Mindsmurf Mafia - GAME OVER - Town Win - The Triple H gods are the heroes!

I don't think you are, because my vote on Nyx did not count.

The next person to vote will be forced to vote Nyx though.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Hebe

Why would you want to lynch Nyx? Just because she voted for Persephone? I don't really have a read on her, has she done anything, really?

---

She created the argument that was used for the lynch. I already explained how it was faulty logic. I'll grab the quote.

I reread the bandwagon rules...

Quote:

---

Each vote made today must be a 'bandwagon' vote, that is, a vote made for the same player as the previous vote, unless that previous vote was itself a bandwagon vote. Also, you cannot unvote until another person has voted after you.

---

So, Hygieia unvoting was legal and then she voted for Apollo again, forcing someone else to vote for Apollo, right?

Also, I'm going to bed. Feel free to ask me :bou::bou::bou::bou:, or explain stuff to me, I'll look at it in the morning.

Alright, so you're unvoting Apollo and voting Nyx? Just making sure because I think it makes a difference with the rules.

Here is is

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Hygieia

The arguments against Persephone are flawed. Here is why.

She saved Hades. So she must be scum.

See the flaw? We do not know what team Hades is on. If you want to go based on the numbers, there is a good chance he is town, as there must be more town members than mafia members.

So a bandwagon occurs on the flawed logic. Persephone is now caught trying to defend herself from it.

This situation does not make her scum. Nor does it clear her from the possibility. It does not give a good reason for lynching though.

Also in case this post is skimmed I'm also calling out Nyx for starting this chain.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Helios

I reread the bandwagon rules...

Quote:

---

Each vote made today must be a 'bandwagon' vote, that is, a vote made for the same player as the previous vote, unless that previous vote was itself a bandwagon vote. Also, you cannot unvote until another person has voted after you.

---

So, Hygieia unvoting was legal and then she voted for Apollo again, forcing someone else to vote for Apollo, right?

---

Nope, because it matched the previous vote.

Basically the rule is you can only vote for someone of your choice if the last 2 votes were for the same person. Also you must wait for someone to vote before you can unvote.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Hygieia

Here is is

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Hygieia

The arguments against Persephone are flawed. Here is why.

She saved Hades. So she must be scum.

See the flaw? We do not know what team Hades is on. If you want to go based on the numbers, there is a good chance he is town, as there must be more town members than mafia members.

So a bandwagon occurs on the flawed logic. Persephone is now caught trying to defend herself from it.

This situation does not make her scum. Nor does it clear her from the possibility. It does not give a good reason for lynching though.

Also in case this post is skimmed I'm also calling out Nyx for starting this chain.

---

---

Hmm, I was caught in that too... I thought of all the possibilities we would have if Persephone would have turned mafia and I guess it kinda blinded me, sorry.

Also, to clear up any confusion...

Person 1 votes for person A
Person 2 must then vote for person A
Person 3 can vote for anyone. If they vote for person A, person 4 can vote for anyone. If they vote for Person B, or whatever, Person 4 must then vote for the same person as Person 3.

Now to bed.

And this is still not answering the question of unvoting, then revoting. Technically, that's following the rules. You can unvote then vote for the same person, forcing the next vote to match yours. Again.

If I understand it correctly, Person 4 must also vote for Person A since they're forced to follow the last legitimate vote.

We need answers. I will not me mindsmurfed!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Helios

And this is still not answering the question of unvoting, then revoting. Technically, that's following the rules. You can unvote then vote for the same person, forcing the next vote to match yours. Again.

---

If I had done that and voted for Nyx then that would have been fine and forced a vote on Nyx.

But since the vote before mine was also on Apollo it did not lock the next vote to be for Apollo.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Helios

If I understand it correctly, Person 4 must also vote for Person A since they're forced to follow the last legitimate vote.

We need answers. I will not me mindsmurfed!

---

I'll say it again. If the two most recent votes are for the same person you can vote for anybody.

If they are for different people you must copy the previous vote.

You can not unvote if you have the most recent vote. (This rule is why my vote on Nyx doesn't count)

The next vote must be on Nyx

To keep it easier we can keep a running list.

When you vote please add the name of the person you are voting for to the end.

Apollo
Apollo
Nyx

What in the bloody mother smurfer. You're saying your vote on Nyx doesn't count, then saying that the next vote must be for Nyx. Makes no sense.

Here's what happened:

Hygieia votes Apollo.
Artemis votes Apollo. Voting is fair game now.
Hygieia unvotes. Then revotes Apollo. Which is totally legal.

You can't unvote now and the next vote must be for Apollo.

Also... Red Apple might not of being able to get on yet.

My vote on Nyx does not count. Yours does though.

Red Apple?