Sig Maker's Challenge

Alright guys, thank you. :)
here are some new rules and things I thought of, tell me what you think and I will close this thread and open a new one, because this one is looking kind of messy, that if you agree of course.
rules for making sigs:
1. same render
2. same canvas size
3. same text

voting rules:
1. Pm me with the votes (I wont go in any comp any more)
2. no awards just one sig to win.
3. no spoilars and cheating

other things:
I was thinking of posting the sigs without putting the owners name before it, so people wont chuge for friendship and stuff- not that has happened before, but just in case.

what do you think everyone?.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Owen Macwere

voting rules:
2. no awards just one sig to win.

---

So it would be like..people vote for their favourite signature? Not on the best text, best render etcetc?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Owen Macwere

other things:
I was thinking of posting the sigs without putting the owners name before it, so people wont chuge for friendship and stuff- not that has happened before, but just in case.

---

Aye, that sounds like a good idea! Just post at the end of the voting who made every signature!

I like the idea:)

Ok, and Yes Voodoo, just one award, though if what we were doing before is better, say people I will stick to what we were doing in the previouse two comps.

That sounds good. But only thing is, with the other type of voting people can realise what areas they need to improve on. Say for example someone voted a signature for best background, I could then look at that and look at mine and see how I would improve mine. If that makes any sense?

What if you have the old votes and then maybe when you collect all the votes at the end and post the winner of each section, who ever won the most sections was the overall winner?

If you decide to just have one vote for the best signature, it really wouldn't bother me :) I don't mind either way! I only do the competition for fun!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VoodooChild

That sounds good. But only thing is, with the other type of voting people can realise what areas they need to improve on. Say for example someone voted a signature for best background, I could then look at that and look at mine and see how I would improve mine. If that makes any sense?

What if you have the old votes and then maybe when you collect all the votes at the end and post the winner of each section, who ever won the most sections was the overall winner?

If you decide to just have one vote for the best signature, it really wouldn't bother me :) I don't mind either way! I only do the competition for fun!

---

Yup, everybody votes for the different sections, like always, but don't put a name, just a number for the votes, and post the winners and the creator's name at the end :)

I guess your second Idea is great, yes, that'll work, alright, i will contact someone now to close this thread, or should we stick to it, but ask for cleaning?. :p

Ok cool.

It would be nice if this was closed instead of deleted. Its nice to have some record of the Signatures entered in the previous competitions. But I guess its up to the Admins.

Yeah, i guess, I am asking them now, I will tell you guys what they say when they answere me. :)

Sdit: Anyone know who should I contact of the admins? a cooprating lovely one if possible. :D

Okay... whoah! VoodooChild and Owen Macwere well done!:) But are you going to let the voters PM you Owen?

Yes, i will let them Pm their votes to me, so the thread wont be so crowded. as I am not gonna participate in any comp so i guess it is alright. but if you don't like it, i will stick to our old way. :)

How come you won't join the contest?:( Can you?:)

Well, I've thought about it, I made this first because I liked to see who will vote for me, but now I have changed, I started to like every sig maker here, so this comp is a gift from me to tem, I will hold it for them and let them have fun, this is the lest I can do to repay the help they provided.
I wont join, it is unfair, I have more time to work on my sig than any of you, and also I can see the other sigs before handed so it is just unfair. :)

PS: Holding the comp will be delayed, in order to sort out the new thread. have fun everyone. :D

So the next comp will be in the new thread?????

Owen, one thread per competition is all you need. This thread is full of conversation that should be done through PMs or IMs instead of in this thread. Stuff like that makes it messy, but it is not a reason to start a new thread in this case. I also think that all votes should be PMed to you rather than be posted in this thread.

Your first post can be used to link to other areas of the thread (such as the post where you post your new image for new sigs, etc.) so that it would be easier for members to get around.

Also, if I or someone else voted incorrectly, a PM would have been nice so that the voting could have been redone.