Orphan that Reactor claim is hard to believe. Explain yourself.
Printable View
Orphan that Reactor claim is hard to believe. Explain yourself.
I don't like Orphan's role claim, ya know? But at the same time, it's too early for me to make any sort of judgement call on him, ya know?
I don't like Hojo or Queen Brahne either, ya know? But I don't think all of them can be evil!
For now though, my vote goes to Golbez.
##Vote: [M] Golbez
Golbez was really close to death yesterday, ya know? He escaped the firing line, but today Ultros is dead and, ya know, Ultros was one of the folks who voted for Golbez to die. Just seems like they trying to pick off all the players on the right track, ya know!
that doesnt make sense, on day one no one can be on the right track, because its day one, it was just a random guess made by everyone.
ORPHAN.
EXPLAIN.
##VOTE: [M] ORPHAN
Makes perfect sense, ya know? If I were scum, I'd wanna take out anyone who seemed like they were suspicious of me on Day 1 before they start getting concrete ideas, ya know. Gotta take out the bad fish before it begins to stink up Balamb, ya know?
That's really annoying, ya know?
that is bull turds, it wouldnt make sense, that would be like saying everyone who voted for..... (who died yesterday, i forget) was scum because they voted for him.
:love:
unvote: whoever
##vote: Ultros
because I still want calamari
Ugh...stop voting for silly reasons.
The short answer is nothing. Random voting again.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
you are right.
unvote: ultros
vote: raijin
your whole tirade just reeks, Im not risking voting for orphan yet, but you havent said one thing that made sense
Hey. What's going on? Are we still lost in this game, because I sure am! From what I am seeing, it looks like Orphan made some random role claim that makes completely no sense this early in the game, you know? It could just be some dumb joke to rile everyone up looking for mafia this early, so my guess is that it means nothing.
Where's your reasoning for voting?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Hojo
Just shooting in the dark I assume.
It's not even a 50/50 for getting town, regardless, even if it was, that's very risky.
ultros already died..... unless you know something to the contrary?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] OrphanWhere's your reasoning for voting?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Hojo
Just shooting in the dark I assume.
It's not even a 50/50 for getting town, regardless, even if it was, that's very risky.
More or less I'm just not paying attention to the events of this game.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Hojoultros already died..... unless you know something to the contrary?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] OrphanWhere's your reasoning for voting?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Hojo
Just shooting in the dark I assume.
It's not even a 50/50 for getting town, regardless, even if it was, that's very risky.
I'm just going to place a vote down right now. I'll change it later if I find a better candidate. My vote will be for Golbez, not only because of his little amount of explanation in the last day, but also because of his most recent post, just a little while back
This, to me, seems like a classic example of "Trying to look like I said something when really I haven't". In addition to what he has done in Day 1, Golbez has yet to say anything of merit, and yet he has posted enough to make his presence known.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Golbez
##Vote: Golbez
Also, to comment on Gilgamesh, we really can't say anything about his role from his posting style. If it's in his role to post like that, that doesn't mean he's a killer. If it's not in his role and he's just posting like that to be funny or something, it doesn't make him a mafia. It doesn't make him a town, either, but it doesn't tip the scales in any way.
As for Orphan, I'd like an explanation on what you mean by Nuclear Reactor. Is that your roleclaim? Also, why wouldn't you use the little time that you have to at least say something of importance? Why haven't you been paying attention to the game thread?
With Sephiroth changing his vote, that doesn't make him a scum. He didn't know that Seymour was a cop, no one did except Seymour. As for why he chose Seymour instead of Golbez, only a lynch for Golbez or a lynch for Sephiroth might possibly tell us the answer to that, which further strengthens my vote for Golbez.
Out of everything I've read, this is the only thing that strikes me as weird at all.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Golbez
He just... voted and left.
Obviously this has been covered but I'm just saying.
Oh, forgot the actual important part of the post.
##Vote: Golbez
All we really have to go on for now.
That's too bad, ya know? I don't like headless eye-breasted freaks either, ya know.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Maybe you should listen to what I'm saying instead of just glossing over, ya know? It's not that hard, ya know?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Hojo
Sorry I have errands to run during the day! Jeezum >:\
Oh my, you people. xD
This game is fun.
##Vote : Orphan
I don't know if you've noticed but everyone's roles up until now have all been normal, like roleblocker, cop and lynchee. So you being a nuclear reactor (?) is not very likely. And you haven't even bothered to explain yourself.
SENSIBLE.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen Brahne
APOLOGIES.
Ugh, sorry I'm so late to the party, but I'll let you know my thoughts so far, ya know? :p
Ok, so, straight away I didn't like Golbez. Why? 'Cause I like discussion. Discussion is the only power that vanilla townies have. It gives us the opportunity to prove ourselves as town members, and gives scum the opportunity to make mistakes and show their true selves. Sure I may not have posted yet, but I hope to contribute more in this post than some will not do in 10...
