Kinda late now... :(
Kinda late now... :(
Doh voted too late. XD
oh and any posts that occur in the next 1 minute are fine, but after that there will be a penalty of a vote on the person next day. I need to wait for den and I dont want you guys spamming up the thread.
Then what was the reason for Myrtle to act like an idiot? :greenie:
My partner was the idiot, besides maybe we weren't tellign the truth maybe we knew all along. ;)
EDIT: Every clown has his tricks. Even though I don't know what my partner is talkigna bout.
EDIT: We will die tomorrow anyway, becuase of you so we may as well tell them.
Ah I completely forgot about the flavor!
Crabbe was being backed into the girls bathroom, every single person against him. While they were in there, they were greatly annoyed by a ghost in the bathroom. Moaning myrtle. Talking to herself and claiming all sorts of things. They were about to kill her, but theuy realized she was already dead and turned to Crabbe again. He was backed against the sink. Voldemort says something is some odd hissing noise and Crabbe falls into the chamber of secrets, to his death.
oh you guys.
Crabbe was indeed a Shrink, played by Xalioniaf. Thanks for playing!
Night actions! NAO.
um let's go with approximately 10 or 11 more hours for Night 2. or when all actions are in, of course.
The dead of the night.
A muffled voice: "Goodbye, Nymphadora."
A shout: "DON'T CALL ME NYMPHAAAAAAAAAAAAH"
A noise: *shunk*
Another noise: *thump*
A head, rolling on the ground.
Tonks, a Mason Doctor with the caveat that she cannot protect any masons, was decapitated by a sword night 2. Tonks was played by Jojee!
Elsewhere, Sirius Black was sneaking around in dog form, sniffing out clues and trying to keep a low profile after being pegged as Ginny's killer. Walking down a narrow alleyway, he sensed danger, so he changed back into human form and pulled out his wand. When he reached the end of the alleyway, he peered around the corner. As he was doing this, a mysterious person clad entirely in black lifted a giant cartoon hammer and bludgeoned him on the head.
Sirius Black, a Mafia Goon, was played by GoldenBoko!
Thanks for playing, both of you!
Day 3 begins now and will go for approximately 24 hours again. With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.
And I am again requesting a thread title change!
Ah, a goon is dead! But we lost a mason-doctor...
Sirius WAS guilty! Woah.
Sucks that we lose such a powerful town role though. =( I'm not sure if Joy was playing her best game though.
Now the question is what do we do today?
WHAT DO WE DO ABOUT MYRTLE?
Also, I'm going back to read Sirius' posts.
I suppose Sirius was the one who PM'ed the mod to kill Ginny, my sweet furry love?
Hi.
I'm the cop and Cho Chang is a member of the mafia. Allow me to elaborate.Yup. C-o-p. I copied that trick from other people here, but I also tried to be very subtle about it. It's very intentional though I assure you, and not a coincidence.Quote:
Originally Posted by Neville Longbottom
Investigations.
Night 1: Neville Longbottom. Result? Town.
I checked myself out first as a sanity test, for obvious reasons. Because of the result, we can conclude I am either naive or a regular cop.
Night 2: Cho Chang. Result? Scum.
Hence Cho Chang must be scum. Yes, there is the possibility of her being a miller or something like that, but at the end of the day, because miller is a rare role (and there would probably only be one of them), the chances are much higher of her being mafia.
Why did I investigate Cho Chang? Well!Remember this?Quote:
Originally Posted by Neville
I don't trust any of you. I know if I am influenced by the town as to who to investigate, there will be mafia corruption in that decision. If I, alone, choose it, it's 100% town decided. Anyway, why not Sirius Black? I believed his claim. I was wrong, and I admit that. But it seems somebody else took care of him so it's all good! :D Why not Moaning Myrtle? She is an idiot and I assumed she would be lynched soon. I did not want to waste a night on someone who was probably going to be lynched, especially when I had already used up night 1 on a sanity test.
Why Cho Chang? I think she is the pairing Psychotic/Levian and as such are key players who needed to be investigated. I got that vibe from her anyway. I know it's not entirely fair to try to work out who people are, so I am sorry. Maybe I am wrong, maybe I am right. Either way, it doesn't matter who she actually is, because the investigation has shown she is mafia.
So please, vote for Cho. Any more protective roles besides Tonks? I need you tonight. If there are any other cops out there, then feel free to investigate me tonight if you don't trust me, but try to remain hidden until I am dead, because we don't want to give our protective roles too many targets.
##vote: Cho Chang.
Bien, il je semble ne sait pas quelque chose. J'ai choisi de protéger et roleblock Sirius, pourtant il finit par mort, quel est en haut avec moi ?
Eh, Cho? Explain yourself before I vote.
I'm going to say this in big bold letters so no one misses it.
MYRTLE IS NOT, I REPEAT, IS NOT A PARTNERSHIP, BUT RATHER A SOLO PLAYER. S/HE HAS BE TRYING TO "EDIT" HIS/HER POSTS TO LOOK LIKE A DIALOGUE BETWEEN TWO "COLORS" IS OCCURING. THE PROBLEM WITH HIS/HER EDITING, IS THAT ALL THE "EDITING" IS DONE BEFORE THE INITAL POST. With as rapidly as I have been refreshing this page, there is NO way the posts have been edited three times in a 2 second span.
S/he is trying to look like a partnership relation to explain why s/he sucks at this game, such as his/her tomfoolery concerning his/her role.
Whether or not I think s/he's mafia yet is to be decided, but I don't want you to be misled thinking it's two people!! :mad2:
OK. Before I say anything, I promised my role, and my role I shall give. I was given the simple role of Doctor. Since Crabbe said I was insane yesterday, I must be an Insane Doctor. I didn't want to say anything about it because if Crabbe was mafia I would be waiving a flag saying "Look Mafia, here is your doctor waiting to be shot"
Who did I protect? Night 1 I protected myself, because I feel that a doctor becomes more valuable after each day. Luckily I didn't kill myself.
Night 2 I chose to protect Nobody, because I knew I was insane and didn't want to risk killing anybody. I aslo have decided to not protect anybody else from now on, because I don't want to risk killing the power roles accidently.
So Sirius was mafia, and I trusted him with his plausible roleclaim. I'm a bit shocked, but that has passed, because only scum kills my little sister!
Oh my god. Everyone. Stop roleclaiming. Please. I'm dying here.
Ohhhh! Roleclaim!
I was looking at things and really didn't get anything from Sirius.
The biggest flag raised on Filch, who seemed to appear and vote and disappear.
And I have no idea what to make of your role claim Neville. I'd like to see what Cho has to say, but I will admit, Neville makes some sense, and Cho has more suspicious posts then Neville.
