Sig Maker's Challenge

[Timster]

a competition fourm is a great idea!
if we get enough people who agree it shouldn't be hard to fix, right?

[ShunNakamura]

Yeah I would think part of the lack of voters is how it is set up now. My problem is I always keep forgetting to pm the votes in[PM'ing is something I almost never do so it slips my mind quite often]. Also the voting criteria may also cause issues[some people may see it as too complicated].


Also I know I prefer posting the vote because then I feel more justified for posting drawn out reasons why I think that is the the vote should go.

[Owen Macwere]

Just pm them Shun. -.- It isn't that hard.

[ShunNakamura]

Just pm them Shun. -.- It isn't that hard.

yeah, I did, but I also put a bit of work into critiquing them. So it can take me several minutes to perform it. Plus, PM'ing always slips my mind. I have never really used any of those kind of systems. I have had PM's that I don't notice until they are months old. Meh. maybe it is just me.


Anyways the point I was trying to make is that having to send a PM can actually be a turn off to people. And may be a factor in why we get so few votes(I know I have missed several just cause I never got around to going to my PM area to send out the PM.... Plus I have to have two tabs open just to do my critiquing which adds one more tab to my already cluttered tab bar).

[Owen Macwere]

yes, I've been thinking of this too, Maybe in the next comp, we can make better ways, rules and style of comps.
And thanks for voting. =)

[atlanteay]

maybe I should start separate threads for each competition? and then when there are enough entries, i'll add a poll to it?

anyways, here's the results from the most recent challenge.

For Best Background Award, #6 received six votes.
Narok
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a105/atlanteay/sig%20comp/FF12/Comp2.jpg

For best sig as a whole Shape Award, #5 received 4 votes.
Ramza Beoulve
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a105/atlanteay/sig%20comp/FF12/eoffnew2vm9.gif

For Best Blending Award, #6 received five votes.
Narok
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a105/atlanteay/sig%20comp/FF12/Comp2.jpg

For Best Effects Award, #1 received four votes.
Ice Angel
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a105/atlanteay/sig%20comp/FF12/smoekgif.gif

For Best Text Award, #3 received three votes.
vinnie's mini's
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a105/atlanteay/sig%20comp/FF12/sig13-1.jpg

For Best Colors Award, #6 received three votes.
Narok
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a105/atlanteay/sig%20comp/FF12/Comp2.jpg

after the results of the individual category winners, it's quite obvious that Narokis the overall winner.

Congrats Narok!

hopefully, this is the last time that all of us have to go through this inefficient way of doing the challenge. Also, i hope more people join the next competition and i PROMISE the stock would be better.

[4evarisha]

Congrats cant wait for the next comp!

[Polaris]

Congratulations Narok :D

[Owen Macwere]

Congratulations everyone and to Narok specially. =D

[Leeza]

maybe I should start separate threads for each competition? and then when there are enough entries, i'll add a poll to it?

Starting separate threads for each competition gets very messy, considering that this seems to be an ongoing competition.

I'm closing this thread and archiving it as it has gotten quite long. You may start a new thread for the next competitions and keep editing the first post of the thread with updates as to what is happening and links to the posts that they are happening in. This has worked well for other competitions.

You should also PM me or another mod/admin to update the thread title for you when each new competition starts or when there is voting, etc. When the new thread gets uber long again, it will be added to the other archived thread.

Congratulations NaroK. :)