Here we have Golbez explaining that he jumped on the bandwagon so that day one would hurry up and end. How does this make any sense? Sure, we don't know much on day one as we have no other days to compare it to, but the least you can do is get discussion going so that day one is a valuable day that we can look back on. I'm not saying Golbez is scum, but we need townies who are helping the town, not hindering it.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Golbez
The next person who got on my nerves for stifling discussion was Sephiroth. Sure day one had gone on with little useful discussion, but a great time to create discussion and get people to talk, presuming they're around, is when their head is on the chopping block. When you've got a 50/50 vote like that, let them plead their case, maybe they'll give some information that would help the town, who knows. The least you could have done was give the smallest reason for choosing one person or the other, instead of just saying the day needed to end.
I'm not liking either of you two right now, but I'd like to see if you have any more to say for yourselves before I go planting any votes.
Oh and before I go to dinner, if Orphan really is a nuclear reactor/bomb. Remember that with a bomb, there is often a bomb/nuclear reactor technician.
It's worth keeping in mind.
OCCASIONALLY.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Kuja
ROLECLAIM?
No not roleclaim, and I'm not asking people to roleclaim either.
Necron wonders what the vote count looks like. Necron thinks this is a slow lynch for a townie.
Necron thinks scum would want to either:
Pile on a townie Golbez because what is an innocent to them as long as a guy is innocent
Try to deflect the pressure on scum Golbez by jumping on the wagon for someone else
Necron feels scum must be too smart to do the first option because it is too obvious. Necron thinks scum may not have be sharp enough to avoid the wisdom and thus folly of the second option. Necron has not looked yet because Necron is mostly asleep but that is about to change.
[1] Gilgamesh - Jihl Nabaat
[4] Golbez - Rajin, Bartandelus, Orphan, unvoted
[2] Kefka - Gilgamesh, Unvoted
[1] Hojo - Necron
[2] Orphan - Fujin, Queen Brahne
[1] Raijin - Hojo
[1] Judge Gabranth *
[1] Seifer *
[1] Jenova *
[1] Kuja *
[1] Zeromus *
[1] Sephiroth *
[1] Jecht *
*Unvoted
Necron wondered if you counted poorly formatted ##VOTE tags.
Necron thought the situation looked little more dire, but sees very little of what Necron had been hoping to see. Necron noticed Queen Brahne expressed interest in the SephirothxGolbez angle but never pursued it.
I just skimmed through them, if someone wants to point out that they have voted then they can feel free to do so, though I am pretty sure I got them all.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Necron
I'm was going to vote for Golbez (at least that way the truth about Sephy will also be revealed). However I would like to know what Orphan meant first.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Necron
He claimed nuclear reactor but that's highly unlikely considering the recent roles. And he said that he had not paid much attention to the game thread so that doesn't do him much justice either.
Also we shouldn't count the unvoted because it makes it a bit confusing.
If Orphan wants to be spared my vote he must come and explain himself.
The rules are the rules, think of it as a reminder to vote.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen Brahne
We have to vote? Oh trout, that's right. I'll just throw this out here because I'm still clueless as hell on whats going on here.
##VOTE: Kuja
Please think this through Jecht. It's not day 1 anymore.
OK guys, sorry about yesterday, I ended up working overtime and was totally exhausted when I got home, so, needless to say, I went straight to bed. However, now I've had a full night's sleep and I am ready to get this discussion in full swing, although I am sure that the day will be ending soon. :(
It's terrible that we lost our Cop and our Role Blocker all in one night, but we can't dwell on such tragedies, we must push forward for the truth.
As Queen Brahne stated, in Persona 4 Mafia, the serial killer (as well as other roles) had to meet certain conditions and was rewarded with a night kill when they were met. I believe the serial killer had to get other players to type backwards to earn his night kill, which he succeeded in doing. When I saw that Gilgamesh was typing so weirdly it raised my suspicions that he maybe trying to get someone else to do the same. I looked through the thread and noticed that at least one player (Queen Brahne) purposely mimiced his typing style in an attempt to show him how distracting it can be. There were also others who quoted Gilgamesh and so had the same typing style in their replies. I, of course, can't really say he has a task or if he even completed it, but I can say that he was typing strangely, at least one person mimiced him on purpose, and we have two night kills perpetrated on us Night 1. This is why I have voted the way I did. If Gilgamesh has a different reason for needing to meet a condition that's Pro Town, then maybe he can explain himself better.
Also, I looked it up and read that when a Lynchee is night killed the Lyncher becomes a regular Townie and wins when Town wins, so this is good for us. The fact that Ultros was a Mason Lynchee suggests that he was recruited as a Mason rather than starting out as one which would indicate that the Mason recruiter is still alive and able to recruit, which is great for Town. I am definitely not suggesting a Mason should role-claim or anything, definitely keep it to yourself, I am just saying all is not lost for the Town.
