Vaan vs. Tidus - THUNDERDOME

Tidus, no contest. Don't even get me started.

What's the contest here? Who dresses like the biggest tit? Whose voice is the nasaliest? Best collarbones?

Originally Posted by Psychotic

What's the contest here? Who dresses like the biggest tit? Whose voice is the nasaliest? Best collarbones?

All of the above, and more.

Vaan wins weirdest abs.

Well one of them is a useless little ponce whilst Tidus is a fascinating and awesome character.

Originally Posted by Mister Adequate

Well one of them is a useless little ponce whilst Tidus is a fascinating and awesome character.

I came here to say something like this. Tidus is a great character.

How was there even a debate?

I have to agree. Tidus wins this one hands down.

Well yes, but I think there is some debate because Vaan certainly has better collarbones. You must all surely see that.

Originally Posted by Psychotic

Well yes, but I think there is some debate because Vaan certainly has better collarbones. You must all surely see that.

But can't you see that his shoulderblades are inferior?

Originally Posted by Jinx

Originally Posted by Mister Adequate

Well one of them is a useless little ponce whilst Tidus is a fascinating and awesome character.

I came here to say something like this. Tidus is a great character.

Agreed.

Yep, Tidus wins it for me.

I honestly do not remember many of the character nuances of anyone from FFXII, except from Bathier who was pretty suave. FFXII was great, but the plots and the characters were pushed into the background for all the endless wandering around.

Tidus is gr8, in my eyes.

Tidus is whiny and annoying, and the worst thing you can say about Vaan (abs aside) is that he's just kind of there and doesn't do a whole lot.

Give me someone who's incapable of being annoying because he didn't really do anything over someone who I wanted to see die for most of the game.

Tidus has way better collarbones.
Vaan's are all narrow and stick up out of his body like they're tall.

I don't like Vaan at all, but at least he's not Tidus.

Originally Posted by Vivi22

Tidus is whiny and annoying, and the worst thing you can say about Vaan (abs aside) is that he's just kind of there and doesn't do a whole lot.

Give me someone who's incapable of being annoying because he didn't really do anything over someone who I wanted to see die for most of the game.

You effectively sell off any right to a decent story when you side with the character who is two dimensional and pointless. We might as well have controlled Montblanc sitting in the guild for all the relevance he had.