The problem, here, are the ramifications. Though right after I type that, maybe it wasn't a bad idea. If we get Cho, and she flips scum, Neville gets protection. If she's not, Neville dies, but that doesn't make much sense, does it?
Ooh, man, Myrtle's been lying?
I agree with you even though is hypocritical of me because what I have just done. I had a very good reason for it. I don't think Ron should have claimed.Quote:
Originally Posted by Luna
I know I have been quiet over the past two days and that was a part of my plan. I did not want to draw attention to myself so that I would not be a mafia target until I had found a mafia member.
If anybody has questions for me, now is the time.
Woah, I click Refresh and there is a Cop Roleclaim.
So here are my thoughts on who to vote for.
Myrtle: the crazy ghost who is only pulling out attention away from actual discussion. active, but so far completely useless.
Cho Chang: Accused of being scum by the Cop, and barely active.
Also to help us think, here are the two final votecounts, with colors added to show scum/town for all confirmed people. (Only dead people)
Quote:
Day 1
Bellatrix Lestrange (5): Sirius Black, Buckbeak, Ginny Weasley, Hermione Granger, VoldemortSeverus SnapeGinny Weasley
(4): Dobby, Albus Dumbledore, Gregory Goyle, Rubeus Hagrid,Luna Lovegood
Mr. Filch (2): Vincent Crabbe, Bellatrix Lestrange,Voldemort,Ron Weasley
Voldemort (1): Ron Weasley
Cho Chang (1): Draco Malfoy
Moaning Myrtle (1): Remus Lupin
Rubeus Hagrid (1): Dudley Dursley
Dudley Dursley (1): Luna Lovegood
Neville Longbottom (1): Severus Snape
Hermione Granger (1): Neville Longbottom
Tonks (1): Cho Chang,Dudley Dursley
Peter Pettigrew (1): Tonks,Remus Lupin
Ron Weasley (0):Voldemort,Ginny Weasley,Luna Lovegood
Draco Malfoy (0):Hermione Granger,Albus Dumbledore,Dobby
Severus Snape (0):Remus Lupin
Remus Lupin (0):Luna Lovegood
Albus Dumbledore (0):Luna Lovegood,Severus Snape
Quote:
Day 2
Vincent Crabbe (11): Buckbeak, Luna Lovegood, Dobby, Dudley Dursley, Vincent Crabbe, Mr. Filch, Moaning Myrtle, Ron Weasley, Remus Lupin, Sirius Black, Voldemort,Severus Snape,Hermione Granger
Moaning Myrtle (1): Tonks,Sirius Black,Voldemort,Remus Lupin,Moaning MyrtleRon Weasley
Cho Chang (1): Draco Malfoy
Sirius Black (0):Vincent Crabbe
Mr. Filch (0):Remus Lupin,Buckbeak
Dudley Dursley (0):Voldemort
Ron Weasley (0):Vincent Crabbe,Moaning Myrtle
Peter Pettigrew (0):Tonks
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Luna Lovegood
You started it. ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by One Ms Luna Lovegood in post #2
I promised I would share my role with you all if Crabbe died, so I did. I keep my promises.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Neville Longbottom
So many roleclaims! Who to believe?
I figured there was something fishy about Sirius because his roleclaim was just too convenient to be true, but I don't know if I believe Neville. You weren't in any danger, so why did you claim Cop?
I do kind of get bad vibes from Chang though. She slips away too much, same with Filch. Myrtle, I side with Voldemort on your multiple personality disorder thing...I think there's only one of you, and I feel less inclined to believe a word you say because of all your roleclaims.
I think Lupin can be trusted, but I'm not sure. I don't get anything bad from him. But, I'm kind of iffy on Voldemort. Just a gut feeling...for now.
I missed coloring one name on the day 2 vote tally, so now I need to fix it
Quote:
Day 2
Vincent Crabbe (11): Buckbeak, Luna Lovegood, Dobby, Dudley Dursley, Vincent Crabbe, Mr. Filch, Moaning Myrtle, Ron Weasley, Remus Lupin, Sirius Black, Voldemort,Severus Snape,Hermione Granger
Moaning Myrtle (1): Tonks,Sirius Black,Voldemort,Remus Lupin,Moaning MyrtleRon Weasley
Cho Chang (1): Draco Malfoy
Sirius Black (0):Vincent Crabbe
Mr. Filch (0):Remus Lupin,Buckbeak
Dudley Dursley (0):Voldemort
Ron Weasley (0):Vincent Crabbe,Moaning Myrtle
Peter Pettigrew (0):Tonks
I claimed because I had found mafia with my investigation. What is the point in the town having a cop if the cop does not tell the town when they have found mafia?Quote:
Originally Posted by Draco
@Buckbeak: Who do you find to be suspicious right now?
@Neville: Good point, my friend.
That's a few investigation roles. You've got The blabbermouth, which tells who killed the player. Shrink, who tells if someone is insane or not that can lead to a mafia. And a cop, who says they aren't insane and they are investigating. PLUS we have masons running about. That's one beefed up town. Either the mafia is big or they are powerful OR LoM's setup is kinda screwy.
IF Neville is the cop and not insane then our shrink may have been right about Ron being mafia. Ron seems pretty guilty to me. Tonks was a doctor and a mason, I doubt they'd have made her insane too. So with an insane doc and an insane cop out of the possiblity i'm thinking Ron is mafia too. If Neville is telling the truth then I think we might have our last few mafia members.
WHOA refreshed and Ron makes a role claim.
I still doubt Ron is a doctor. Why would they include two doctors? As I said, the mafia needs to have something to them. Thats still a lot of roles town side. So far confirmed are Masons, Doctor, and two investigation roles.
I think we should think about other reasons why Cho is mafia besides just what Neville says. While the role claim is believable we should still try to find our own reasons. Also we should avoid a speed lynch so we can find more things out.
I still think ron is scummy though. SOOO...
##Vote: Ronald Weasley
At first, I was suspicious of Sirious, but I have to say that I had made up my mind that his outrageous roleclaim was true. Of course, that was before he flipped scum.
I need to be less trusting.
>.<
I'm having trouble dealing with all the roleclaims, but I'm especially unnerved at Ron. Myrtl's just a given, even if there isn't a completely decisive way to determine whether *they* have even muttered truth or not (but it doesn't make a difference anyway), although I'm not sure I think you're MAFIA or not. I don't think it's possible to not be suspicious of you though. You just confuse the hell out of me!
D:<
Maybe I'm just completely overwhelmed by the massive amount of roleclaimness, but, to me, Ron's roleclaim comes with very little credibility. Crabbe was warning us about you, and he flipped Shrink, just like he said. Now you're going for Insane Doctor....
All the roleclaims are clouding my judgement, but wouldn't you have killed yourself the first night if you were Insane?