One other thing; Barthandelus made a giant post that essentially said that what a player says or how he/she says it may or may not indicate guilt. He accuses Golbez of not contributing anything of substance to the discussion and yet doesn't contribute much of anything himself. It is true that Gilgamesh's strange posts could mean nothing, and Sephiroth's vote change to end the day doesn't necessarily mean he is scum, but we are here to weed out Mafia and the only thing we can go on is what players post. So, we must scrutinize everything that is said, otherwise we will go nowhere and we will all die.
Actually, I'm afraid that in this particular game if the lynchee is killed by any means other than lynching, the lyncher loses, although apparently they can still win by convincing the town to lynch a dead body. How would I know this? I am the lyncher!
And dd or kd told me that I can still win if we somehow lynch Ultros, which means either we can lynch a dead person, someone has a resurrection role, or Ultros's death was faked.
That's an interesting role claim, I have not heard this twist before, although I am not dismissing it straight off. However, what do you mean they said you could still win? Still win as a Townie with Town? Or still win as a Lyncher? I think it is important that you explain exactly what you were told, so we can make a proper decision about your claim.
my role pm said that if ultros wasnt lynched, I would lose, a pm afterwards said that because he had been killed, I lose: unless I can find someway to lynch Ultros.
Another Pm said that There was still a way for me to win. Whether town or lyncher or both I can't sy, but none the less.
##:unvote: raijin
##vote: ultros
it's worth a shot
Those who have questions and so on, if you want to receive a reply you should clear out your PM box so we can send you new messages.
Hojo, my best guess would be that one of us has some kind of reviving power. If Ultros were revived and you lynched him, you could still win.
Orphan is being pretty weird. Superpowered roleclaim, questions another players voting of Golbez, questions another players obvious voting for a dead player and then turns around and votes Golbez? Huh.
So for now ##vote: Orphan.
Necron wants to set the record straight here:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Necron
Necron was trying to jumpstart conversation with an improperly formatted vote.
##UNVOTE Hojo
##VOTE Golbez
Necron has obligations and will not be around much longer today.
[5] Golbez - Rajin, Bartandelus, Orphan, Necron, unvoted
[1] Gilgamesh - Jihl Nabaat
[2] Kefka - Gilgamesh, Unvoted
[2] Kuja - Jecht, Unvoted
[3] Orphan - Fujin, Queen Brahne, Judge Gabranth
[1] Ultros? - Hojo
[1] Seifer *
[1] Jenova *
[1] Zeromus *
[1] Sephiroth *
*Unvoted
10 Votes needed for speed Lynch otherwise we have just about 25 minutes left on the clock.
necron bandwagon
Hojo you want a tie?
Wow, I've missed quite a bit. It seems I don't have enough time to catch up, though I don't think a vote at this point would matter anyway, so I'll just have my vote on myself for today. Oh and I might not be on for the first half of tomorrow.
Time is up, Flavour to follow.
Final Fantasy IV (II) Music: Golbez Clad in Dark - YouTube
Hiding through the shadows all night and all day was not enough to save Golbez, the mob closed in on him chanting "LYNCH LYNCH LYNCH" in a dull monotonous drone, the cries of Golbez shouting "I am innocent!" were not enough to say him as the droning mob dragged his body up to the gibbet and without ceremony proceeded to hang him till his feet stopped kicking.
Golbez was a Vanilla Townie played by Cim! 16 hour of night to follow, PM me with your night actions.
Final Fantasy XIII Final Boss Music - "Nascent Requiem" - YouTube
Orphan looked on down from on high in his cradle, thinking all was safe, little did he notices the sneaky ninja like person coming up behind him, the masked killer grabbed his head and slit his throat before he even had a chance to say no dont kill me!
Orphan was a Vanilla Townie played by Trollhunter, may he ever rest in pieces!
Elswhere however...
Final Fantasy XIII - Barthandelus Battle Music [HD] - YouTube
Bartandelus was walking along thinking he had out done himself having Orphan done in, soon it would truly be time to meet his maker, he was walking along his hopes held high until he was grabbed and shoved into a dark ally and beaten to death with a rubber duck.
Bartandelus was the Mafia Mason played by leader of mortals.
Mafia...........amongst the masons.............2 more townies dead...............Gilgamesh knows not....................who to trust...................all who voted for Golbez.............except Rajin...........dead.............Rajin............needs to explains himself...............but......................Gilgamesh...........smells..............a frame job....................Rajin.................guilty.........................or...................... .....innocent.........................what does town........................think?
