P4 - Mafia XIX Game Thread - [Game Over] Mafia DOMINATION

Printable View

Show 200 post(s) from this thread on one page

04-13-2011, 03:49 AM
[M] Greg - Hot Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Morooka

Nice to see you too, cabbage breath.

I can accept no one wanting to be the hammer, Adachi, and agree it was a tough call. Thanks for at least stepping up to the plate, Rise.

Chie, on Day 1 almost anything's fair game. Not voting is a sin though, you gotta contribute cause that's all we got if we want to eventually lynch the right people.

Can we all agree that there's at least one scum in the voters for Teddie?

What about the voters for Mitsuo? Who died maybe didn't matter if they both were innocents looking gulty.

True, I kinda wish I'd not voted at all. I hate day 1
04-13-2011, 03:52 AM
[M] Adama

Perfectly understandable. A vote yesterday would have gone in one of two directions though, a vote directed at Mitsuo/Teddie or a wasted vote for someone else. Voting for either Mitsuo or Teddie would have been either a tiebreaker or a tiemaker depending on when the vote was cast. Voting for someone else would likely just be for the sake of casting a vote. With the way some people play, either of those could potentially be seen as suspicious.

It was clear either Teddie or Mitsuo was going to end up getting lynched, I had no reason to speed that along.
04-13-2011, 03:53 AM
[M] Athena

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Morooka

Can we all agree that there's at least one scum in the voters for Teddie?

What about the voters for Mitsuo? Who died maybe didn't matter if they both were innocents looking gulty.

I agree with you. It's very likely that there was at least one scum vote on each of them. But I can't help but thinking the mafia sat silent as the town tore itself apart. Paranoid, maybe, but you don't survive on Inaba Police without being paranoid.

I'm not roleclaiming cop. If anyone thinks I'm roleclaiming cop without the text "Hey guys, I'm the cop", I will permaban you.
04-13-2011, 03:54 AM
[M] Greg - Hot Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Adachi

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Morooka

Can we all agree that there's at least one scum in the voters for Teddie?

What about the voters for Mitsuo? Who died maybe didn't matter if they both were innocents looking gulty.

I agree with you. It's very likely that there was at least one scum vote on each of them. But I can't help but thinking the mafia sat silent as the town tore itself apart. Paranoid, maybe, but you don't survive on Inaba Police without being paranoid.

I'm not roleclaiming cop. If anyone thinks I'm roleclaiming cop without the text "Hey guys, I'm the cop", I will permaban you.

are you Jiro?

[jiro]Are you Jiro? - J[/jiro]
04-13-2011, 03:55 AM
[M] Harry - Dad's Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Chie

Perfectly understandable. A vote yesterday would have gone in one of two directions though, a vote directed at Mitsuo/Teddie or a wasted vote for someone else. Voting for either Mitsuo or Teddie would have been either a tiebreaker or a tiemaker depending on when the vote was cast. Voting for someone else would likely just be for the sake of casting a vote. With the way some people play, either of those could potentially be seen as suspicious.

It was clear either Teddie or Mitsuo was going to end up getting lynched, I had no reason to speed that along.

Very true, people are already looking at the participants who threw a random vote on me; voting so late always arouses suspicion. No way around that sadly.
04-13-2011, 03:56 AM
[M] Greg - Hot Dad

jen, thats your regular account
04-13-2011, 03:56 AM
[M] Athena

My real account is irrelevant to this game, however one thing is clear man; do not pretend that Jiro dude is anywhere near as cool as me :colbert: I will permaban you both if you :bou::bou::bou::bou: me off.
04-13-2011, 03:57 AM
[M] Greg - Hot Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Adachi

My real account is irrelevant to this game, however one thing is clear man; do not pretend that Jiro dude is anywhere near as cool as me :colbert: I will permaban you both if you :bou::bou::bou::bou: me off.

lolololol!
04-13-2011, 03:59 AM
[M] Harry - Dad's Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Adachi

My real account is irrelevant to this game, however one thing is clear man; do not pretend that Jiro dude is anywhere near as cool as me :colbert: I will permaban you both if you :bou::bou::bou::bou: me off.

The Inaba police is serious business.
04-13-2011, 04:00 AM
[M] Caprica

Tip: Change the setting of your mafia account to use a different skin. That way you wont accidentally post in the wrong account.
04-13-2011, 04:01 AM
[M] Mom – Host

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Mitsuo

are you Jiro?

Please don't ask about anyone's identities. That's not how we play around here.
04-13-2011, 04:04 AM
[M] Aaron

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Rise

So because I have to work and because I wanted to contribute, this makes me guilty?

It makes you a person of interest.

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Adachi

Yukkiko, I resent your grasping at straws comment. We all know Day One is a bitch, and you didn't particularly contribute anything. No need to rag on our poor luck.

Oh, all I meant was that nobody could possibly do any better than that. Day one being a bitch and all!
04-13-2011, 04:04 AM
[M] Gaius

What I'm not so secretly saying is odds are there's a scum in each group.

[M] Mitsuo, [M] Souji, [M] Nanako, [M] Kanji, [M] Shu, [M] Rise
[M] Yukiko, [M] Adachi, [M] Namatame, ~~[M] Teddie, [M] Yosuke~~

Mitsuo, Souji, Nanako, Kanji, Shu, and Rise make it hard to figure out which. Can we rule out Rise since the scum might've thought who died didn't matter? Mitsuo isn't a top suspect in my vote and also was the first voter, mafia love joining the wagon, not starting one. So I'm looking at Souji, Nanako, Kanji, and Shu as one suspect pool. Anyone agree that this logic is okay? Not great, but alright?

The second pool is easy cause we got two dead guys in it. Yukiko, Adachi, and Namatame are just three names. If we go with my reasoning to let off Mitsuo off the hook for now, then we let Yukiko off it too. So then were down to Adachi and Namatame. I like these odds, but it feels wrong for reasons relating to the actual video game: (SPOILER)antagonists as scum? come onnnn.. But it fits as the child of my bigger theory of scum joining in on the big votes of townies, so I'm still selling it.
04-13-2011, 04:06 AM
[M] Adama

If you have two browsers (like anyone that doesn't use IE on a Windows machine does) you could probably use the second browser to avoid further confusion.
04-13-2011, 04:06 AM
[M] Harry - Dad's Dad

Hmm the discussion seems to be dying... that's no good.
Well Im going to go ahead and vote for who I was going to earlier
##vote: Rise

Same reason as before

Quote:

Rise you seem to be getting defensive and even trying to draw attention away from you to Hanako. Maybe I'm thinking too much into this but in mafia it's better to think too much than not at all.

Show 200 post(s) from this thread on one page