I've had my eye on Cho from near the beginning, and Neville's roleclaim is pretty stable in my book, though, with Sirius's recent flip, I'll have trouble trusting anyone for a while.
No votes yet for me >.<
p.s. Roleclaims must be contageous. I hope I don't catch them.
D:
EDIT: Cleared up some doubt about Neville.
I understand exactly where you are coming from. Since I didn't make the setup I can't say for sure why there is so many power roles. The only reasoning for myself and Tonks both as doctors is that I am either a doctor or a vigilante, and the one I am is completely random.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Rubeus Hagrid
Wow. Writing that made me think about my role in a whole new fashion. I am like a vigilante, only half the time though. I like the sound of that.
But it makes me wonder who is killing the mafia at night. It's not me, thats for sure.
I do not want a free-riding Mafia member, i.e. Plum Kitaki from the last game.
##Vote-Cho Chang
You have filled the strategy that causes the town to lose. I do not want us to make the same mistake again.
It's a 50/50 chance. I got lucky and protected myself and didn't kill myself instead.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Luna Lovegood
Does anyone here speak French, BTW?
It seems to me that Myrtle is worthy of slight suspicion... I am not entirely certain why s/he would try to make everyone believe that s/he would be multiple players, but it seems that way.
I'm not certain how many protective roles there usually are, but I do know that Mafia has doctors, too. Since one town doctor has already been killed, it is probably a slim chance that there are multiple...
As to Cho, she does seem to come and go an awful lot. She hasn't seemed to contribute too much, aside from votes, but then, Filch is the same...
So, for now, I have quite a few people I am looking at, I suppose...
Buckbeak:
De la curiosité simple, j'ai voulu essayer de traduire vos postes dans le français. Je ne suis pas entièrement certain si vous êtes véridiques, mais pour maintenant, je tiens peu de soupçon sur vous. À mon opinion personnelle je dirais pour utiliser votre rôle sur Neville, doit Cho être lynché et vous révéler être l'écume. C'est simplement mon opinion comme un townie. Malheureusement, je n'ai aucune adresse spéciale, à ce titre, je ne peux pas aider beaucoup.
French is not a language to be spoken around me. >:O
So yeah, kindly keep it English plzkthx
Intelligent, Dobby. Très intelligent. Je l'ai l'intention d'utiliser sur le Neville, je trouve sa réclamation pour être plus de beliviable que Ron, et Cho agit beaucoup comme Kitaki de Prune. Donc il travaille bien.
Pour le rapport, je suprised mon français était assez bon être utilisé sur un traducteur. Mon français est rouillé.
EDIT-Alright, Harry. No more.
Je parle un peu de français.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Buckbeak
That being said, please keep your comments in English! :D
@Ron - So you're really not efficient as a protective role OR a killing role.
Assuming you're telling the truth, that is. You have to understand that you look really suspicious, so don't take it harshly (harshness will be saved until someone has decisive evidence that you're mafia). Innocent until proven guilty. I'm still not sure if I believe you or not though.
I'm so unsure right now >.<
Luna agrees with Luna :D!
Buckbeak:
I don't really know the person you are talking about, but I agree, Neville is a tad more believable than Ron, though it is true that Ron said his role would be revealed if it turned out that Crabbe was who he claimed to be. Crabbe was already investigating Ron and was hinting that Ron was either a Doctor or perhaps a Cop.
If Neville is to be believed, though, we should be watching Cho, as well.
Yeah, well I will use my powers on people I think are mafia, and if I get lucky, that person actually is mafia and dies. it's your choice to believe me.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Luna Lovegood
I'm thinking about "protecting" Myrtle tonight
Indeed. Yes, but the Shrink could very well be something other than the Psychologist.
Ron, 'protecting' Myrtle is a win-win situation for you. If she lives, you are a lucky insane cop, if she dies, you can claim it was pure chance. So regardless if she lives or not, you haven alibi for both, so are you truly belivable?
I suppose that could be true. I am still learning all of the roles in Mafia, however, the term 'shrink' usually implies a psychologist.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Buckbeak
Indeed Dobby, but we need to do some websurfing if we run into a psychologist being called a shrink, make sure we post a link.
Can the first page of the thread be updated with who is dead?
I think it is a good idea for Ron to try to protect Myrtle. I do not trust him, but I will not make my mind up on him one way or the other until his test on Myrtle is completed.
To further elaborate with Ron' so-called 'protection'....
He can try to hide behind the insane doctor mask if he's mafia so anything that happens he says can be due to his role when it could very well be a Mafia kill, which sets him up in a win-win situation.
Or, he could be telling the truth, but then, why tell us who you are going to protect, so we can say it was unintentional when Myrtle dies?
Certainly, Peter.
And now I will not be quite so active for a while, but I'll make sure to get at least one vote count in before I turn in for the night.
22 hours and 21 minutes remain.
We still need to figure out what the deal is with the two killings per night. Both nights it was 1 mafia and 1 townie. Does that mean we have a Vig and the mafia, or perhaps 2 mafias and some sort of Nexus or Bus Driver?
There's no guranteeing that the mafia will even aim at Myrtle ._.
In fact, if Ron's mafia, and they kill Myrtle, he could use that and say "Oh, look. I'm an Insane Doctor."
True enough, Luna... If it turns out that Ron really is a Doctor, there is a chance that Myrtle is Mafia... with the two killings each night, Ron might 'protect' Myrtle from a Vig attack or something...
Is the possibility of a serial killer out?
Since I am half Vigilante, the safest bet is we have either a serial killer around us, or a second mafia. If these are true, the scum is killing more scum then us town.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Dobby
Voldemort:
I don't think it has been ruled out... So I suppose there is a chance of that, as well... I am mainly looking at the fact that both nights, 1 mafia and 1 townsperson was killed...
Great Idea, Luna.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Luna Lovegood
But I made it first. XDQuote:
Originally Posted by Me
Might explain the Shrink a bit more?
But two mafia in two nights? That's pretty impressive. Possible, tough.
I didn't think of that. :(Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Luna Lovegood
Now I see many holes in my plan. At least they were brought up before the day ended and the mafia used me to escape Justice.
And i also should stop skimming posts. buckbeak, you explain the hole very well.
Whoops xDQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] BuckbeakGreat Idea, Luna.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Luna Lovegood
But I made it first. XDQuote:
Originally Posted by Me
I really shouldn't skim. I could miss some really important stuff x.x
Yes, skimming is bad.
Hermione:
From what I gather, the Shrink is supposed to help the town by figuring out who is insane. By saying someone is insane, the person would know to be certain of their results and/or targets before announcing anything or 'protecting' anyone.
What's your source, Dobby?
Has everyone forgotten about this? Really we have a confirmed Mafia according to Neville.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Neville Longbottom
Buckbeak:
I am simply going off of what I have seen here... I have yet to find a very good source for Mafia roles aside from the flash tutorial...