Ha! I knew that Orphan fellow was pulling our legs with that fake role-claim of his, but nobody would listen to old man Jecht, or even give my opinion any thoughts. I did say it meant nothing. Well, at least he wasn't lynched or anything... Looks like one of the Mafia people was also killed, and I think this pretty much confirms we have a serial killer on the loose, and guess what guys? I don't think its Gilgamesh with the way he speaks. I know in some past games the serial killer had to meet a certain condition to earn a kill, but I call bulltrout on that. If there is a serial killer, he sure didn't need to act like an idiot or get others to act like him just to get a nightkill. trout, I think that pretty lady Jihl was trying to cast Gilgamesh as a serial killer so he could get the lynch, because you know, since we had two straight nights with two kills. So yeah, I'm gonna pull my super awesome Jecht Shot on that bitch, she certainly deserves a good spanking!
##VOTE: Jihl Nabaat
Gilgamesh...........agrees with...........Jecht..........Jihl Nabaat..............needs to explain..................Gilgamesh...........will not vote.................however............until..........Rajin........explains
Oh and Day 3 will end at 1900 GMT tomorrow (thats 28 hours 35 minutes from this post)
now I have to do 50 push ups. lets hope the next person flips mafia
He's clearly defended Gilgamesh and Sephiroth, but not with Orphan.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] BarthandelusI'm just going to place a vote down right now. I'll change it later if I find a better candidate. My vote will be for Golbez, not only because of his little amount of explanation in the last day, but also because of his most recent post, just a little while back
This, to me, seems like a classic example of "Trying to look like I said something when really I haven't". In addition to what he has done in Day 1, Golbez has yet to say anything of merit, and yet he has posted enough to make his presence known.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Golbez
##Vote: Golbez
Also, to comment on Gilgamesh, we really can't say anything about his role from his posting style. If it's in his role to post like that, that doesn't mean he's a killer. If it's not in his role and he's just posting like that to be funny or something, it doesn't make him a mafia. It doesn't make him a town, either, but it doesn't tip the scales in any way.
As for Orphan, I'd like an explanation on what you mean by Nuclear Reactor. Is that your roleclaim? Also, why wouldn't you use the little time that you have to at least say something of importance? Why haven't you been paying attention to the game thread?
With Sephiroth changing his vote, that doesn't make him a scum. He didn't know that Seymour was a cop, no one did except Seymour. As for why he chose Seymour instead of Golbez, only a lynch for Golbez or a lynch for Sephiroth might possibly tell us the answer to that, which further strengthens my vote for Golbez.
Anyone know what that means? :D
I have VERY BAD internet today! I can't get all my posts in :argh:
1. Anyways here's my thoughts on some people.
Hojo - I believe you could be the lyncher. If you're not then we're going to find out the moment the lyncher decides to reveal himself. But I think we can believe you for now.
Jihl Nabaat - Seeing how you questioned Barthandelus I believe you might have done some justice to yourself but nothing conclusive though.
Siefer - Where is Seifer? (is Timekeeper playing him?) He was nearly lynched on day 1 and now he doesn't even show up.
Gilgamesh and Sephiroth - Seeing how Barthandelus said nice things about you two and not about Orphan makes me question your identities.
2. Now for everyone who voted for Golbez. I'm afraid someone in there is a mason. Why? Because masons can communicate with each other. That means that they probably planned to vote together. However Barthandelus was a lying cheat so he must have tricked him/them to vote for innocent Golbez.
Now the people that voted for Golbez are :
Rajin, Barthandelus, Orphan, Necron.
We know Orphan was an innocent victim. So that leaves Rajin and Necron. One of them is mason probably, the other is mafia or just someone like Orphan who jumped the wagon.
What I believe is, the mafia could have split up. One of them acting with the masons and the others voting someone else. And that someone else could have been Orphan. Which puts me, Fujin and Gabranth into question. But Orphan was killed, so that would help lighten our suspicion, "who in their right mind would kill someone he has voted for?" That's like ultra suspicious. However I know I'm innocent. So for me it only leaves Fujin and Gabranth, for you however it's the three of us :p.
3. About night kills
The mafia did Orphan in that's for sure. But the serial killer or something else did Barthandelus in (why is everyone insisting on the serial killer anyway, why not vigilante?). Now why was Orphan killed? I've been playing as a mafian for 3 games straight so I know that the deaths are usually planned. Night 1 kills are usually the only ones that are random. Was Orphan killed to remove doubt from the people who voted for him? (though that includes innocent me so i don't know why the mafia would do that , but of course I can't prove it)
Though if the mafians are noobs that means the reverse : they killed Orphan to make us three look bad. I doubt it though.
So those are some of my thoughts. I'll try to get the rest in...if the thread ever loads.
Gilgamesh thinks........Orphan.............was killed..........for his...........role..................claim.............................Gilgamesh doesn't get..................why Queen B...............questions Gilgamesh identity.....................Gilgamesh is town...............not............scum............not...........serial killer
Why...................nobody else.................find strange...................Rajin only Golbez voter..............still alive?
There's also Necron...
Gilgamesh sorry.............only read last vote count.............then Rajin & Necron should explain..........confused Necron & OrphanQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen Brahne
At Jecht: Really? Up until I posted no one even commented on two night kills, why would I bring it to everyone's attention if I were the serial killer? Gilgamesh is still posting strangely and has not done as I requested, which is to explain his posting style if he is a Pro Town role.
