I like the second option best. Two attacks (on two different people) for 30, and a heal on one for 30.
Printable View
I like the second option best. Two attacks (on two different people) for 30, and a heal on one for 30.
I'm sorry, but I don't like any of the options.
Like the other threads, it just take 30/30. FFIX end easily.
We need more EoFF experience user to give their opinion.
Right, after 6 post, I can:
Heal Nanaki, Hurt Bugenhagen
Aeris: 300
Barret: 330
Bugenhagen: 270
Cait Sith: 330
Cid: 330
Cloud: 330
Gast: 330
Ifalna: 330
Nanaki: 390
Reeve: 330
Reno: 330
Rude: 300
Rufus: 300
Sephiroth: 330
Tifa: 330
Tseng: 330
Vincent: 360
Zack: 330
Consider this an official post
Heals Sephiroth, hurt Aeris
Aeris: 270 *hurts*
Barret: 330
Bugenhagen: 270
Cait Sith: 330
Cid: 330
Cloud: 330
Gast: 330
Ifalna: 330
Nanaki: 390
Reeve: 330
Reno: 330
Rude: 300
Rufus: 300
Sephiroth: 360 *heals*
Tifa: 330
Tseng: 330
Vincent: 360
Zack: 330
reeve controlled him!?!?!
ahh, i just found this out, now!!
Smack Aeris, Heal Vincent
Aeris: 240
Barret: 330
Bugenhagen: 270
Cait Sith: 330
Cid: 330
Cloud: 330
Gast: 330
Ifalna: 330
Nanaki: 390
Reeve: 330
Reno: 330
Rude: 300
Rufus: 300
Sephiroth: 360 *heals*
Tifa: 330
Tseng: 330
Vincent: 390
Zack: 330
Okay so my over a year here means nothing. Fine. And the obvious expressed desire to change this by several other members here means nothing, sure. How about the fact that I am right? Does that make a difference? Probably not.Quote:
Originally Posted by vivi_ultima
With the 30-30 plan you are never actually removing Hit points from anybody.
Look at it this way. You have a cap on the Max HP, right? Is it still 420? I'll assume so.
Aeris: 240
Barret: 330
Bugenhagen: 270
Cait Sith: 330
Cid: 330
Cloud: 330
Gast: 330
Ifalna: 330
Nanaki: 390
Reeve: 330
Reno: 330
Rude: 300
Rufus: 300
Sephiroth: 360
Tifa: 330
Tseng: 330
Vincent: 390
Zack: 330
This is where it stands now. Lets say for example's sake everyone decides to hate on Aeris, Barret, Cait Sith and Bugenhagen until they die. And heal others.
Dead Now
Aeris: 0
Barret: 0
Bugenhagen: 0
Cait Sith: 0
Alive Still
Cid: 390
Cloud: 420
Gast: 420
Ifalna: 420
Nanaki: 420
Reeve: 420
Reno: 420
Rude: 420
Rufus: 420
Sephiroth: 420
Tifa: 420
Tseng: 420
Vincent: 420
Zack: 420
This is the result forcibly. I removed the HP from the dead characters 30 at a time healing the others 30 at a time. You will HAVE to have most other characters at Max HP. Sure it might not be this exact layout or those exact characters dead, but with the way you have the game, once four more characters die, it will become impossible to kill anyone as the Max HP barrier will prevent anyone from getting lower than 390 HP. Once you remove the 30 HP from anyone besides Cid, you HAVE to heal Cid making him at Max HP. Thus not really doing anything. This process WILL repeat.
Of course I'm typing all of this in vain as the person who created this won't even CONSIDER looking at how this game will pan out. If you can explain how, after three more characters die, you can kill anyone without cutting everyone's HP like some hand of god, by all means. I'll shut up and you'll never have to deal with me again. But please look at the future.
I reviewed the FFIX thread and the only reason that game ended was because Jhei and others decided to cut everyones HP once they all got to Max and also that game forced people to give up heals and protects. If you want a functional game where there doesn't have to be an interference from god swiping everyone of a chunk of HP off everyone once they get to max HP, you should just make the damage more than the heal. This way it will pan out on its own rather than having divine intervention hurt everyone. It will remove the hassle and eventually make the game end at some point in the near millenium.
