What is an RPG?

Starts do not make a game an RPG. just because you cant pull up a character sheet and see them does not mean they aren't there. Link has hit points, his weapons do a certain amount of damage. Zelda and other RPGs function the same way. Things are based on a set of stats. Zelda just isn't very open-ended. The most open-ended RPG i have played would have to be the Fallout series. You could do absolutly anything in those games. But open-endness doesn't define an RPG either. The SIMS is very open but it is hardly an RPG. The biggest problem is Adventure games and RPG look so similar it can be hard to distinguish the two.

Morrowind is a rpg and u can decide on what he looks like and what he wears and how he fights.

Peace Out ?M?y?s?t?e?r?i?o?u?s? :Juggalo 4-Life:

I think you mean *gigallo
Maybe Im wrong. I dont now what a Juggalo is...

I always figured a Role Playing Game was just that- a game where the main attraction of it was taking on the role of a character. Sure, in many other games you do this, but that's not them main or dominant focus.

In FFVII for example, the main focus of the game was taking on the role of Cloud Strife, ex-SOLDIER, turned mercenary, in his struggle with his inner demons and his overcoming of them in order to save the Planet.

In a game like Halo, you take on the role of a particular character, yes, but that is not the main focus of the game. So in general, a game like Halo, woul not be consider a RPG.

RPG's are the little, now huge category of games, that's specifically focused on things that were smaller elements of most games at that time. Sure, Crash Bandicoot, for example, had a story and a character you took on the role of, but that sure wasn't the focus of the game- it was a platform game, which had you going through levels, collecting inane items for special bonuses, etc.

Why are some of the people here trying to say that RPG's do and don't have certain characteristics? RPG's are kind of a hodge-podge of many, many genres all rolled into one, but with a predominant focus on story, or the role of the main character, and the events around him or her. FFVII for example, by the elements in it could be considered the following:

Racing Game- Chocobo Racing
Snowboarding Game... heh
Shooter- Speed Square
Adventure- Looking around and exploring a world, collecting items
Strategy/War Game- Fort Condor, Submarine Game, and the battles themselves in a way.

There's probably more categories I could throw in there, but FFVII is NOT any of these genres because those parts of the game are obviously not the main focus. They use elements from other rather linear genres to tell the story of the game, or the character who you control and take on the role of.

Zelda is an RPG in a way. It's not strictly an RPG, and is more of a dungeon crawler/adventure game, but it's story is still a fairly large focus of the game. Heck, I could be wrong, but I think the creators of it even label it an RPG.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ljkkjlcm9

That's it, I'm getting tired of always arguing with people about what is an RPG.

Then why are you posting a topic about the subject, which will obviously lead to debate, disagreements, and yes, arguments? You have an idea of what an RPG is to you, but if you shut out other's ideas of what they think it is, you're only asking for arguments. People have their own opinion just like you, why fight them on it? ;)

Ya, and what about wrestling or sports games? In wrestling games you can mold a wrestler that you create into whatever you want, what moves they want, etc. How is that different from an RPG in your logic?