At Hojo: I didn't get a chance to respond to you before the day ended yesterday but this is what I've thought about and this is my response to your role claim. So what? If we had a Reviver amongst us why would that player waste his ability on bringing back a role that is useless to Town like Lynchee? If the role existed, don't you think the Reviver would have brought our cop back by now? So I can't imagine anyone daft enough to waste his time bringing back a role that has been night killed just so one player can convince us all to lynch them and win the game. So you can go ahead and vote to lynch a dead body if you want, or you can suck it up and help Town pinpoint the Mafia.
At the Masons: This is good news, I am happy that the Mafia Mason was taken out early. You all should have a better understanding about who is who just by reexamining everything Barthandalus.
Now for Barthandalus; I knew something was up with him, the way he bullied Goldez about not contributing and yet not contributing anything himself. One thing though, Goldez could have tied up the vote by placing a vote on Orphan and that would have extended the day, and maybe even saved his life. Everyone has to vote, everyone has to contribute, or you might as well be Mafia fodder.
I am finding the discussions between you two most disturbing. And Gilgamesh, I will have your sister punch you in the dick if you continue to type like that. Now, I don't think that we need to focus on the lynchers of Golbez. It would be folly to assume the mafia definitely had a hand in their lynching. We should be looking at all suspects. Just because a vote didn't lynch someone does not mean that they are not mafia votes.
Well, this game sucks so far. Hmm....
I also find Jihl and Seph suspcious, but who I really want to hear from is Gilgamesh. This game is far too chotic for my dead heart to take. As a sake of organization: Gilgamesh, why are you talking the way you do? If you're a townie there's an admittedly small chance you may have to speak that way, but it's distracting nonetheless. However, it's many a Serial Killer (or Mafia) tactic to speak on such a manner to give people the impression that's what their role does. It's smart! So explain yourself.
You find this discussion disturbing? What discussion disturbs you? The thought that we must look at who voted for who now that we know at least one Mafia alignment? Well, let's look at it:
If we are going to not look at who voted, lets look at who didn't vote. With Barthandalus able to persuade the Masons on how they should vote, maybe Mafia just let the Town decide, after all, none of these non voting roles were in jeopardy.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] The Shadow Lord
I should say, other than Goldez, the non voting posts were not in jeopardy. I already pointed out that Goldez should have voted to save himself.
Indeed. But what I meant by "disturbing" was how easily queen brahne and Gilgy were steering this investigation. Pointing out minor discrepencies but not voting as though they wanted the rest of the town to do the leg work allowing them to lead and have us lynch their desired targets. Like the mafia would do.
Gilgamesh speaks................as Gilgamesh does.................because Gilgamesh wants too.......................................not role related......................just....................Gilgamesh........................Gilgamesh has not voted yet.....................because Gilgamesh............wants to see...........................more conversation......................Gilgamesh could vote Jihl................as Jihl............without evidence....................sees Gilgamesh................as a serial killer.............................but why else................Gilgamesh can direct investigation.....................because town is silent..........................
Bulltrout. I already stated my opinion on Gilgamesh and Sephiroth. And that I am equally suspicious about them because of Barthandelus. I'll only vote after I decide which one.
My post is open to discussion. No one is leading you anywhere.
Jihl's point......................about non voters.....................is very interesting.........................Seifer & Sephiroth..................focuses of conversation Day 1........................but suddenly not....................Gilgamesh isn't the only.......................enigma..................it would appear.............
But if your credibility depended on it wouldn't you stop talking like that?
At Zeromus: Hmmm, well Queen Brahne does make a good point. Barthandalus was a Mafia and a Mason and could have easily persuaded either group to vote in a particular way. The problem is deciphering which group did what, only they know how they acted. Did Barthandalus tell the Mafia to lie low, let the Masons knock off a Townie, or did he sit in the background of the Mason Hall and just inform the Mafia which way the Masons were leaning so they could add to the vote as needed. It is hard to determine from the outside, so what we need is more discussion.
At Jenova: I totally agree, Gilgamesh needs to tell us why he is posting the way he is and stop ignoring our requests for him to explain himself.
Gilgamesh, could you even attempt to make a point that isn't made in half-ellipses half-tomfoolery?
Oh my god can people not see role playing when it's right in front of them, sometimes I actually wonder................why I play this game
Don't roleplay. It's annoying. And I would believe your point if you left the ellipses out of it.
SO, motivate me to do otherwise: ##VOTE: GIRUGAMESH!!!~
You have not really given him a need to feel motivated with your fake vote. :(
Oh my god. This game is ridiculous. :lol:
Okay, I am going to go with a hunch, it may be a bad way to explain it, but if I am right then we have been led quite easily in this game of Villains.
