Moon
06-04-2017, 05:16 AM
Storm
Jubilee
Black Canary
Invisible Woman

Rez09
06-04-2017, 01:11 PM
Storm, for reasons of rains down in Africa and always being one of my favorite X-Men; I'm also completely unfamiliar with this variation of Thor, though I hear her book isn't all too bad.

Batwoman; Jubilee has always been a very 'there' member of the X-Men for me, and Batwoman's black and red visual design is wonderfully striking.

Black Canary; I'm not familiar with Donna Troy and she has the nicer outfit, but I'll go with the character I actually know and don't mind.

Susan Storm; Invisible bubbles, yo!

maybee
06-04-2017, 11:14 PM
Storm- She's bae !!!!

Jubliee- Idk I always felt sorry for her

Black Canary

Susan

Colonel Angus
06-05-2017, 03:58 AM
Thanks to everyone who voted in the latest bracket. The results of that round are:

Storm 6-Thor 2
Jubilee 5-Batwoman 3
Black Canary 7-Donna Troy 1
Invisible Woman/Sue Storm/Richards 4-Lady Blackhawk 3

I voted Storm, Jubilee, Donna Troy, & Lady Blackhawk (But dropped that vote to prevent a tie)

This round we have:

Red Sonja

72419

vs

Caitlin Fairchild

72420

Power Girl

72421

vs

Spider-Gwen

72422

Valkyrie

72423

vs

Wasp

72424

Psylocke

72425

vs

Lady Sif

72426

Probably wrap up this round on the 6th.

Vermachtnis
06-05-2017, 06:55 AM
Red Sonja
Spider Gwen
Valkyrie
Lady Sif

Rez09
06-05-2017, 03:50 PM
Red Sonja; I dig sword and sorcery

Spider-Gwen; Gwen's Spider-Woman design is miles away the best so far, and I've never had any particular love for any of the Superman clones/cousins/alternates/whathaveyous. Hell, don't even have a lot of love for the original, really. :/

Valkyrie; I'm not familiar with the character, but I'm pretty sure Wasp and Captain America kicked the She-Hulk out of the Avenger's building for too much partying, and that's just not okay. >: I

Sif; I don't like Psylocke

Colonel Angus
06-07-2017, 03:52 AM
Going to close out this round. Thanks again to everyone who voted.

My votes are: Red Sonja, Power Girl, Wasp & Psylocke. The results are:

Red Sonja 3- Fairchild 0
Spider-Gwen 2- Power Girl 1
Valkyrie 2- Wasp 1
Lady Sif 2- Psylocke 1

This next round will close on the 8th. I'm going to do 8 matchups this time instead of 4 to speed things up a bit.

Ms. Marvel

72451

vs

Arachne/Spider-Woman

72452

She-Hulk

72453

vs

Silver Sable

72454

Catwoman

72455

vs

Polaris

72456

Huntress

72457

vs

Talia al Ghul

72458

Captain Marvel

72459

vs

Cheetah

72460

Harley Quinn

72461

vs

Silk Spectre

72462

Enchantress

72463

vs

Hawkgirl

72464

X-23

72465

vs

Jessica Jones

72466

Vermachtnis
06-07-2017, 05:22 AM
Ms Marvel
SHE HULK
Catwoman
Talia Al Ghul
Captain Marvel
Harley Quinn
Hawk Girl, my favorite member of the Justice League cartoon
X23

KleinerKiller
06-07-2017, 06:18 AM
Ms. Marvel
She-Hulk
Catwoman
Talia al Ghul
Captain Marvel
Harley Quinn
Hawkgirl
Jessica Jones

WarZidane
06-07-2017, 04:21 PM
Ms Marvel
She-Hulk
Catwoman (such an oldschool picture :p)
Talia Al Ghul
Captain Marvel
Harley Quinn
Hawkgirl
Jessica Jones

Rez09
06-07-2017, 04:37 PM
Spider-Woman; Miiiiiiiiiiiiiiiind webs!! Also like the costume and don't know who that Ms. Marvel is.
She-Hulk; Favorite comic character. :cheer:

Polaris; I actively despise Catwoman.

Huntress; She grabbed Batman's butt. I saw it. Facebook can't lie to me.

Captain Marvel; This is the Ms. Marvel I know and kind of like, which is more than I can say for Cheetah, who I don't care about either way.

Harley Quinn; While I'm not a fan of where this character has been going design wise, she is an eternally fun character and almost always a joy to encounter.

Enchantress; Her design is pretty basic, but I've always kind of liked this character.

X-23; I've no real attachment to 23, but since I actually have some familiarity with her I'll put her above Jessica.

