Squall Vs Tidus

[RoxasLeonhart]

I think Squall win in this fight.:) How you

[bipper]

They are both a couple of whiney cry babies. One is just an introvert and one an extrovert. I say they both trip on an emo and die.

[Armisael]

They are both a couple of whiney cry babies. One is just an introvert and one an extrovert. I say they both trip on an emo and die.
:lol:

I prefer Squall however!

[~SapphireStar~]

Same here :D

[Ryth]

They are both a couple of whiney cry babies. One is just an introvert and one an extrovert. I say they both trip go on an emo and die.

Quoted for truth.

[Rocket Edge]

Squall. -has a gunblade. :/

[DJZen]

I say Tidus would win for being less emo. Squall is just a jerk for no reason, while Tidus has actual problems (ie an abusive father who turns out to be the destroyer of Spira, I think we'd all be pretty upset about that). However, Squall has a LOT more training than Tidus (when you start the game, Tidus can't even lift up his sword, while Squall is getting ready to graduate).

...Now that I think about it, this one's kind of a toss-up. Squall can junction 6 ways to sunday and become insanely powerful, but Tidus can break the damage limit and do 99999 damage per hit with Blitz Ace. I think this is probably one of the only hard to call FF matchups.

[the_sandman]

tidus would own him.

tidus would be doing like 9999 damage while squall is still doing 200 some damage. whats crazy is that tidus can go over 9999 making it a guarantee that no matter how high squalls HP is...tidus will kill him in one hit.

[DJZen]

OBJECTION!!!

Squall can use GF to absorb the damage, then capitalize by attacking while Tidus's overdrive meter is at 0.

[the_sandman]

OBJECTION!!!

Squall can use GF to absorb the damage, then capitalize by attacking while Tidus's overdrive meter is at 0.

gf's HP can only go up to 9999 also...so fine. it'll take tidus two hits to kill him. if tidus's overdrive meter is at 0 and squall attacks...tidus will take it. he'll take all the 500 damage or whatever squall throws at him and attack squall with his 9999 damage.

[Dynast-Kid]

Tidus please!

[Sephex]

Tidus would suggest that they play Blitzball to settle their differences and Squall would say something witty like, "Whatever."

[LunarWeaver]

Ugh I wish emo had never been invented. It's ruining games that were made before emo was made.

While I like Tidus better, I think Squall would win a fight between the two as Tidus is more of a normal person and Squall is a mercenary with training.

[Dell]

Squall, definitely.

[Skyblade]

OBJECTION!!!

Squall can use GF to absorb the damage, then capitalize by attacking while Tidus's overdrive meter is at 0.

gf's HP can only go up to 9999 also...so fine. it'll take tidus two hits to kill him. if tidus's overdrive meter is at 0 and squall attacks...tidus will take it. he'll take all the 500 damage or whatever squall throws at him and attack squall with his 9999 damage.

That is purely a fanboy answer, with no attention payed to game mechanics at all.

Squall would win, because of the power of the Junctioning system. Tidus may be able to reach 99999 damage with his Caladbolg, but that would be his undoing, because having that much damage doesn't matter. Speed is always the most important attribute in a battle between FF characters. The Caladbolg doesn't have Initiative. Squall can Junction Initiative. Squall strikes first, and his 9999 damage may not be as impressive as Tidus' 99999, but it will be enough to kill Tidus anyway. Then too, Squall can junction 100 Deaths or Pains to his Status Attack, and Tidus will fall that way.

[boys from the dwarf]

when i do VS things i dont do it stat wise. i you judged strength by stats, tidus could probably beat ultimecia, kuj and sephiroth at the same time (which we all know through common sense that he cant.) think about it storyline wise. seems as squall has the power of the GFs id say he would win. hes also a trained fighter.

[Jimmy Dark Aeons Slayer]

They are both a couple of whiney cry babies. One is just an introvert and one an extrovert. I say they both trip on an emo and die.

Got my support they both pretty much suck.

[Griff]

Tidus' strength could only be determined by Squall's level anyways, just like anyone else Squall fights. So if Squall were at a low level like at the beginning of the game, it would be roughly the eqivilent of Tidus with an empty sphere grid. In which case Squall would lay a royal beating upon him. But if Squall was at top level, Tidus would have a full sphere grid and be able to top the gunblader. Think about it...