Yes, but that doesn't rule out a SK, that's all. That could be part of the Shrink role. Not that it matters now.
Oh, okay. Dobby. Now that you mention it, it makes sense.
Yes, but DD, claims are made all the time, even though Neville seems more reliable to me.
I suppose it is true that a SK can not yet be ruled out as they have no alliance... It still strikes me as odd that there has been a, so far, constant pattern for the night kills...
I got a new game for my DS, and it's calling me to play it. I will be back later, but before I go.
##Vote: Cho Chang
Neville could be our cop, and I hope the town kills a mafia member during the day this time. XD
Go, play your DS game!
So I suppose the question of the day is, Trust Neville or not?
Cho really has yet to say much... s/he tends to appear for a few moments, mostly when there is talk of lynching inactives, it seems, says a few words, votes, then leaves... that is how it appears to me...
Yeah, and that is a tried and true Mafia strategy...
So far it seems that Cho only appears when people are called out for inactivity and/or when the voting is almost finished. Of course, there are a few others who are the same way, though they have not been called out officially, only for inactivity...
OhiPSY!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Neville Longbottom
[levian]Their on to us Psy! Quick grab the cyanide capsules![/levian]Quote:
Why Cho Chang? I think she is the pairing Psychotic/Levian and as such are key players who needed to be investigated. I got that vibe from her anyway.
It's cause they smelled your Norwegian ass a mile away. =O
Actually naw. I'm neither of them if that makes you happy. I am honoured that you think I'm an uber awesome team, but sadly I'm all by my lonesome here. :p
As for the claim. Either your lying, or I'm a Miller (I wasn't told I was, so if I am then that's why I come up guilty).
I can't really defend myself in any way unless I die. So then go ahead and lynch me if you must. However depending on what I flip the town will know what to do.
If I come up as what I was told I am, then clearly your lying and should be lynched. If I do in fact come up Miller then you have some credibility, but I wouldn't run it past you to be a Mafia Cop either though. The fact that you mentioned Miller makes me think this more because it just seems a little....odd that you would mention that possibility. Especially since I know for a fact I was never told I was miller so only a Mafia Cop could know if I were in fact one.
As for Ron. I don't quite buy the role claim. I'm somewhat biased too because I found you scummy early on. I'm not sure what to make of you yet. If you are in fact telling the truth though, don't stop using your night action, if I were you I would use it to try and find the mafia. 'Protect' the most likely people to be scum, and you'll have a chance to kill them. I think it works out nice. Just don't try and protect people who we think are town.
Why can't we just have a mass-lynching where everybody dies?
I'm still not entirely sure if that means Mafia or just no time... Cho has tried to cover up her inactivity by saying that she is a bit put off, I guess would be the right phrase for it, by the fact that when she finally does arrive there are at least 3 pages to catch up on...
Edit: I'm not entirely certain how suspicious it is to be looking at all possibilities, but I suppose it could look that way. It doesn't seem like many people would actually look at all of the possibilities in depth...
Voldy:
Because then no one would win, of course!
Thanks Hank.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Harry Potter
I don't know if I trust Ron, but I'll vote for him if you all want. Sorry I've been out of the discussion but it looks like you guys are handling things. 2 mafia dead! Way to go!
Oh, yeah. Right. Forgot about the whole "rules" thing. :pQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Dobby
http://i188.photobucket.com/albums/z...vil_Barney.jpgQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] VoldemortOh, yeah. Right. Forgot about the whole "rules" thing. :pQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Dobby
Barney was my best friend as a child :(
And you were faced with death as a child, right Luna?
Who do you think is responsible?
I like this game isn't too much "lol," not too much "srs." It's kinda just "lolsrs."
Back on topic. Allova sudden Cho shows up! :O Kinda fishy to me. But, I'm not ready to vote just yet. I've been voting rather recklessly and I think I need to cool it this time.
Alright... so it is back to who to trust. At the moment, Cho, it does seem a little suspicious that you only seem to show up when you are on the chopping block...
As to Ron, I am not sure I would agree with Cho on that one... if he really IS an Insane Doctor and he tries to protect Mafia, there is a chance that the protection would go through... with a possible Vig out there, why would we want to be protecting scum, even if there is a chance of their death?
Would you rather I just didn't post? :pQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Voldemort
Besides someone wants me dead so I got something to discuss now. :monster:
Sorry, just thought of this:
Also, simply trying to protect someone who we all THINK is Mafia would not work very well, would it? With the Blabbermouth, we all sort of thought 'mafia', but it might actually have been a helpful role, the same with the Shrink...
IF the 'Insane Doctor' were to protect someone we all thought was Mafia, there is a chance that they would kill a power role for the town... so I am not entirely sure I would agree to Ron 'protecting' anyone, whether we all think they are Mafia or not...
As I have said before, a few times, Cho only seems to show up when there is talk of her lynching... I truly do find this suspicious... Why do you not simply continue speaking, trying to aid the town, rather than simply trying to defend yourself?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cho ChangWould you rather I just didn't post? :pQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Voldemort
Besides someone wants me dead so I got something to discuss now. :monster:
Indeed, this a team effort, unless you are the Serial Killer, Jester, or the Survivor.
I am still not completely certain of the Jester's role, but if we do indeed have a Serial Killer, they seem to be taking out Mafia right now... which is a good thing at the moment, as I doubt the Mafia would target themselves...
Cho, if you truly aren't Mafia, you would be more ready and willing to help us uncover them. It simply doesn't seem right that you only appear if your name is mentioned negatively or, I believe this occured once so far, if the vote is down to mere minutes...
If I recall I've only been called up on a lynch twice. And the first hardly counts since it was day 1 shenanigans. Also what do you call what I did in my big post? I hardly call it defense since I even said I can't really defend myself against a cop claim. I simply told the town how things were and my take on it.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Dobby
Cho:
That is basically the only time I have seen you post anything of aid to the town... I'm still not certain what to make of all of this, that is why I have yet to vote against anyone. There is simply too much information to sort through and process...
I don't like your miller argument.
Why did he bring it up? Because it's one of the ways you'd still be innocent. I think most people have enough of a grasp on the rules to know the roles, so surely this is just an easy way to throw it back in Neville's face?
Granted, there's nothing solid on you unless Neville's roleclaim is to be believed. (And boy has there been a lot of that.)
At the same time, you're not the only one on my radar right now.
You know, the more I think of it, the more I don't like Neville's claim.
I mean why would you mention Miller? Honestly? What Cop in thep ast has said "I tested it and I'm sane and he's scum, oh by the way they could be Miller" it's almost like he KNOWS I'm a Miller when I don't, and expects his claim to get me killed,. flip Miller so he can go "Oh my bad! Guess that off chance of 'em being the Miller was right!".