Colonel Angus
06-10-2017, 05:26 AM
Was supposed to close out this round yesterday, but forgot. ^^; So, I'll extend it another day & maybe we can get a few more votes. :thumb:

Bubba
06-10-2017, 02:46 PM
Ms Marvel
She Hulk
Catwoman
Huntress
Captain Marvel
Silk Spectre
Enchantress
Jessica Jones

Colonel Angus
06-11-2017, 06:33 AM
Ending this round, & thanks to all who voted! My votes are:

Spider-Woman
She-Hulk
Catwoman
Huntress
Captain Marvel
Harley Quinn
Enchantress
X-23

Our results are (I abstained my votes where it would cause a tie)

Ms. Marvel 4- Spider-Woman/Arachne 2
Shulkie 6- Silver Sable 0
Catwoman 5- Polaris 1
Talia al Ghul 3- Huntress 2 (abstain my vote)
Captain Marvel 6- Cheetah 0
Harley Quinn 5- Silk Spectre 1
Hawkgirl 3- Enchantress 2 (abstain my vote)
Jessica Jones 3- X-23 2 (abstain my vote)

New Round of 8 matchups! Going to close this on the 12th!

Batgirl (Gordon)

72512

vs

Lady Death

72511

Scarlet Witch
72510

vs

Raven

72509

Poison Ivy

72508

vs

Rogue

72507

Gamora

72506

vs

Shanna the She-Devil

72505

Jean Grey/Phoenix

72504

vs

Dagger

72503

Squirrel Girl

72502

vs

Vixen

72501

Zatanna

72500

vs



Medusa

72499

Emma Frost

72498

vs

Vampirella

72497

Vermachtnis
06-11-2017, 07:10 AM
Lady Death
Scarlet Witch
Rogue
Gamora
Phoenix
Squirrel Girl
Zatanna
Emma Frost

WarZidane
06-11-2017, 10:45 AM
Batgirl
Raven
Rogue
Gamora
Dagger
Squirrel Girl
Zatanna
Emma Frost

Bubba
06-12-2017, 01:36 PM
Batgirl
Raven
Poison Ivy
Gamora
Dagger
Squirrel Girl
Medusa
Emma Frost

Colonel Angus
06-13-2017, 03:24 AM
OK, I'mma gunna close this round out. Thanks again to everyone who voted. First, my votes:

Batgirl
Scarlet Witch
Rogue
Shanna
Jean
Squirrel Girl
Zatanna
Vampirella

The results are:

Batgirl 3, Lady Death 1
Raven 2, Scarlet Witch 1 (abstain my vote)
Rogue 3, Poison Ivy 1
Gamora 3, Shanna 1
Dagger 2, Jean Grey 1 (abstain my vote)
Squirrel Girl 4, Vixen 0
Zatanna 3, Medusa 1
Emma Frost 3, Vampirella 1

This bracket we'll have 4 matchups & close the round of 64 contestants. Hopefully more of you guys will vote! :shobon: Will close the voting on the 14th.

Supergirl

72537

vs

Nebula

72538

Kitty Pryde

72539

vs

Madame Hydra

72540

Black Widow

72541

vs

Death (Sandman)

72542

Mera

72543

vs

Domino

72544

Vermachtnis
06-13-2017, 03:27 AM
Supergirl
Kitty Pride
Death
Domino

Bubba
06-13-2017, 01:24 PM
Nebula
Madame Hydra
Black Widow
Mera

Colonel Angus
06-14-2017, 06:23 AM
Bump to remind people to vote & that I'll close the round out on the 14th!

WarZidane
06-14-2017, 04:27 PM
Supergirl
Kitty Pryde
Black Widow
Mera

Formalhaut
06-14-2017, 04:42 PM
Bracket One: Supergirl

Bracket Two: Kitty Pryde

Bracket Three: Black Widow

Bracket Four: Domino

Colonel Angus
06-15-2017, 06:21 AM
This round's Results! Danke to all the voters. First my votes:

Supergirl
Kitty Pryde
Black Widow
Domino

The results:

Supergirl 4, Nebula 1
Shadowcat 4, Madame Hydra 1
Black Widow 4, Death 1
Domino 3, Mera 2

Our next round, I'll close things out on the 16th.

Wonder Woman vs Spider-Woman (Drew)

72564 72565

Starfire vs Witchblade

72566 72567

Storm vs Sue Storm

72568 72569
Black Canary vs Jubilee

72570 72571

Red Sonja vs Lady Sif

72572 72573

Valkyrie vs Spider-Gwen

72574 72575

Ms. Marvel (Khan) vs Talia al Ghul

72576 72577

She-Hulk vs Catwoman

72578 72579

Bubba
06-15-2017, 04:12 PM
Spider-Woman
Starfire
Storm
Black Canary
Red Sonja
Valkyrie
Talia al Ghul
She-Hulk

Rez09
06-15-2017, 07:06 PM
Wonder Woman; Wonder Woman has always been the face of female super heroes for me, and, unlike Superman, I actually like her quite a bit. This is also the Spiderwoman I'm the most indifferent to.