For that (lack of) reason:
##Vote: Queen Brahne
Oh my god, make it stop! :lol:
I don't really think that Gilgamesh is suspicious because of the way he talks to be honest. Because he didn't always use ellipsis and nobody mimicked his manner of speech on day 2 (i did on day 1 though). So to think he's a serial killer just because of that is not enough. He could be a vigilante or perhaps we're completely wrong about this.
I find him suspicious only because he was on Barthandelus's nice side.
Whether you believe.................Gilgamesh.............or not...................is irrelevant......................town needs to stop..............grasping at straws
Really? You're following a hunch, on day 3? After I went through the trouble of rereading the thread over and over in search of clues and laying them out in the open for everyone to think about.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Zeromus
*meanwhile Freya is laughing her ass off*
I would really like to hear Hojo's opinion as he is the only one who I believe to be innocent. Reason : His vote against Ultros was counted by the moderator. (otherwise dd is getting a beating)
I don't see where..........the so-called link..........between Gilgamesh.........& Barthandalus............exists............Barthandalus..........doubts my guilt............and suddenly...........we are linked..............I don't believe..............I addressed..............Barthandalus........until now....................why punish Gilgamesh...........for playing the game...................when others have gone silent.................
While I agreed with Jecht.............you find Gilgamesh..........more suspicious...........then the man..........who votes................then leaves..................
Breaking news: There are two mods.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen Brahne
I know...
@ Gilgamesh. Sorry but I didn't get any of that o.o Men who votes leaves???
Jecht! Jecht voted then left
Leaving does not imply guilt. I was not here at all yesterday because I had farm work to do. That does not make me guilty. Just because Jecht left does not mean he is guilty. Perhaps he has things to do in RL like dissolve a body in acid.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Gilgamesh
The way you speak, Gil, can be significant. Especially considering it's a common and valid way to hide your role.
Yes but given how little he has pointed in this game it doesn't scream innoncence either. Sounds like you're defending him Zeromus..........something to hide maybe?
Quote:
Originally Posted by demondudeBreaking news: There are two mods.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen Brahne
What our dear Queen Brahne is saying is "I am afraid to be eaten by a smurfing giant dragon god, so I will bitch slap you even if it was KD who posted that vote count ^^"Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen Brahne
OK I am going to stand up for Gilgamesh here for one reason, because I know who is playing the role. He is talking like that to piss all of you off. Me especially. He annoys people in RL too by acting in annoying manners. Just leave him to it. But, I still think he could be scum.
Point taken........not proof of guilt........or otherwiseQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
You are not allowed to know other people's accounts~!
And no, it isn't proof. But you would be far more likely to hide a negative role than a positive one.
I figured it out. He is easy to spot. Get over it.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Why would he want to piss us off? People are considering to lynch him for that reason. And if he's town he shouldn't be so suicidal as it's not beneficial for us -.-. I don't get it.
I dreamed this when a slept.
No but he plays like its a game. So he doesn't mind losing. But he enjoys smurfing with everyone here. So the way he types may not be significant.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen Brahne
And why would someone deliberately try to act in a manner that makes their guilt ambigious if they have nothing to hide?
If that's the case, why keep a Saboteur?
And WHY would you try to speak for him?
Point taken, but seriously nobody finds Jecht's behaviour suspicious? Or Seifer or Sephiroth for that matter?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
We do but they sure as hell aren't here to defend themselves.
And I see now you're trying to speak normally. :colbert:
So basically town should vote for me because you don't like the way I play Mafia.........wowQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
We don't like that you're deliberately sabotaging the town, according to your buddy Zermous.
So yeah, that's why everyone votes for people. Your arguments are flimsy.
Because you sucked the fun out of this for me :colbert: See Zeromus this was why I wanted to get a replacement :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
I'd rep that XDQuote:
Originally Posted by KaiserDragon
Jecht is well...a hit and run case. But that's all I can gather about him. He seems to have voted random people.
People not being able to read between the lines doesn't make me a sabotuer. You know what I'm done arguing with you Jenova
##Vote: [M] Jecht
You should be aware of the way you're acting.
And how do you keep being able to talk to Zeromus?
Replacements don't smurf with the town. You'd be disappointed without shenanigans.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] GilgameshBecause you sucked the fun out of this for me :colbert: See Zeromus this was why I wanted to get a replacement :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
WE SHOULDN'T HAVE TO!!! BEING NEEDLESSLY ABSTRACT IS POOR GAMEPLAY!
And now you're avoiding my arguments. Welp, my vote stays.
But it is hella fun to watch. The reason your vote is a bad one is because your vote was for him basically being annoying and unhelpful. This is a wasted vote.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Go back through previous games of mafia here, I'm not the first player to do it. I was being abstract because i felt like it get over it.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
No. It's because when I called him on being annoying and unhelpful he didn't do trout to make anyone think otherwise.
And sure, it may be fun, but it's worthless. Especially when the player concedes as such.