What's this 'experienced user' business? I haven't been here long, but I instantly judged the situation and knew that it was going to take a very very long time to end.
Besides, listen to the poster above, he talks sense. :)
Experience hummm... that is really interesting.
Well it might be true that i have just joined but still i think that it´s a matter of logic and not experience.
And in terms of logic i think i have some:rolleyes2
Um, usually someone just knocks everyones hp down by 60 or 90. The FFIX elimination game eventually ended and the VIII one is getting there and no one ever changed the hurt damage. Just give this one time.
Right, nobody ever changed the hurt damage, it only ended because once the characters got to MAX hp after transferring all the dead characters HP onto themselves, someone had to say something like, and I quoteQuote:
The FFIX elimination game eventually ended and the VIII one is getting there and no one ever changed the hurt damage. Just give this one time.
Page 4.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jhei
or
Its THESE power blows that must be done to the maximum combined HP that allows for the killing of characters, not really the choice of other people. For a string of posts people were forced to do:Quote:
Originally Posted by Boys from the dwarf
orQuote:
drowns Quina in a swamp,protect Mikoto,no healing
That lsast move was done by Kain's_girl. Is it fair that you were forced to not heal someone because everyone else was healed?Quote:
Hurt Quina, Heal and protect no one!
If you ALL want to go on having to do the death by divine intervention, be my guest but its going to take a VERY long time. Especially with the love people have for FFVII, there's going to be a lot of competition for certain characters.
I would start my own variation of this here, but I have a fear it'd get locked because we already have an elimination match going and it will seemingly last until august.
And the whole experience issue is just wrong. It doesn't matter who has been here the longest, it matters that players of this game might want a change of pace and you should listen to them. And Secondly if it IS about experience, I have more experience with this site than most of the people who have played this game, not that it matters. There are "more experienced" people who play this game, but if they have the maturity to last here this long, they'll probably at least check out to see if what I have to say is worth anything and make an opinion based on facts rather than just being stubborn.
Its not about who's been here longer anyhow, as
Can you just actually let the thread starter do what he wants and not spam up the game? Amaru, doesn't matter what you think, the thread starter has the final say.
~Setzer Gabianni
Er, excuse me, but I'm not the only one expressing my opinion here, heck, I'm not even the main one. ;)
when it comes to that points lets just knock 120 HP off everyone seems as you have to heal unless its impossible.
this talk has stopped the thread progressing.
less staying more playing!
hurt aeris, heal tifa.
Aeris: 210
Barret: 330
Bugenhagen: 270
Cait Sith: 330
Cid: 330
Cloud: 330
Gast: 330
Ifalna: 330
Nanaki: 390
Reeve: 330
Reno: 330
Rude: 300
Rufus: 300
Sephiroth: 360
Tifa: 360
Tseng: 330
Vincent: 390
Zack: 330
To all people who give their opinion, I do not mean one, two, three or four person but I mean more person. Thanks for giving your opinion.
The no heal and protect post is use when most of the character HP is at max. They will all join and eliminate one character.
Do you see, one of my post in this thread remove 90 HP of all characters.
I don't force you to heal. You can avoid healing if you want.
If you see, FFVIII Elimination thread have more than 20 pages while FFVII Elimination thread does not even pass 10 post.
I don't want this thread to be closed, so do not spam.
I can post after 6 post,
Heal Nanaki, Hurt Bugenhagen
Aeris: 210
Barret: 330
Bugenhagen: 240
Cait Sith: 330
Cid: 330
Cloud: 330
Gast: 330
Ifalna: 330
Nanaki: 420
Reeve: 330
Reno: 330
Rude: 300
Rufus: 300
Sephiroth: 360
Tifa: 360
Tseng: 330
Vincent: 390
Zack: 330
Alright. I was only trying to make it faster and possibly more interesting. If this is the way you really want it doen, I have no choice but to go along. Sorry for all the delays then.
Aeris: 210
Barret: 330
Bugenhagen: 240
Cait Sith: 330
Cid: 330
Cloud: 330
Gast: 330
Ifalna: 330
Nanaki: 420
Reeve: 360
Reno: 330
Rude: 300
Rufus: 270
Sephiroth: 360
Tifa: 360
Tseng: 330
Vincent: 390
Zack: 330