Rolling Stone: "The 100 Top Music Videos"

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by shadowtheninja

There's no Guns n Roses, this LIST SUCKS!!! :mad2:

---

Yeah, I think that at least "November Rain" should be there. It's a nice video.

But my first reaction was, "wtf is nirvana doing in the second place?", because Smells like teen spirit isn't that good a video, and I think it got to the list because it's a classic grunge song. Nothing wrong about being a good song, but they shouldn't lift it up to the video list just 'cause of that. :/
I'm also wondering why so many Madonna videos, they're not all THAT good...

Otherwise I'm not that good at saying which vids should be there and which not. I'm kinda sad that Metallica's One didn't make it any higher, but I understand it, because there's a lot of performing in the video, and that normally isn't something that's very unique ;P

Well, at least their top 100 songs list is a bit better than this ;)

When MTV made its "top 100 videos of the 20th century", MJ's Thriller came in first, and while I'm not a MJ fan, I have to admit that it kicks ass. It's a small movie!
At any rate, there's one SY clip, so I'm satisfied.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kikimm

That list is lacking NINs "Closer." This makes me angry.

Screw this list!

---

wins

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chris

Actually, I think this list is a good overview with many mixed genres. No bias here!

---

Yes, because Rolling Stone is the epitomy of musical integrity.... or not.