1up rates every Final Fantasy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rase

This guys opinion is different then mine and I don't like that, so he's a terrible person.

---

<3!

What bugged me most is that I couldn't place the correct pictures to their stupid reviews.

*stumbles onto thread* What the hell is this?

Well its truly unusual to see a major game critic badmouth VII and IV while praising IX (I only remeber one magazine giving IX a positive review and that was GameFan). I consider most of his thoughts to be irrelevant. VII is not nearly as bad as he makes it out to be though I agree it has not aged well... Overall, he did it to get attention.

As for KHII, I disagree that from a gameplay perspective its a downgrade from the first. I think its gameplay is its strong point. Its story is a disaster making little sense, dropping the ball on many key moments, and filled with so many pointless convulated plot twists (or plot holes) it can only be a Nojima script... Story wise, KH2 killed all interest I had in the series. Thank you Nojima for taking my smile away again...:cry:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Wolf Kanno

Overall, he did it to get attention.

---

Incorrect!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Final Fantasy VII

Final Fantasy VII is a goddamn mess of a game.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Final Fantasy X-2

But the truth is, it's not that bad.

---

Logic error

Well that made for an interesting 15 minutes.

Some of you lot are acting like the reviewer slagged off your favourite FF and said it was a pile of poo. I didn't see much of that happening at all, I thought he had fairly balanced and reasonable opinions.

FFVII for example. It wasn't slagged off, it was said to be a great game worth playing! He just happened to point out its flaws like the messy storyline (very true, although in my opinion this gives it more depth). I don't agree that the materia system was bad, it's one of the best Final Fantasy battle systems I've ever played. But an opinion is an opinion.

I quite liked Dirge, so I disagree with that one.

I didn't like FFXII, but I think I may appreciate it more on a second play-through.

The rest of the reviews I can pretty much agree with.

I still think that FFVIII and KHII are very, very, very worth it, but in the end I agreed with most of the listing and thought it was an enjoyable read.

id dint agree with a lot of it. calling the materia system a wreck i dont understand it was simple and the most interesting way of learning abilities.

also the main thing i disagreed with is FFIV. that stands as one of my favorite games. i dont think they ever have any valid reasons for saying its not worth it.

and super mario RPG that agme is so much fun ive replayed it probably like 20 times.