I take back what I said earlier. If I flip what I am (I.E. not Miller) he's scum and kill him. If I die and flip Miller, he's the Mafia Cop and kill him.
Why don't we just kill you both?
Cho can die tonight, and then if you aren't scum, Neville can die tomorrow?
We can't forget Ron, either... :mad:
Oh and before anyone gets on me, I don't mind being lynched today. My role isn't overly helpful to the town in what I got in my role PM, and we got 2 mafia bagged, so we can afford to take a hit if it'll be a good info lynch to smoke out the Mafia Cop.
Of course there is no way to be certain that Neville is even a cop... He could simply be a regular Mafia, but then, so could most everyone here... We have had so many roleclaims, it would not surprise me...
At the moment, I am tending to side with Voldy on this one... If Cho dies and it turns out she was innocent, then we can easily go after Neville tomorrow unless the SK or Vig or who/whatever the second killing party is takes him out...
Actually that's more then likely. I mean what Mafia would throw their Mafia Cop out on the chopping block when they could throw a less useful Goon? Well unless there's only one mafia and their low on members now and their only remaining roles are other power roles.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Dobby
Though with the frequent mafia deaths, I'm thinking there's either 1 big mafia, or 2 mafias. Too many mafia have died too fast for me to think it's just a standard 4-5 mafia set up. Unless our night killer is just that damn good. But the first 2 scenarios are far more likely.
Ack, my head hurts.
It not fair that other people get to hide in the back, so until tomorrow, I'm not worrying about Mafia.
Exactly. Since the mafia are free to talk to each other, it would not be hard to toss a lesser member if it is to throw people off of their power roles.... which makes me think that the timing is a tad convenient, too...
I find it interesting, though there is a slight chance it is merely coincidence, that the claim only came after Ron was put under suspicion...
Cho Chang (3): Neville Longbottom, Buckbeak, Ron Weasley
Ron Weasley (1): Rubeus Hagrid
20 hours and 20 minutes. Wow, that long still? It seems like it should be way later than it is. Oh welly welly!
OK. FF IV DS is amazing. If you have a DS, you need to go buy it.
I agree, and hope that even if whatever is killing the mafia , that (s)he kills Neville if he is in fact lying.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Dobby
There is only one thing that I have a problem with. If Neville is telling the truth, he is probably useless as a cop as our remaining protective roles will hinder him as well. Buckbeak claims to be a jailkeeper, and he would block Neville's cop ability to protect him. And if I try and protect him there is a chance he would die. And it would stink to lose our cop. Especially because he can clear my name. What a predicament. :(
Ron:
True enough... there are so many roleclaims that there are quite a few people at risk... it is all a matter of who to go after. If Cho really is innocent, there is no reason to protect Neville, however, if it really is that Cho is Mafia, the question is, risk losing Neville so that he could do his job, or protect him and not let him investigate?
Filch, where are you?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Draco Malfoy
Admittedly, my thoughts are too disorganized for me to properly form suspicions...I'll probably have to start from page 1 and reorganize my thoughts so I can have a list of the suspicious ones and why I think they're suspicious.
Hey, Buckbeak. Would you mind translating all the stuff you said before in English, please?
:greenie:
Unfortunately, I must leave now....
For now, I am keeping an eye on Ron, Neville, and Cho.
I think Myrtle is scum, but isn't a large threat to the town. Our next plan of action really depends on whether Cho is scum or innocent.
We have bagged two (I believe) Mafia members already, but I'd really hate to lose another townie.
Thank you for answering.
My eyes are currently on Ron (not sure what I think about his claim), Neville (don't completely believe his claim), Cho (pegged mafia by a "cop"), Filch (who pops in long enough to vote but says nothing else), and that's about it for now.
Myrtle, I'm pretty confident she's mafia, but I don't know what to make of her just yet.
I think the cop is gonna have fun determining who to investigate tonight.
Hagrid draws my suspicion too, though I'm not sure why. He hasn't done anything to earn my suspicion, but still... I just get a bad feeling :)
He kinda drew my attention too, but so does Pettigrew. He's only made 3 posts and hasn't posted anything to contribute. The first post was his check-in, the second was a request for the first post to be updated for those who have died, and the third post was:So...he's another one to watch.Quote:
Originally Posted by Peter Pettigrew
But, in the meantime...
##Vote: Filch
Until he shows up.
Yeah, Pettigrew irks me too. Even more than Hagrid. I'll hold my vote for a bit longer, see if anything unfolds
Cho Chang (3): Neville Longbottom, Buckbeak, Ron Weasley
Ron Weasley (1): Rubeus Hagrid
Mr. Filch (1): Draco Malfoy
Last votecount before I go to bed. 18 hours and 42 minutes until Night 3.
Bed time for Draco.
Gnight all :bigsmile:
Oh yeah, my partner voted before xD
That vote stays :)
I'll believe Neville for now because I thnk Cho has been pretty scummy up until now.
##Vote: Cho Chang
Off to bed~
Voting Cho for previously stated reasons.
##Vote: Cho Chang
HAH you guys sure are chaotic, love the way I'm not in the limelight anymore, but I did promise you a roleclaim, did I not?
I am the Schizophrenic!
As a Schizophrenic my powers alternate between days.
- On ODD days I have the ability to protect during the night, but I also must be mentioned in at least 5 different posts, or I can’t use my special ability.
My dumb partner took it too far and role claimed like crazy, EVEN THOUGH IT WAS THE WRONG DAY ignore him.
- On EVEN days I have the ability to investigate anyone I want, but once again there is a catch! I must change my vote at least 5 times in the day, a bit easier but still hard, if I fail to do that I can’t use my ability.
That is why my partner vote hopped so much.
I win with the town. On night 1 we weren’t online at all and couldn’t use our protective abilities.
Last night I investigated Remus Lupin and the result was innocent.
We were role playing to the role, I also need to be mentioned in 5 posts today so I can protect someone, any questions?
P.S me and my partner, WERE doing it on purpose to suit the role, but we only started agter the role claim spree.
Oh, and
##VOTE: RON
You killed the shrink, shrink said ron was the psychopath, BAM Ron should die.
And Nevile if you look back at my post earlier, I too did the C O P trick, you could of done it to make your role claim more believable, hmm?
I don't believe you, sorry. Seems WAY too far-fetched for my liking
I give up the roleclaims, the don't work, it makes me look like an amateur and I am NO amateur.
I was TOLD to claim that and I've been screwed over by my own team.
I am a Cult Member.
Don't you mean another role claim? :pQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
Oh and greatest role evar! :up:Quote:
I am the Schizophrenic!
