First Sigs

These are basically the first sigs that I've ever done:
http://img236.imageshack.us/img236/4...tionsigrm0.png
http://img60.imageshack.us/img60/263...ionsig2ez7.png
Are they any good as a beginner's sigs and are they good as sigs overall? What would you rate them? Also which one is better?

Cool you did a very good job on these ^_^*

Those are really great! I like how you blend the picture with the backround. Really nice job on those siggies. :bigsmile:

Nice blending! Neat text too.

they're a hell of a lot better than most first signature i see..

in fact i'd have to say mine is the worst ever.. lmao

http://i8.photobucket.com/albums/a48...dienow/FFS.jpg

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL

you'll get over the harsh high contrast backgrounds soon.. i'd say that the renders are a bit too transparent but other than that nice one ;)

I will answere all your quistions. :cool: me special

FIRST OF ALL< as they are first attempts, they are awesome. (mine were crap, don't mention it).
They are very good as sigs, and you are still in the begining.
I rate them, here look, 8/10.
I think the first one is better.
good work, keep up, let us see more.

Thanks for the advice and the compliments. :)
I'm trying to learn from tutorials right now, so hopefully I'll get better. :P

Yeah, tuts are good, but not all the time, just learn and then figure out your own style. ;)

All right, well I made another one.

http://img221.imageshack.us/img221/6...ionsig3df5.png

Kinda simple, but I couldn't find any characters or anything to add.

This looks really nice, are these brushs, or a picture, because it looks so good.
Well done.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Conflagration

All right, well I made another one.

http://img221.imageshack.us/img221/6...ionsig3df5.png

Kinda simple, but I couldn't find any characters or anything to add.

---

Its nice, but what is it? looks like some sort've warcraft 3 city with green colouring.

Well the background is all brushes. :)

I seriously need a render for it though.

here is a place for renders, cheer, your sig is just great without any renders. ;)

http://www.render-world.com/gallery/...bum=topn&cat=2

www.gamerenders.com
www.animerender.com (highly recommended ;))

do it yourself it another option.. or ask me.. im pretty okay <_< :P

http://animerender.com/forum/uploads...5_1_191360.png

:) my favourite one :P

Oo thanks for those links. :D