SO!? Then why are you playing? Are you actively trying to smurf over the town?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] GilgameshGo back through previous games of mafia here, I'm not the first player to do it. I was being abstract because i felt like it get over it.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
And yet again somebody needs to be reminded me are playing a game :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
We are playing a game even :lol:
Some people just don't like losing, like mafia. XDQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] GilgameshAnd yet again somebody needs to be reminded me are playing a game :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Yes, yet there are expectations when playing a game. One cannot play a game and wish to actively sabotage the other players' efforts. You can't just play the parts you want to and expect people to like you for it.
I ask you this: Do you care if you live?
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] ZeromusThat would be a weaker reason to vote for Jenova then why they voted for me :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] GilgameshAnd yet again somebody needs to be reminded me are playing a game :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Some people just don't like losing, like mafia. XD
I hate this post so much. :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] ZeromusSome people just don't like losing, like mafia. XDQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] GilgameshAnd yet again somebody needs to be reminded me are playing a game :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Well yeah, it's irritating. You are expecting to play the game properly, so play it. The town is about to lose and you do nothing. That sounds scummy to me.
Number 1 you need to take a chill pill or 10. Number 2 Is that some kind of threat? Have we found our serial killer ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Or rather, on their way to losing.
@Gilgamesh, why did you just try to edit my post in the quote reply?
You need a depressant.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] GilgameshNumber 1 you need to take a chill pill or 10. Number 2 Is that some kind of threat? Have we found our serial killer ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
And no. I'm asking you seriously: Do you care if you win or not?
...*smurfs self*
If we spent as much time arguing as finding mafia town wouldn't be losing! Apart from me is there any other player you find guilty for reasons other than you don't like the way they play mafia ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Oh please, now you're putting words in my mouth. I don't like that you admit you're sabotaging the town and you think I should be okay with that. And then put the heat on me for noting as such. It's weak arguments, this is a game of strategy and you don't play it as such you'll alienate people and have them question your loyalty. ESPECIALLY in a team game.
Zeromus will seem very suspicious depending on how you flip. :D
Don't drag me into this. I said he might be mafia. I simply said his way of typing was designed to annoy us. I have no idea if he is scum or not.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
But now you're defending him and his flimsy arguments. Or I might just be looking to much into you. :lol:
I AM NOT SABOTAGING TOWN. You think I am sabotaging town because you don't like how I play. Get over it vote me if you like I don't care.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Anybody else want to weigh in on Jecht?
I never defended him. I joked along at your rage and I said that his typing was designed to annoy us. I posted earlier he may still be scum.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
GAAHHH SOMEONE WHO MANUFACTURES WEAK ARGUMENTS, POSTS IN A POINTLESS FASHION, AND SUSPECTS EVERYONE WHO TRIES TO "RUIN HIS FUN" IS SABOTAGING WHETHER YOU ARE DOING IT DELIBERATELY OR NOT
djgasdbh,fhesfse,fhasejk
Could we please here from someone else? Am I being unreasonable or what?
I'm the bomb.
A little unreasonable. But I see your point. We need to focus on a proper investigation that arguing about posting styles.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Smurf off. We're busy.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] The Shadow Lord
Well, I know you think I'm being unreasonable. But can you at least admit Gil's defenses are flimsy and needlessly accusatory? Do you think I'm suspicious?
It takes a lot of effort to play badly.
I don't think you're suspicious but you certainly need some prozacQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
I think everyone is suspicious. But why have we not taken a look at inactives. They may be active and not posting. Seriously.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Kefka, Seifer & Sephiroth anyone?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] ZeromusI think everyone is suspicious. But why have we not taken a look at inactives. They may be active and not posting. Seriously.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
There's a bunch of inactives. I think Judge Gabranth is particularly suspicious. Come, Gabranth! Prove your guilt!
I guess I should do this: ##Unvote: GIRUGAMESH!!!!
Seifer, Sephiroth, Kefka, and Gabranth! COme out and plaaaa-yaaay~!
Gilgamesh has 666 posts. That's suspicious!
Perhaps a few votes on one of them could get them out of hiding quicker? I would add Kuja to that list also
The actual number of the beast is 616. So not really.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen Brahne
Oh my god not this again :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen Brahne
I'm going to vote for Gabranth.
##Vote: Gabranth
What if I told you I had a way to determine he may be Mafia?
...seriously?
Then I would be interested yet doubtful. Caution and critical thinking powers ACTIVATE!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
I would be very very interested so interested I'll change my voteQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
##unvote: [M] Jecht
##Vote: [M] Judge Gabranth
You're pulling our leg right? If that's so why not vote from the beginning?
Number 1 To angry at me to focus Number 2 He may be indirectly claiming an investigative roleQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen Brahne
The way my role works he could have easily been someone else. I decided to gun for Gil in attempt to fuel discussion to no avail.
