EoFF Mafia XXVIII Game Thread - Banquet of the Voyager Witches

It would be really helpful if we got that last purple statement at this time

I mean, Scruff, I'm not pressuring you and I know that you opting not to say it doesn't necessarily mean that you're a witch since there are many reasons why you'd do that, but we are all still working off of very limited data. I mean, perhaps limited data is better than all data with even MORE false statements than now, but still, it could help

Maybe there's some additional rules regarding the Pained or the Cynic - or hell, the village idiot!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FFNut

If anything I would guess that you and Pumpkin are the Witches. I can get Formy's vote for me, it was kinda cute the way I was on Carny and he voted to protect his man.

---

OH FOR THE LOVE OF

Should I temporarily break up with him just so people don't think literally every action I take in this game is to protect him?

Please don't.

Also Scruff or Laddy want to add more? I'm about to go into work. Come onnnnn. You know you wanna.

Don't you dare break up with him.

Also, I sorta realized that whoever is sending the notes probably has the "Whisper" ability.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Formalhaut

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FFNut

If anything I would guess that you and Pumpkin are the Witches. I can get Formy's vote for me, it was kinda cute the way I was on Carny and he voted to protect his man.

---

OH FOR THE LOVE OF

Should I temporarily break up with him just so people don't think literally every action I take in this game is to protect him?

---

Shhhhhhhhh

There, there :soothe:

I mean, I'm joking, but damn guys. I'm not thinking with my penis here.

Anyway, I've kinda been thrown back after I realised it isn't a mass-roleblock so much as a mass-protection. The candy girl in the statement then is either Pumpkin saying she didn't use her ability (and thus that is Lamb), or in fact her target (who was eating sweets). Am I getting this right?

As for the cynic, I can tell everyone that I certainly didn't send or recieve any letters. I mean, I can't prove that, but I thought I may as well address that directly. I think it is the cynic who can send letters, as that would make sense for the traitor to be able to have occasional contact with the witches.

Thanks for your input Laddy! Scruff's also been quiet today. We should probably see what he has to say as well. Still think Nutty is the most viable candidate, in my opinion.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Formalhaut

I mean, I'm joking, but damn guys. I'm not thinking with my penis here.

---

I would've said you were thinking with your heart but ok :erm:

So I've been thinking about this, and really, if I was Pained, my strategy would be pretty stupid.

Either I am correct in who I think the witches are, they get lynched and then.... I lose

OR they aren't witches, innocent people die, suddenly extra people are being killed at night and I'm the only one who has role claimed and no one trusts me anymore after like tonight and then... I lose

I mean I get that I'm not the most brilliant tactician but I'm also not an idiot, come on guys

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fynn

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Formalhaut

I mean, I'm joking, but damn guys. I'm not thinking with my penis here.

---

I would've said you were thinking with your heart but ok :erm:

---

I was thinking similar to you there.

I propose me, TSoL, Carny, and Formy create an alliance for queer dudes. Who's with me?

And Formy and Carby are kinkier than I thought. I bet they Mafia roleplay too. ;)

Queers against the world?

I always get excluded from queer dude groups :(

It's discrimination is what it is is what it is

I agree :stare: