Mafia XIV Game Thread - GAME OVER - Cult Win! Skulls for the Skull Throne!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Titan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Carbuncle

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Cactuar

What the hell. I never attacked him. I was never against him. What I meant is that you can't just assume he isn't town. He wasn't suspicious to me, but that doesn't mean he's beaming townie vibes out of his ass.

---

You say you were never against Ifrit and yet, you voted to lynch him. It did seem like an easy target for you because alot of people were ganging up on him at the time.

---

Sounds like a contradiction, and there's an old saying, and it goes something like this: Cheaters never prosper. Sorry Cactuar.

##Unvote: Ramuh
##Vote: Cactuar

---

The above post was made at 10:42pm (whatever timezone this account is in). So was the below post.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Cactuar

smurf it, Titan is the Psychologist. Have at him.

---

Which means:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Titan

Have you noticed how Cactuar immediately named me as that Psychologist after I had casted the final vote? Well, there you go.

---

Yes I noticed how he posted at the exact same time as Titan. I don't think he would have had enough time to preview, see the vote and then out Titan as the psychologist just to lay heat on him. I'm undecided as to whether Titan actually is the psychologist.

First of all, Cactuar was a townie. So outing another townie would draw the mafia's attention straight to that person and get them night killed. Here are some possible outcomes of last night:

- If Titan was protected, then we have to be dealing with two parties who can night kill, otherwise there wouldn't have been a death.
- There might be a bus driver, who decided to target Titan and Alexander.
- Titan is scum, and Cactuar outted him in the hope we'd be suspicious of him.

Regardless, I think we are actually dealing with a Cult. So it's on our psychologist, whoever that is, to find who it is and out him.

One more post coming~

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Leviathan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Bahamut

I had chalked Ifrit's annoying behaviour up to first day ridiculousness, but I see what you're getting at, Chocobo. Regardless, I'm sticking with my vote, because, like I said, Ifrit annoys me, whether it's his role's fault or his.

As a note, if I had a role like that, I'd be screwed. If that is the case with Ifrit, I commend you.

---

Voting for people solely because they annoy you is mean :( but besides that, it's a careless move and can't afford to be making careless moves. We have a mafia and possibly even a cult or some other such third party to get rid of.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Bahamut

The fact that Cactuar claims that he would flip scum has brought something unorthodox to light. I'm gonna stick with my vote, but if Ifrit is lynched and flips scum, I'll have something more to say, not an accusation about anyone specific or involving any suspicion in any one person, but about the roles of the game itself. This still stands if Ifrit is not lynched, someone else is, and they also flip scum. I have a feeling that it's just a ridiculous hunch, but I'd like to investigate it further if our first lynch flips scum, regardless of who it is.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Bahamut

Also, I say we do it the other way around. Let's lynch Ifrit first, and if he flips town then I'll take the knot next, whether I like it or not. If he flips Mafia, then I'm off the hook. Whichever way you decide, him or me first, it'll work out the same way.

---

You're essentially telling the town here that if Ifrit turns out to be mafia, then you're definitely town, and if Ifrit is lynched and turns out to be town, then you're definitely mafia. I see a potential problem here, does anyone else?

---

Leviathan sums up my thoughts pretty much exactly. Voting for someone because they annoy you can get us in a lot of :bou::bou::bou::bou:, especially if Ifrit does have an important role.

All of this "if he's town then I'll be next anyway" talk makes you reek of scum. Also:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Siren

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Valefor

Why would a mafia make themselves so visible and go after Ifrit so determined?

---

Because most ,if not all, of us wouldn't expect something like this.

---

Siren has it right. Nobody expects the really loud characters to be scum, particularly if they're posting and (apparently) trying to help catch scum.

So for now, Bahamut is on top of my list.

##Vote: [M] Bahamut

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Ramuh

Hey guys srs time nao. I was just messing earlier, but it caused some discussion so go us? :D Ifrit being mafia would strike me as odd, because he is the most active poster and no mafia is ever so vocal day 1. (same logic can be applied to me btw.)

---

Okay this post just irks me. Especially the bit at the end, in brackets. "I'm vocal day 1 just like Ifrit so we're both not mafia". Uhuh.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Valefor

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Leviathan

b) he's a third party player who knows who's on what team. if Ifrit's on the mafia team and we all lynch Ifrit, then it will clear Bahamut's name if we follow his guidelines, and so the third party will live on and he will not be suspected...Unless of course he slips up somehow/a cop investigates and finds him to be guilty/a tracker follows him to the scene of crimes.

