whod win in a fight?tidus or shuyin? (i know theyre the same but on your opinion)

[tidusguy#1]

hey guys, who do you think would win in a fight? i know theyre practically the same but who do you think?:choc2: :elk:

[McLovin']

Shuyin.

[Tavrobel]

Tidus. Shuyin can't even break 9999 damage cumulative OR total, even with Terror of Zanarkand. And when he kicks the Blitzball, it is the World Champion, not a regular Blitzball. If you consider all the plot theories and how Tidus was a version based on the Shuyin Template, Tidus would still win because over the millenium, Tidus would only get better and better. Then again, without Shuyin, there is no Tidus.

[D.os]

Tidus :D

[mega_tonberry]

Tidus

[ff7+ff10 gurl 100]

Tidus.

[McLovin']

Shuyin haters :mad:

[D.os]

Shuyin haters :mad:

No, I like Shuyin, and i think, he would give a good fight. But the winner is quite obvious:D

[ff7+ff10 gurl 100]

Yep shes right

[Setzer Gabianni]

=/ It would be nice if people could explain why they chose Tidus xD I'm giving a reason as to why I chose..Tidus..because..I don't want to make a spammy response.

I chose him because you can make him break the HP damage limit xD

Shuyin..you can't. I don't hate Shuyin *shrugs*

~Setzer Gabianni

[D.os]

=/ It would be nice if people could explain why they chose Tidus xD

~Setzer Gabianni

Ok, here's my reason to chose Tidus, we has very powerfull attacks, and I can break the Hp limit with him:D He is a powerful warrior x)

[Little Blue]

Tidus, because if he started losing, all he'd need to do is get his dad to pwn Shuyin.

Seriously though, I believe Tidus would win because of his clarity of thought. Shuyin, after spending 1000 years in the Den mourning the loss of Lenne would make him more than a little mad, causing him to settle on one strategy and open himself to weaknesses (such as love), whereas Tidus would think (towards the end of the game at least) his actions through and hopefully come to a reasoned strategy that would be flexible, thus giving Tidus greater battle skill over Shuyin. However the fact that Shuyin can possess others would raise Shuyins chances of winning, eg possess Tidus and get him to run himself through with his Caldebolg... Also, iirc, wasn't Shuyin a Zanarkand Warrior before he died?

My thoughts at least...

[Tavrobel]

Tidus, because if he started losing, all he'd need to do is get his dad to pwn Shuyin.

Seriously though, I believe Tidus would win because of his clarity of thought. Shuyin, after spending 1000 years in the Den mourning the loss of Lenne would make him more than a little mad, causing him to settle on one strategy and open himself to weaknesses (such as love), whereas Tidus would think (towards the end of the game at least) his actions through and hopefully come to a reasoned strategy that would be flexible, thus giving Tidus greater battle skill over Shuyin. However the fact that Shuyin can possess others would raise Shuyins chances of winning, eg possess Tidus and get him to run himself through with his Caldebolg... Also, iirc, wasn't Shuyin a Zanarkand Warrior before he died?

My thoughts at least...

No one ever said he was a good warrior... and Tidus COULD get Jecht to destory Shuyin, but Tidus probably would not be able to be possessed, since Shuyin only gets those who despair. Tidus despairs ONCE in the game, and that is because he was left out of the loop, and by the end, Tidus is completely clear on what he has to do, that he would let himself disappear to get what he wants.

Shuyin and tidus are both selfish (being based on the same person, Shuyin), but Tidus is selfish for the better reason. Plus, Tidus' dad is also not able to be possessed. 2 spirits can't inhabit one body (even if the body is made up of millions of bodies and corpses, and if you look really closely, he's got a gigantic Buster sized sword stuck in his head)

And for all those anti-anti-Shuyins, I gave MANY reasons why Tidus would win.


Ok, here's my reason to chose Tidus, we has very powerfull attacks, and I can break the Hp limit with him:D He is a powerful warrior x)

Shuyin has about 20k Hp, the exact number is wierd, but it is not a multiple of five, as people would expect final bosses to be, so therefore, they both Break HP Limit.

[BahamutGurl]

Tidus would win

[Hambone]

:kaocheer: Tidus, Tidus, Tidus! :kaocheer:

'cuz he can do a lot more than Shuyin, and you can actually play with Tidus.