Best Non- Square Enix JRPG ~SEMIS ROUND 1 ~

[maybee]

Vote for the one that you think is the best RPG out of this round. All of these RPGs got chosen because they all got the highest votes when they won their original rounds, about 7/8 votes each.

The winner of this round will go up against the winner of Round 2.

Please correct me if there has been a mistake.


Here we have :


Suikoden II


http://michibiku.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/suikoden-ii-800x445.jpg

VS


Persona 5


https://thumbs.mic.com/NGM2MTdmZDhiMiMvZWhxZmhKM3hGb2xyRDBTUjFoUjZHc1NScHl3PS8xNng2MDoyNTQ0eDE2MjEvODAweDQ1MC9maWx0ZXJzOmZv cm1hdChqcGVnKTpxdWFsaXR5KDgwKS9odHRwczovL3MzLmFtYXpvbmF3cy5jb20vcG9saWN5bWljLWltYWdlcy9vbWF5a3dtdWdz Y2hxcm03d2twbzF6cmNqYzJtYjlnb3QzaGU1c25jdmRnbWJ0b2loeWd3cndnZWpjanBxdXllLmpwZw.jpg

VS

Persona 3

https://personacentral.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/P3-Manga-header.jpg


*closes in 24 hrs *

[Lord Golbez]

By putting these three together you made the choice between P5 and P3 easy. I get to choose neither. Of course, it's also disappointing that you put my three favorites together, so basically only one game that I actually care about is going to advance past this round.

[Vermachtnis]

Persona 5 has the best turn based battle system and one of the best normal battle themes.

[Wolf Kanno]

I'm still going to have to give this to P3. It was the game that put Persona on the map and still one of the most artistically sound titles in the franchise.

I am also sad that all of the games I was rooting for went up against each other this round. I imagine I won't be voting much after this one, except for Grandia, Wild Arms, and BoFIV.

[Karifean]

Damn is this a battle of the giants or what O.o

[Rez09]

I guess Suiko 2, 'cause I like it a lot.

[WarZidane]

Similar to my opinion on Persona 3 vs 4, I still think 3 has the better story/characters, but the gameplay improvements and polish for 5 put it just ahead of 3, unlike 4 where the improvements aren't quite enough to put it ahead.

Therefore, Persona 5 gets my vote

[Lord Golbez]

Three way tie? I think this tie-breaker should be decided by the obvious factual objective winner criterion. Suikoden II. It is known.

[maybee]

It's a 3- way tie! I have to give my vote to Persona 5. Therefore breaking the tie. Sorry to those who were cheering for Persona 3 and Suikoden 2.


https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/suikoden/images/5/56/Five_Squirrels.gif/revision/latest?cb=20180304093844


https://media.giphy.com/media/lZYYf407bjO0/giphy.gif


*CLOSED *

[Jinx]

I DIDN'T SEE THIS COMIIIIIN

[Wolf Kanno]

Honestly, any of these three games would have made it through and I would be fine with that decision. Here's looking at P5 to take this whole tournament.

[maybee]

Honestly, any of these three games would have made it through and I would be fine with that decision. Here's looking at P5 to take this whole tournament.

Yeah, it was really tough. :ffvitrouble:

[Lord Golbez]

This was the real finale in my heart.