Starfire; Not so much for her comic iteration as her animated one, who was one of, if not the, most likable characters in a cast of likable characters. Witchblade, on the other hand, I've never had any form of attachment to.

Storm; She may lack invisible mind bubbles, but she controls the weather, yo! I've also always liked how mature and level headed she feels as a character -- certainly a better field leader than Mr. Summers. :colbert: Actually, I kind of wonder if there was ever a storyline about that. . .

Black Canary: Jubilee does nothing for me and Black Canary wins on that alone.

Red Sonja: I prefer her setting and generally feel Sif is far more eclipsed by her Asgardian contemporaries than Sonja is by, like, Conan? And Conan alternate guy no one bothers to remember the name of? (Seriously, what the hell was his name?)

Spider-Gwen: Don't know the book, but I absolutely love that design, and with no attachment to Valkyrie either way that is enough to win for me.

Ms. Marvel: Don't know this character, but I don't mind her design and don't like Talia, soooo yeah.

She-Hulk: Basically the easiest pick imaginable.

Pumpkin
06-15-2017, 07:14 PM
Wonder Woman
Starfire
Storm
Black Canary
Red Sonja
Valkyrie
Ms. Marvel
She-Hulk

WarZidane
06-15-2017, 08:31 PM
Spider-Woman (sorry, never was a wonder woman fan :p)
Starfire
Storm
Jubilee
Lady Sif
Spider-Gwen
Ms Marvel
She-Hulk

Vermachtnis
06-16-2017, 03:28 AM
Wonder Woman
Starfire
Storm
Jubilee
Red Sonja
Spider-Gwen
Ms. Marvel
SHE-HULK

Colonel Angus
06-18-2017, 02:15 AM
Ooops, a day late closing again. :lol:^^; Anywho, closing this round! Thanks to all the voters! First, my votes:

Wonder Woman
Starfire
Storm
Jubilee
Red Sonja
Spider-Gwen
Talia al Ghul
Shulkie

Now the results:

WW 4, Spider-Woman 2
Starfire 6, Witchblade 0
Storm 6, S. Storm 0
Black Canary 3, Jubilee 2 (abstained my vote)
Red Sonja 5, Lady Sif 1
Spider-Gwen 4, Valkyrie 2
Ms. Marvel 4, Talia 2
She-Hulk 6, Catwoman 0

Last set for this round of 32, I'll close this out about Monday, if I remember.

Captain Marvel vs Jessica Jones

72609

Harley Quinn vs Hawkgirl

72610 72611

Batgirl vs Gamora

72612 72613

Raven vs Rogue

72614 72615

Dagger vs Zatanna

72616 72617

Squirrel Girl vs Emma Frost

72618 72619

Supergirl vs Domino

72620 72621

Kitty Pryde vs Black Widow

72622 72623

Pumpkin
06-18-2017, 02:22 AM
Captain Marvel
Hawkgirl
Batgirl
Raven
Zatanna
Emma Frost
Supergirl
Kitty Pride

Vermachtnis
06-19-2017, 01:09 AM
Captain Marvel
Hawkgirl
Gamora
Rogue
Zatanna
Squirrel girl
Kitty Pride

WarZidane
06-19-2017, 09:30 AM
Captain Marvel
Harley Quinn
Batgirl
Raven
Zatanna
Squirrel Girl
Supergirl
Kitty Pryde

Bubba
06-19-2017, 02:26 PM
Jessica Jones
Harley Quinn
Gamora
Rogue
Dagger
Emma Frost
Supergirl
Black Widow

Colonel Angus
06-20-2017, 01:34 AM
Closing out this round! Danke shoen to all who voted! My votes first:

Captain Marvel
Harley Quinn
Batgirl
Rogue
Zatanna
Squirrel Girl
Supergirl
Kitty Pryde

Results!

Captain Marvel 4, JJ 1
Harley Quinn 3, Hawkgirl 2
Batgirl 3, Gamora 2
Rogue 3, Raven 2
Zatanna 4, Dagger 1
Squirrel Girl 3, Emma Frost 2
Supergirl 4, Domino 0
Kitty Pryde 4, Black Widow 1

Next Round!