I'm almost inclined to believe your role claim just because of how in depth you go to explain this role. Really kudos even if you happen to be scum, since that's the most effort on a role claim I've seen before.
Though I'm gonna believe it for now, since Neville and Ron I don't believe their claims too much, and I doubt the mafia is stupid enough to throw 3 people out there on role claim duty.
I laughed, the schitzo can investigate people. Though since this seems to be a role custom made that differs from the flash, I'm not so sure Remus can be cleared as innocent. Since after all you *are* insane, it's possible that so too are your investigations.Quote:
On EVEN days I have the ability to investigate anyone I want,
The Shrink said he only found if people were insane or not, and not if there was a psychopath or not. He simply said that Ron was insane (I'm too lazy to look for the quote, but it's there.) Which would suggest this is an insane heavy game. Seeing as we have you as a possible schitzo, and we know that what ever Ron is, he's insane.Quote:
You killed the shrink, shrink said ron was the psychopath, BAM Ron should die.
Sorry Psy, where ever you are, that's kind of a lame trick you started you got to admit. :)Quote:
I too did the C O P trick, you could of done it to make your role claim more believable, hmm?
Besides I don't think I've seen that tactic ever used by non-mafia before. :p
Gah make up your mind!!!! :mad2:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
Oh and before I forget.
##Vote: Neville
Because as I already said, I know what I am, and his accusation doesn't sit well with me since he claimed "Sane Cop".
Also, I don't believe Crabbe said anything about Ron being the psychopath. For all we know, Ron is an Insane Doctor. And if Ron is, as you say, the psychopath, then he's still not the biggest threat to the town at the moment.
Sorry Cho, as good a roleclaim as it was I didn't write it.
Wait, Cult Member now? Jesus Christ, I can't keep up. I say we lynch Myrtle tomorrow to keep our sanity =D
Thats my last roleclaim, the others were forced upon me.
Yeah Myrtle is pushing it with the role claims. Who ever does the night kills please get 'em tonight. For all of our sakes. T_T
*Sigh* hear this
I was FORCED to do those past role claims, I got fed up off being played like an amateur so I revealed the truth.
I won't give my team members away, but trust me on this okay?
It would be an awful claim if I was trying to win with it.
Someone resurrect Vincent Crabbe, I need a shrink ASAP. I think I'm going crazy :D
I'll make things clearer
- Recruited Night 1
- Told to roleclaim like crazy and drag attention.
- I got fed up
- Revealed I was Cult Member- I now warn you that the Cult are potentially very powerful.
And thats all there is to it.
So there's a cult then.
If the Masons had a power role among them, good chance the Cult does as well.
Also looks like only 1 mafia team and they are hurting right now. So with cult in mind might be a good chance to bag us a few purples. :D
Lynch me if you want now, unless there is a mason recruiter who can convert me back, I'd appreciate it because then I'm allowed to give some info away.
Yet you won't reveal your team? Why not rat them out? :D
Ah, I see. You're not overly dangerous to us now, so we just need to find the scary Cult people
Something tells me Pettigrew is a Cult member. Or maybe that's just me combining my suspicion with this new roleclaim
I believe Pettigrew may be Cult Leader (or whatever Cult member can recruit).I should post resoning for my suspicion. As Draco noted before, he has only posted thrice in this thread, once asking for a status update on page one. This may be so he can easily tell who is available to recruit. Possible, plausible, but I'm not sure if it's likely.
However, I'm not sure how dangerous this Cult is. Is it possible one of them has a night kill power?
Myrtle, can you share any information with us?
That's a hell of a lot to read. Unfortunatly, I have to go out now. I'll be back in a few hours and read everything, before revealing who I find suspicious. Don't post too much while I'm gone.
Seeing as I'm falling asleep at the keyboard, it would make sense for me to go to sleep. Good Luck while I'm gone
I won't give any names because I would die, and then I have no chance to be saved by any other recruitment type character.
But if I don’t get recruited and I screw the cult over I get nowhere, I’m taking a risk for YOUR sakes don’t act like you guys are doing me a favour.
- There is a Cult Recruiter - He recruited me on night 1, beforehand I was a Vanilla townie.
- Another Cult member, recruited last night.
- And a Cult Cop - presumably to make sure the Cult recruiter doesn’t recruit a mafia and get killed.
These are what they SAY their roles are, but whether their trustworthy … They did try to make me a scapegoat.
But I can’t give names, or it’s game over for me unless I get out of the Cult somehow.
Oh, and I'm pretty sure the Cult count as insane, the Shrink was probably implemented to find us, not sure though.
Claiming miller is a typical mafia defence to a cop's guilty verdict, so I tried to pre-empt that. However you're using that against me, so I think it's a case of damned if I do, and damned if I don't.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cho Chang
At the end of the day, I do not think you are a miller simply because the role is very rare. It's actually much more likely that you are a serial killer, although obviously you wouldn't use that as a defense. I do think you are mafia and I've made that clear.Let's leave the mafia alone and concentrate on the cult? Haha. Come on now. :greenie:Quote:
Originally Posted by Cho
Anyway, I've put my neck on the line to tell the town my night results. Take them or leave them. I think it's the best lead we've got by a long shot.I know you did. I did it first though. Well, Psycho did it first but hehe :D As for Myrtle, I do think we should wait until tomorrow with that one to see if she gets turned back to the town side.Quote:
Originally Posted by Myrtle
I think that would be a bit too overpowered!Quote:
Originally Posted by Buckbeak
It is likely a CPR doctor targeted the mafia godfather, if that is the case I implore ALL doctors in this game to be careful of who they protect.
I'd also like to point out that we need to make a decision, do we kill mafia or the Cult, lets look at both sides.
- Mafia can kill but are weakened by the loss of their Godfather, they have little influence now but may take advantage of the Cult and come back at the end.
- Cult, they can't night kill (as far as I know) But can recruit an extra member every night, and with the edition of a Cult Cop it is very unlikely they will accidentally recruit a mafian and die, once the cult recruiter is dead, they lose their trump card, but we need to find him soon if they are the main target.
Here is how we will decide.
-If I get recruited tonight by the mafia/masons I will have the chance to rat out all my fellow Cult members, this should insure they die, unfortunately either way, its impossible for me to win because I will get lynched if I am mafia recruited or night killed if I am mason recruited, I am ready to make this sacrifice.
- If I DON'T get recruited by any parties then I'll be forced to reveal the Cult, but due to the fact I won't have any parties supporting me and helping prove my fact, it is likely the Mafia AND town would have to collaborate to take down the cult names, this will be complicated because I'd need a certain level of trust.
- If get killed then it would be proven there is a Cult, unfortunately I would not be able to give any names, if I die then focus on those who voted for Crabbe as they are the likely suspects.