---

What role would have that super powerful ability?

---

Mafia usurper. They have access to the mafia forums, they're counted as a member of the mafia, but their goal is to get the godfather killed. The other mafia members don't know that they're a traitor.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Phoenix

First of all, Cactuar was a townie. So outing another townie would draw the mafia's attention straight to that person and get them night killed. Here are some possible outcomes of last night:

- If Titan was protected, then we have to be dealing with two parties who can night kill, otherwise there wouldn't have been a death.
- There might be a bus driver, who decided to target Titan and Alexander.
- Titan is scum, and Cactuar outted him in the hope we'd be suspicious of him.

---

All the mafia figured Titan might be protected and went for someone else.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Leviathan

Mafia usurper. They have access to the mafia forums, they're counted as a member of the mafia, but their goal is to get the godfather killed. The other mafia members don't know that they're a traitor.

---

I don't think the usurper can see the Mafia forum.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Siren

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Phoenix

First of all, Cactuar was a townie. So outing another townie would draw the mafia's attention straight to that person and get them night killed. Here are some possible outcomes of last night:

- If Titan was protected, then we have to be dealing with two parties who can night kill, otherwise there wouldn't have been a death.
- There might be a bus driver, who decided to target Titan and Alexander.
- Titan is scum, and Cactuar outted him in the hope we'd be suspicious of him.

---

All the mafia figured Titan might be protected and went for someone else.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Leviathan

Mafia usurper. They have access to the mafia forums, they're counted as a member of the mafia, but their goal is to get the godfather killed. The other mafia members don't know that they're a traitor.

---

I don't think the usurper can see the Mafia forum.

---

Actually they can. I iknow this because: a) I played one in breakfast mafia, b) the roles flash says so :p

I must of being thinking about the Final Fantasy mafia game.

Carbuncle stop voting for me :(

It's because he likes you, y'know? ;)

Ok, here I am.
I have been rather slack not only this evening, but yesterday also, so I'll have a read through on what's been going on.
I'll do my best to give you my opinion on those who I find to be sus, of course.

Hey guys do you know the time?
Of course you do, it's 20 past RHYME

There's just one thing that I'd like to know
And so I am about to ask someone: Chocobo
Yesterday at one point you voted Valefor
How do you feel now? Is he someone to ignore?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Diablos

Ok, here I am.
I have been rather slack not only this evening, but yesterday also, so I'll have a read through on what's been going on.
I'll do my best to give you my opinion on those who I find to be sus, of course.

---

Please do.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Phoenix

- If Titan was protected, then we have to be dealing with two parties who can night kill, otherwise there wouldn't have been a death.
- There might be a bus driver, who decided to target Titan and Alexander.
- Titan is scum, and Cactuar outted him in the hope we'd be suspicious of him.

---

-Probably. I think there are two anti-town factions. Cult and Mafia or Serial Killer and Mafia because I think psychologist could be for a serial killer too.
-:confused: How could a bus driver target two people in one night?
-If Titan was scum, why wouldn't Cactuar mention that? They just said psychologist and psychologist doesn't necessarily mean Mafia though a Mafia psychologist could exist, but I think Cactuar would have said this if this were the case.

Rydia :mad2:

A Bus Driver switches the places of two people, Carbuncle.

Okay, for the first time I have an opportunity to make a good post.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Shiva

Oh for Crystals' sakes :mad2: If no one else is switching votes or an inactive's not saving the day in the next five posts, I'm going to lynch someone.

---

What? Why would you want to end the day like this? It's much more beneficial for the town if we can deliberate longer.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Shiva

[M] Carbuncle must be a saint for not settling that sudden death. :p Was sure hoping someone'd crack from that stalemate, and [M] Titan might not be looking too hot for doing the deed. Also worth looking into are the other people who voted on [M] Cactuar, because while he was begging for a rope, wouldn't be too easy to get a mafia like that? Another thing, I don't know what a Psychologist does, could someone explain? :(

---

Titan has been confirmed as a psychologist, so we aren't bothered about that, and you yourself said you were about to cause a lynch anyway.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Shiva

Thanks, [M] Valefor, I guess it was mentioned earlier, but I couldn't find a link in the mafia flash explaining the role, but that's what I'm going with then. Can Psychologists be turned cult, if [M] Titan wasn't killed, he could have been recruited?

---

I'm seeing a trend here of you dropping hints about Titan. Your point does not make sense because Titan would have been killed even if he was recruited. I find it odd how you are trying to taint Titan's reputation with invalid arguments.