Wonder Woman vs Starfire

72637

Storm vs Black Canary

72638 72639

Red Sonja vs Spider-Gwen

72640 72641

Ms. Marvel vs She-Hulk

72642 72643

Captain Marvel vs Harley Quinn

72644 72645

Batgirl vs Rogue

72646 72647

Zatanna vs Squirrel Girl

72648 72649

Supergirl vs Kitty Pryde

72650 72651

Voting will close, maybe Wednesday. Thank you to everyone who's participated & please continue to do so! :penciltrick:

Pumpkin
06-20-2017, 03:12 AM
Starfire
Storm
Red Sonja
She Hulk
Captain Marvel
Batgirl
Zatanna
Supergirl

Bubba
06-20-2017, 11:29 AM
Starfire
Black Canary
Spider-Gwen
She-Hulk
Captain Marvel
Rogue
Zatanna
Supergirl

Vermachtnis
06-21-2017, 05:02 AM
Wonder woman
Black Canary
Red Sonja
SHE HULK
Captain Marvel
Rogue
Squirrel Girl
Kitty Pride

Colonel Angus
06-22-2017, 04:57 AM
Going to expand this for another couple of days. Friday I'll close it, so if you want to vote, please do!

Scruffington
06-23-2017, 03:48 PM
Wonder Woman
Storm
Red Sonja
She-Hulk
Captain Marvel
Zatanna
Kitty Pryde

Colonel Angus
06-23-2017, 07:04 PM
Going to close out this round. Thanks to all who voted! My votes first:

Wonder Woman
Storm
Red Sonja
She-Hulk
Captain Marvel
Rogue
Zatanna
Supergirl

Now the results:

Wonder Woman 3, Starfire 2
Storm 3, Black Canary 2
Red Sonja 4, Spider-Gwen 1
She-Hulk 5, Ms. Marvel 0
Captain Marvel 5, Harley Quinn 0
Rogue 3, Batgirl 1
Zatanna 4, Squirrel Girl 1
Supergirl 3, Shadowcat 2

Now we're in the Elite 8! Voting will go until probably Sunday.

Wonder Woman vs Storm

72669

Red Sonja vs She-Hulk

72670

Captain Marvel vs Rogue

72671

Zatanna vs Supergirl

72672

Pumpkin
06-23-2017, 10:05 PM
Storm
She-Hulk
Captain Marvel
Zatanna

Vermachtnis
06-24-2017, 01:34 AM
Wonder Woman
SHE HULK
Captain Marvel
Zatanna

Bubba
06-24-2017, 01:04 PM
Storm
She-Hulk
Rogue
Zatanna

Colonel Angus
06-26-2017, 01:08 AM
Gonna bump this & leave this round open for another day or two so if anyone else wants to vote they can. Thanks to all who've voted already!

Scruffington
06-26-2017, 02:38 AM
Storm
Red Sonja
Captain Marvel
Zatanna

Colonel Angus
06-28-2017, 06:09 AM
OK, gonna close. Thanks to all the voters! My votes:

WW
SH
CM
Zatanna

Now the winners:

Storm 3, WW 2
Shulkie 4, RS 1
Cap 4, Rogue One
Zatanna 5, Supergirl 0

Now, the FINAL FOUR:

Storm vs She-Hulk

72779 72780

Captain Marvel vs Zatanna

72777 72778

I'll close this round on July 1st!

Bubba
06-28-2017, 09:13 AM
She-Hulk
Zatanna

Pumpkin
06-28-2017, 07:55 PM
Storm
Zatanna

Vermachtnis
06-29-2017, 04:06 AM
SHE HULK
Zatanna

Colonel Angus
06-30-2017, 06:20 AM
Bump! Two more days to vote on this one! Now if you don't want Puffy coming to your door waving a gun around, you'd better remember to vote!

https://media.giphy.com/media/26ufgRQW4QHZKoOFa/giphy.gif




Now, the FINAL FOUR:

Storm vs She-Hulk

72779 72780

Captain Marvel vs Zatanna

72777 72778

I'll close this round on July 1st!

Rez09
06-30-2017, 10:58 PM
She-Hulk and Captain Marvel

Bubba
07-02-2017, 08:32 AM
Come on, peeps! It's semi-final time!

Colonel Angus
07-03-2017, 01:51 AM
OK, gonna close this out, a day late ^^; Anywho, here's my votes:

She-Hulk
Captain Marvel

Now the totals:

SH 4, Storm 1
Zatanna 3, CM 2

So, our FINAL will be:

72809 72810

Voting will go until the 5th! Thanks to those who've supported this thread w/ their votes!

Rez09
07-03-2017, 02:31 AM
She hulk. :)

Pumpkin
07-03-2017, 04:01 AM
Zatanna

Vermachtnis
07-03-2017, 05:47 AM
She Hulk

Bubba
07-03-2017, 12:28 PM
She Hulk!

Lone Wolf Leonhart
07-08-2017, 05:13 PM
Came here in anticipation of the Captain Marvel sweep and left in tears.