You must remember that I can only give Cult names tomorrow, there is a chance you will lynch the recruiter, in that case I won't need to relay any info and you guys can focus on the mafia, as the Cult won't be powerful enough to make a real difference.
Oh, Jesus. Die already!!!! :mad2:
I'm feeling like I should just vote Myrtle so she'll shut the hell up.
I won't be around until later this evening. So, I won't be able to contribute or vote 'til then.
If we're gonna lynch Cho, I have no problem with that... yet.
Jesus H, Myrtle. You are making things unpleasant.
Alright, fine.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Luna Lovegood
My first post was that I am the Jailkeeper.
So if you need my role just gimme the word. The second was translated by Dobby, so he pretty much said it already.
Okay guys, I'm an ass I was trying to manipulate the voting becuase you guys were doing it wrong. :(
I'm not Cult, heck I don't even think there IS a Cult, anyway....
Buckbeak why claim such a powerful role so early on? You'll probably get killed tonight now.
Because people distrusted me that I wrote in French, translate it using a translater.
That dosen't make any sense...
EDIT: If your the jailkeeper what were your night actions?
Night 1-Voldemort
Night 2- Sirius Black
What? Sirius was killed night 2! You have some explaining to do.
##unvote: Ron
##vote: Buckbeak
Yeah, you can just stop talking now Myrtle.
Also the psy C-O-P thing, little overused. Think of new tactics instead of rehashing old ones.
I'm going to ignore all of Myrtles role claims because they are just ridiculous.
Moving on to the other couple role claims.
Buckbeak:
Your jail keeper claim seems very plausible. Also you haven't gave me any bad vibes so for now i'll believe you.
Neville:
Anyone can make a cop claim. It's just if you're lucky or not if you're correct. There was no reason to come out saying you were the cop. Even if you are you could have just dropped hints. Like C-O-P, yeah you did it once, try it again. It just might work!
Ron:
Also anyone can make a claim of insanity. I still wonder why you wouldn't use your power. Like others have stated, you could just target someone who you thought was mafia. Almost everyone believed Sirius for at least day and night 2. So if you thought that was the only kill then what were you afraid of protecting someone from on night 2? Your claim is fishy to me.
So my suspects are Neville and Ron. My vote for Ron still stands though.
Buckbreaks role-claim makes no sense, if he targetted sirius then he couldn't of died!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hagrid
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Neville Longbottom
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Rubeus Hagrid
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Neville LongbottomQuote:
Originally Posted by Hagrid
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Neville Longbottom
The C-O-P thing isn't a hint. It's to give credit to a roleclaim. To show that from post one, that's what you are, and you haven't made it up on the fly to adapt to a situation.
As for hints, sure, if the person is innocent you should hint. But if they're guilty, you should claim. Why waste time watching the town bicker about Jack Stupid Townie when you can give them a lead?
Is nobody sceptical about Buckbeaks roleclaim?
It doesn't give it credit. Anyone can do it. Since what, two people have already said to do this said tactic, you don't think mafia has yet to pick up on it? it lost it's credibility a long time ago.
Another thing, if you come out as a possible cop you're risking yourself when you're a main asset to the town. If you're any good at mafia you should be able to convince the other players of your suspicions and if all else fails then you should reveal your findings. You didn't even try to convince us otherwise that Cho was guilty. Besides with your roleclaim.
Except it does give credit. Take Sirius. He was accused of killing Ginny and he claimed overager vigilante. That was adapting to the situation. If you are a bad guy, being fixed on one roleclaim throughout the entire game is a lot harder to pull off. Imagine if he'd been gearing up for a cop claim - how could he have explained killing Ginny?
Any further questions about my role or claim?It was a bit odd that Sirius died. We'll see what Buckbeak says.Quote:
Originally Posted by Myrtle
So you're basing that it wouldn't work because Sirius got caught. Are you serious!? That's a bunch of "what ifs".
Absolutely I'm risking myself. I'm being a team player. I don't want to die, I want to carry on playing. I did this because it's the right thing to do. And do you really think anybody would have listened to me with all this roleclaiming insanity that's going on?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Rubeus Hagrid
If you want to ignore me and let Cho go then hey, go for it. I don't know what else I can tell you.
You were the first to role claim today. You started the insanity. Again I say as I said before. Give me proof that your claim is correct. Stop trying to convince people of your opinion when all you have to say for it is "Look this is what they told me!"
For people that are disbelieving you like I am, try to prove them with your words. You're a big kid now, use them.
What is the case made about Cho. They were inactive. WOO a lot of people go inactive. It's no reason for lynches, at least not right away.
Cho's responses haven't done anything to lessen any suspicion on her. She escaped a little scrutiny by simply claiming something like "I know I'm innocent so you should too." I guess that means we can let her go, right?
Also, Myrtle. Stop. Just stop. If you're town, you are not helping us, and if you're cult you're not doing them any favors anyway. My patience draws short with you.
Sirius - I've believed you all the way up until this point, and I want to keep doing so - any ideas why Sirius died?
Anyway, I think our two most pressing options are Cho or Myrtle. We should also come to terms with the Ron thing at some point.
Oh, and I think I said it before, but you seem to know what you're doing, and if you're telling the truth you're really helping the town, so you've still got my vote of faith.
Also, Hagrid? Raising some suspicions. I don't know, just a bad feeling I get.
Roleclaiming cop when you have found someone guilty is not "insanity". At least, I don't think so. Prove that I'm the cop? Sure, I can do that. Lynch Cho Chang. Or lynch myself. Whichever you prefer.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hagrid
"people" disbelieve me now? I think you're the only one who really disbelieves me, Hagrid. Sure, not everybody trusts me, which is fair enough - I ask you all for a bit of faith and to trust me on this, and then with the lynch hopefully I'll have proved myself - but you're going all out against me. Which brings me to this: Why are you so desperate to try to undermine me anyway? You're being totally unreasonable and dismissing anything I say, even when it's logical. There's something not right about the way you're acting.
As for what is my case against Cho, go ahead and read my first post on this day. I investigated her, it came back scum. What else do you want? Detailed surveillance tapes showing her meeting with Sirius and Goyle or something? :p
I suppose it's time to put my money where my mouth is.
##:Vote: Cho
I find it, still, a little strange that there are a few who have yet to say much... Cho has made a few arguments defending herself, but she will not so much as TRY to explain her role or anything, simply justify her defense with 'I know what I am'.... I'm really not sure what to think... perhaps a Mafia who can not think of a good enough role for a decent roleclaim? Or maybe just a townie who is not so keen on giving up her role... Either way, I find it suspicious.
As to the Ron situation, I am slightly more inclined to believe it, as he had someone confirm at least part of it... All I have to say is, be careful who you choose to 'protect', as we do not want anymore Townie power roles getting 'protected' only to end up dead. Be certain of your choice.