[The Crystal]

Both of them will find Cloud, and then, try to discover who is the most emo character in the series. And Cloud will win with easy.
Then, Zack Laguna and Zidane will show up, and kill them.

[the_sandman]

That is purely a fanboy answer, with no attention payed to game mechanics at all.

Squall would win, because of the power of the Junctioning system. Tidus may be able to reach 99999 damage with his Caladbolg, but that would be his undoing, because having that much damage doesn't matter. Speed is always the most important attribute in a battle between FF characters. The Caladbolg doesn't have Initiative. Squall can Junction Initiative. Squall strikes first, and his 9999 damage may not be as impressive as Tidus' 99999, but it will be enough to kill Tidus anyway. Then too, Squall can junction 100 Deaths or Pains to his Status Attack, and Tidus will fall that way.

im far from a tidus fanboy. i think he's the most fruitiest gay starburst ass kid.

as for your reasons why you think squall would win. it depends on what point of the game or whatever they meet. plus, i'm not to sure if this is 100% positive...but somewhere in ff10, i swear you could use one of those ability spheres to attack first also...same thing as an inititive.

[Skyblade]

That is purely a fanboy answer, with no attention payed to game mechanics at all.

Squall would win, because of the power of the Junctioning system. Tidus may be able to reach 99999 damage with his Caladbolg, but that would be his undoing, because having that much damage doesn't matter. Speed is always the most important attribute in a battle between FF characters. The Caladbolg doesn't have Initiative. Squall can Junction Initiative. Squall strikes first, and his 9999 damage may not be as impressive as Tidus' 99999, but it will be enough to kill Tidus anyway. Then too, Squall can junction 100 Deaths or Pains to his Status Attack, and Tidus will fall that way.

im far from a tidus fanboy. i think he's the most fruitiest gay starburst ass kid.

as for your reasons why you think squall would win. it depends on what point of the game or whatever they meet. plus, i'm not to sure if this is 100% positive...but somewhere in ff10, i swear you could use one of those ability spheres to attack first also...same thing as an inititive.

If they meet early, Tidus won't have Break Damage Limit, so your post would have been inaccurate.

And, no, there is no Initiative Ability Sphere, just a weapon upgrade.

[Pharoh Amon Khan III]

Has anyone thought about Evade and Agility Stats?

Humans, always thinking aggressively instead of passively aggressive. The object is not to clash swords but strike home.


BTW: Skyblade... I win.

[the_sandman]

If they meet early, Tidus won't have Break Damage Limit, so your post would have been inaccurate.

And, no, there is no Initiative Ability Sphere, just a weapon upgrade.

he wont have break limit damage. but his attack would still do more than squalls in the beginning...unless squall somehow draws some high level magic early in the game. squall only does like...200 - 300 some damage in the second disk.

[Polaris]

nahhh both will die at the same time when Rinoa and yuna will call them for dinner :D If they don't, Squall wins!

[BustaMo]

I would pick Tidus here. Not only does Tidus have Squall beat on the level of athletic ability and agility, but he's also got the motivation and spunkness to keep his head up in the fight even if Squall would deliver a strong blow to Tidus. When I picture Squall taking on someone in a one-on-one battle, I seem to refer back to the opening of FFVIII and the fight vs. Sefier. I can see Tidus landing a few more gashes on Squall's face.

[Chocobo_Knight]

Ugh I wish emo had never been invented. It's ruining games that were made before emo was made.

While I like Tidus better, I think Squall would win a fight between the two as Tidus is more of a normal person and Squall is a mercenary with training.

Haha i think yours has the most probable explanation.

I personally like Tidus more though both are nice guys :) Hooray for protagonists!

[Cookie]

What about Cloud vs. Squall vs. Zidane vs. Tidus? Who'd win that one?

[f f freak]

Out of Tidus and Squall I say Squall. Squall could just say 'whatever' and Tidus would most likely start crying because he was getting no attention. Then Squall would walk over and shove his sword in Tidus's heart and then pull the trigger blowing up Tidus's heart.