So, with nothing to lose, I present you this: I am the Chosen One.
I can use a night power on someone every night and get a random role's power on them. Last night I got Watcher and used it on Oprhan. Gabranth entered his house. Naturally, it would be likely to assume he did the killing, making him likely Serial Killer or Mafia.
You realise if we take you at your word and you are wrong, you will be confirmed mafia and instant retribution will be had.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Chosen one huh?
And what did you get on night 1?
Okay I'm uneasy at this given that all of a sudden you have decided to share. But given that it also sounds a bit like a modified Jack of all trades I'll humor youQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Night One I abstained from doing anything in the hope I wouldn't get a killing role. Night 2 I got Faith Healer and used it on Fujin.
Jack of all trade, Master of Bates.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] GilgameshOkay I'm uneasy at this given that all of a sudden you have decided to share. But given that it also sounds a bit like a modified Jack of all trades I'll humor youQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
If you want you can lynch Gabranth and see for yourself.
Or do nothinhg. :lol:
And again, I'm not 100% sure of anything, but seeing he's the ONLY person in Orphan's house he probably did it.
Risky but I like itQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Liar Liar Pants on Fire!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
There's only been two nights. If you didn't use it on night one and you used Faith Healer on night 2...then when did you watch Gabranth?
Night 2.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen BrahneLiar Liar Pants on Fire!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
There's only been two nights. If you didn't use it on night one and you used Faith Healer on night 2...then when did you watch Gabranth?
You sound Like Shattered Dreamer in The Dynasty Warriors mafia "Liar Liar Pants on Fire" I mean.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen BrahneLiar Liar Pants on Fire!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
There's only been two nights. If you didn't use it on night one and you used Faith Healer on night 2...then when did you watch Gabranth?
If Gabranth did kill Orphan he is not the serial killer, because the Mafia would not have taken out the Mafia Mason, that was there most powerful role against Town.
This is an interesting role claim Jenova, I too, want to know what you did with your role on Night 1.
Well that's embarassing, no wonder I thought I did nothing on Night 1. :lol:
You had 2 night actions in the same night? I smell Mafia.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] JenovaNight 2.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Queen BrahneLiar Liar Pants on Fire!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
There's only been two nights. If you didn't use it on night one and you used Faith Healer on night 2...then when did you watch Gabranth?
I made a mistake. I protected Fujin Night 1. xDDDD I thought it was Day 4 because I forgot Day 0 wasn't Day 1. I considered doing nothing on Night 0 but it didn't happen.
My mistake. :lol:
You expect me to believe that? :lol:
Free in two hours will post then
Yes, yes I do, actually. :lol:
For serious, I wouldn't get myself lynched because I forgot basic arithmetic.
I love it when I find a gazillion posts between the one I am responding to and when mine finally posts. I agree with Queen Brahne: Jenova, you just said you did nothing Night 1 and received Faith Healer on Night 2 and used it on Fujin after originally saying you saw Gabranth go to Orphan's house because you received the role ability of Watcher. So one of those is a lie.
There was no night 0 in case you decide that was when you abstained from using your ability ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
I recall deliberating on what to do with my role Night 0. Unfortunately I forgot there was no Night 0.
Seriously, I smurfed up elementary math but that doesn't make me Mafia.
There was no Night 0, Day 0 flowed smoothly into Day 1 with no break for night.
Also have the memory of a retarded walrus.
Damn, I seem to be one step behind instead of on top of the conversation :/
Yes, I remember thinking there would be a Night 0 for some reason and choosing to abstain that night. But there was no Night 0 and I counted it anyway for some reason. :lol:
So let me get this straight, you choose another player during the night phase & by doing so you perform a random night action on them.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Or is it that the player you choose you get to use their power the following night?
Please give me a chance. Lynch me tomorrow if you want, but please give me a chance to prove my role. I swear I'll follow through with my claims.
I get a random power and used it in a night. I discover the role I got for the night and discover the "results."
Lu Bei smurfed up the math in the last Mafia and he was scum. I smell your fear. Smells like cheese.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
This seems a bit random, you get that don't you Jenova?
Provolone or Harvati?
Hell, I know I look really stupid right now, but at least keep me around until tomorrow. Hell, you can even give me someone to use my Night Action on!
Well it wouldn't hurt to investigate Gabranth's behaviour a bit. I mean why choose him out of ever other candidate?
But would a mafia go ape $hit at me for the reason Jenova went ape $hit at me?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] ZeromusLu Bei smurfed up the math in the last Mafia and he was scum. I smell your fear. Smells like cheese.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova
Coming from Gilgamesh himself! :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Gilgamesh
Yes, I am aware I have no real way to prove myself, other than lynching Gabranth but you guys probably don't wanna do that now. xD I got a powerful role, and I really don't wanna waste it. :(
I say use it on either Seifer, Sephiroth or Kuja given they were the other candiatesQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Jenova