With Myrtle, there have been so many roleclaims, I'm not certain what to think anymore... Jester, backwards jester, cop, cult, it makes my head spin... Now... are you just a poor player or are you trying to draw attention to yourself... that's the question.
Neville probably should have tried not to roleclaim right off, but he is a tad more believable than Cho's 'I know what I am' claim. For the moment, I trust him.
I shall continue to withhold my vote for now.... but those are the main people I am looking at.
Cop, please investigate Neville tonight...if he doesn't get lynched.
Myrtle, you're really grating on my nerves. Why don't you try sticking to a story for once instead of always making up new ones? I know the character in the movie is annoying, but you don't have to play that role out so fervently.
Ron, Cho, Myrtle, Buckbeak, and Neville. Our list of suspects. Cho only because she was pegged by our "cop," plus the fact that she doesn't say much to defend herself other than "I just know I'm innocent, believe me plz."
Myrtle because she won't quit with the ridiculous role claims and so we can't trust a word she says.
Neville because while he claims he's cop, it's looking more and more unlikely, unless he's the mafia cop:
He could very, very well be lying about the result he got on himself. But, I'm not going to say just yet what it is that causes me to descredit his roleclaim so strongly.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mafia Role Flash
If I'm right about him being the Mafia cop, the real cop and any other doctors out there are in danger, so...be careful.
Draco:
You make a good point. It would make sense if he were a Mafia Cop... It would also lend a little credit to Cho's being so wary about giving away her role... especially if it is a power role... I suppose we should keep an eye on him, as well...
Dobby:
Yes, and this is why despite the fact that I suggested the cop investigate who they want before, I think that it'd be best for the town for him or her to investigate Neville.
Draco:
I would have to agree with you there. If anyone can investigate him, they should.
I still find it a tad strange that the claim that Cho was Mafia came right after Ron's claim of being an insane doctor and all of this Myrtle business... if it weren't for Neville's 'investigation', it is likely that Myrtle would be a bit closer to lynching... Perhaps Myrtle has a power role in Mafia and is simply playing it like she does to make everyone think she is simply a newbie or a very bad player...
Cho Chang (6): Neville Longbottom, Buckbeak, Ron Weasley, Dudley Dursley, Luna Lovegood, Hermione Granger
Ron Weasley (1): Rubeus Hagrid,Moaning Myrtle
Mr. Filch (1): Draco Malfoy
Neville Longbottom (1): Cho Chang
Buckbeak (1): Moaning Myrtle
Not voting: Albus Dumbledore, Dobby, Mr. Filch, Peter Pettigrew, Remus Lupin, Severus Snape, Voldemort.
Takes 9 to lynch, remember.
7 hours and 51 minutes remaining.
Could this game get any crazier?
In what way is it looking more and more unlikely? I'm inviting questions. Anything you want to know about my role or whatever, ask me. Let's get this cleared up now.Quote:
Originally Posted by Draco
And yeah, anybody else who has an investigative power can feel free to use it on me tonight if they have any doubts for any reason.
To be honest, I think Neville is playing this truthfully, I believe him!
OK. Myrtle, Shut up. You are annoying me to the point where I think I am going to try and "protect" you. Why? Because you are a distraction, something that the mafia would want to keep around. Your crazy antics are allowing the remaining mafia to hide while everybody looks at you.
Cho, you are three votes away from death. To keep you alive, I will
##Unvote: Cho Chang
If you have a role, then say it now, before the mafia takes the oppurtunity to kill you if you are in fact town.
If you are lynched, and come up as a town role that is not miller, then we should kill Neville if whatever is night killing mafia doesn't kill him first. If you are mafia or a miller, then Neville is the cop.
Neville:
It just seems a bit strange that you would come straight out with 'I'm the cop.' At least to me it is. There would likely be other ways to say it without drawing so much attention to yourself... If you really are the cop, you have just brought yourself out into the open as a prime target for one of the killing factions. There is little you can do for us now if it turns out that Cho really is Mafia since they would likely target you before you could investigate any more of them.
I apologise the ridiculous claims shall stop now.
Unless a doctor protects him, which would be a clever thing to do.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Dobby
Myrtle:
This is true, but you must keep in mind that Ron is an 'Insane Doctor' and we would have a 50% chance of losing him with that, anyway.... Tonks was a town Doctor and has been killed. If Buckbeak is telling the truth and is, in fact, a Jailkeeper, what would be the point in protecting Neville with him? Yes, he would be safe, but he would be useless as far as power because the Jailkeeper role would block his investigations.
Buckbeak is not a Jailkeeper, I'm sure he "Jailed" Sirius Black yet Sirius still died?
Myrtle:
We also have a chance that there is a Nexus or a Bus Driver, do we not? They could have easily switched who Buckbeak was 'jailing' if Buckbeak really is the Jailkeeper. We can not rule out those possibilities, as well... And of course there is the possibility of a second Mafia. If that is the case, a Mafia Ninja or a Mafia Hitman from the second Mafia would easily have killed Sirius, even though he was 'jailed'.
I guess...
##Unvote: Buckbeak
##Vote: Cho Chang
How do I know you're not the cop, Neville? Because: I know who the cop really is, might say we're..chums.
I am simply looking for all possibilities, not just what seems the most obvious... I am not saying that Buckbeak is for sure a Jailkeeper, but if s/he is, a second mafia or nexus or busdriver would explain why the 'jailing' failed.
Brothers?
I don't get it, why aren't we voting for Myrtle if she's a cult. Isn't Cult scum?
##Vote: Myrtle
I also find it odd that Draco says he knows who the cop is. I think he should reveal this piece of information.
I think, Neville, that you're trying to trap the real cop into revealing him/herself so you can kill them tonight. You come out and make a claim "oh look I'm the cop!" and reveal your "investigations" so that everyone will believe you.
And no, Pettigrew, I will not. Not until the time is right.
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peter Pettigrew
I said I wasn't cult read the thread again.
Neville investigate me tonight.
Well my vote stands. Anyone who changes their role claim so many times isn't a pro town and needs to be killed.
Well I might switch to Cho. I am suspicious of her too. Really I'll do whatever you guys want. I'm new to this game is why I haven't been participating much.
Especially not to you, Pettigrew, because you're under scrutiny. Demanding that kind of information totally sets off the scum alarms because a town member wouldn't want me to reveal that information...They'd rather I keep it to myself so that the cop doesn't die tonight at the hands of the mafia team.
##Unvote: Filch
##Vote: Peter Pettigrew
Because of that stint and your post quality and quantity, you're scum in my book. 4 posts in 2 days, and absolutely no help to us at all, especially in a time of need such as now.
I think Peter Pettigrew is mafia scum.
5 posts now, and still no help.
I think Peter pettigrew may be a survivor or some role that needs to stay low....