[Malboro_Menace]

Tidus. With Caladbolg and Blitz Ace Squall would have no chance.

I think a more interesting battle would be Seymour and Kuja.

[Sweet Beloved]

Oh...very difficult, considering I love both characters.
...oh well, cheers to Squall. ^_^ I love a man with a gunblade.

[_yeojina_]

Tidus

Pros
Can break the Damage Limit
Powerful Overdrives

Cons
*Coughisablondiecough* Had never even held a sword
Is so lovesick for Yuna he wouldn't even be able to concertrate anyway

Squall

Pros
Has been training for twelve years
Can do about 200 000 damage from Renzozuken and Lionheart
Has a gunblade
Can junction
Actually knows how to hold a weapon
*Coughisahottiecough* Isn't that lovesick over Rinoa

Cons
Is a emo kid

Overall Winner
Vivi. :D Squall.

[Dell]

Tidus

Pros
Can break the Damage Limit
Powerful Overdrives

Cons
*Coughisablondiecough* Had never even held a sword
Is so lovesick for Yuna he wouldn't even be able to concertrate anyway

Squall

Pros
Has been training for twelve years
Can do about 200 000 damage from Renzozuken and Lionheart
Has a gunblade
Can junction
Actually knows how to hold a weapon
*Coughisahottiecough* Isn't that lovesick over Rinoa

Cons
Is a emo kid

Overall Winner
Vivi. :D Squall.

Tidus can do more than 800000 damage.
Squall can Junction but Tidus can use different type of magic to prevent that.
What's the 'Has a gunblade' doing in the Pros?
All of the male protagonists are lovesick to the female protagonists.

[Dante WolfWood]

I would pick Tidus here. Not only does Tidus have Squall beat on the level of athletic ability and agility, but he's also got the motivation and spunkness to keep his head up in the fight even if Squall would deliver a strong blow to Tidus. When I picture Squall taking on someone in a one-on-one battle, I seem to refer back to the opening of FFVIII and the fight vs. Sefier. I can see Tidus landing a few more gashes on Squall's face.

I think he was the only one to think of this IN A LOGICAL way; not a fanboy,tidus/squall hater, or idiotic way...

no offense...:p

[the_sandman]

to the people who think squall can deliver the first blow with initiative, tidus has a sword that has the first strike ability.

[Dell]

to the people who think squall can deliver the first blow with initiative, tidus has a sword that has the first strike ability.

Not in Caladbolg. :p

[XandrewX]

Squall with a yellow hp will be enough to kill tidus...1 hit of renzokuken=9999 and plus all of the 4-5 hits and plus lionheart every hit 9999 tidus die 1st though with initiative junctioned...

[Sefie1999AD]

Why are people always comparing in-game battle mechanics and the damage the characters do to show how powerful they are? It doesn't make the character any weaker if the game doesn't allow you to do 999,999,999 damage. :rolleyes2 I think Squall would win just because he's more trained. Tidus did become a guardian, but he still had no proper battle training, and he couldn't even lift the sword at the beginning of FFX. Tidus has some strong points too, such as his agility and speed. If this turned into a popularity contest, this (http://www.gamefaqs.com/poll/index.html?poll=2516) may give you some kind of an idea about who's more popular.

[James16]

I think squall would win. He was all crunk an mean and like when ever people asked him something or talked to him he would just sit there an say "......" While Tidus was always yellin an cryin an was to much of a pussy to tell Yuna how he felt bout her, an squall could slash at him an if Tidus blocked it or jumped out of the way Squall could just shoot his ass!!:D

[BustaMo]

While Tidus was always yellin an cryin an was to much of a pussy to tell Yuna how he felt bout her

...or Tidus didn't want to interfere with what Yuna needed to focus on with her pilgrimage and defeating Sin on her mind. Sounds pretty unselfish to me.

[James16]

While Tidus was always yellin an cryin an was to much of a pussy to tell Yuna how he felt bout her

...or Tidus didn't want to interfere with what Yuna needed to focus on with her pilgrimage and defeating Sin on her mind. Sounds pretty unselfish to me.

Why not tell her then help her to have a happier plgrimage an to be there for her for alot more moral support??? And at least when he left she could he sumwhat happier....