Originally Posted by Mercen-X
Well, I guess it would be odd to be trapped/stranded on an island with a couple of items you just happen to need.
If I were banished to a tropical island, sentenced to live out the rest of my natural or unnatural life there, then I'd still bring my hat. There's no need for any other item, because I could just build it there on the island. I'd also bring water materia because it's harder to collect water from a random storm than it is to make fire from scratch. Then, I'd have the Shiva materia.