Mafia XVIII Game Thread: Welcome To The Soul Society

Printable View

Show 200 post(s) from this thread on one page

02-14-2011, 03:29 AM
[M] Apollo

I believe we're voting for the Kingmaker.
02-14-2011, 03:30 AM
[M] Harry - Dad's Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Kisuke Urahara

Why Renji?

So I can make you king!
02-14-2011, 03:30 AM
[M] D'Anna

But why are you choosing Renji as the Kingmaker?
02-14-2011, 03:30 AM
[M] D'Anna

Why do you guys want me to be king?
02-14-2011, 03:30 AM
[M] Felix

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Kisuke Urahara

I have good reason to believe Shinji is anti-town. He voted for the very person who started the whole things that bagged a mafian, for starters! Wheither that translates to mafia, I don't know.

Orihime just seems to be a new player. She has failed to really do much of anything. I'm leaning towards new, but mafian is quite a possibility.

This I guess could count, but I'm the one tha treally hammered it in after that, and this was at best a stretch, since you seem to admit yourslef you're not sure if your suspcion comes up to mean anythign.

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Jin Kariya

Yes, just like that. My investigation results:

Night 0: Myself- Innocent
Night 1: Gin- Guilty
Night 2: Kisuke Urahara- Innocent
Night 3: Shinji- Guilty

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Rukia Kuchiki

And dude, the art is a running gag from the show.

And 'secret alliance'? You mean how we've both agreed on lynching Gin and Yoru openly, and turning out to be right? That secret alliance?

And if you suspect this 'alliance' of being suspicious for me, why do you not know what to think of Kisuke? Surely if you believe an alliance between us, you'd know what to think of him.

Though I had a theory during night, though I believe Jin just gave me the reason to believe it.

Gin is not our enemy. Why? Because the enemy is Shinji. What happens? He comes out and votes you yesterday as the heat on Jin rises, but we get :bou::bou::bou::bou: for reasoning. He's stretching to attach himself to anyone town, but that only works under the assumption that Gin is town.

As it looks, he's got a guilty rating, but I propose he's not Mafia at all, but a miller. Why else would Shinji have went after Kisuke the other day, since if Gin really was Guilty he would surely look guilty by default. Both being Mafia makes no sense, but Gin could get so excitable, because of how defensive being a Miller had made him.

Also, if you look at Yoru, the Poisoner, perhaps Mafia DIDN"T try to implicate Gin at all, nor did he try to get rid of his enemies. The blind player may have chosen Ichigo by fluke. I don't think we can use the night kill of Ichigo against Gin now because of it.

Either way, SHinji is the one who looks like the enemy tonight. His actions have yet to be helpful to town, as well as his jump to voting you yesterday, and for some god aweful reason me today.

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Kisuke Urahara

I'm just stuck between Shinji and Gin. :I

So Gin, sell me your innocence (hehe), as Shinji is just unable to talk to.

YOu say this after I post reasoning as to WHY gin may not be guilty, without so much as questioning any of what I suggested.

There was also this post of yours that day.

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Kisuke Urahara

19 1/2 hours left.

I have a theory. The Death Miller died already. Last night's death showed a night kill resulting in a Mafian's death. However, the Poisoner was killed, and the only double night kill happened after the day the poison would have taken effect. As a result, It would make logical sense that it was Rangiku that was a Death Miller.

It woudl be odd to have both Miller and Death Miller, I just think this is you still doubting the Miller Claim by Gin. A bit of a stretch, yes, but something to look at no doubt.

And after all this, as well as a few votes being on Shinji already. This.

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Kisuke Urahara

I like Rukia's Logic, so for the time being I will join with Shinji. If Shinji ends up town we know Jin's lying.

## Vote: Shinji

Every vote after that came from Shinji freaking out and then you got louder. Once again, you seem to be jumping on a Mafian who was likely to die over anything esle. You just happened to get louder when it was happening.

You even directly state it's because of MY logic, notthign you yourself presented. If anything, I was still the cause of Shinji's death, with you jumping on as it seemed others were going in.
02-14-2011, 03:31 AM
[M] Harry - Dad's Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Kisuke Urahara

But why are you choosing Renji as the Kingmaker?

The kingmaker makes the king. The king does the lynch. Make me the kingmaker and I make you King.
02-14-2011, 03:34 AM
[M] D'Anna

Why do you want ME to be King though?

I get ONE guy wrong and I'm scum now? And now we're having a pissing contest. Oh great! Avast he who pees after I do is one who pees evil!

That's just poor logic.
02-14-2011, 03:35 AM
[M] Apollo

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Kisuke Urahara

Why do you guys want me to be king?

Since you have it pretty much figured out. You do want Town to win, right?
02-14-2011, 03:36 AM
[M] Felix

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Captain Hitsugaya

Jin investigated several times and here are his results.

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Jin Kariya

Yes, just like that. My investigation results:

Night 0: Myself- Innocent
Night 1: Gin- Guilty
Night 2: Kisuke Urahara- Innocent
Night 3: Shinji- Guilty

So, Gin and Shinji were his guilty results. Gin turned out to be a pro-town Miller, and Shinji was the personal bodyguard of the godfather/cult leader. So Rukia... who was the other guy that Jin might have investigated later? Or were you refering to Shinji?

I was referring to Kisuke claimin the innocent investigation cleared him of being Mafia, which was odd given the talk about the Godfather possobility. He tried usind the investigation to prove himself, yet in reality it means nothing.

He seems rather defensive for someone who has one person going after him right now.

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Kisuke Urahara

Jin is Cult. Rukia is Mafia. Jin has abstained from voting for every single Cultist in the game, while Rukia has not only made a lie of role claim, turned on me purely on the prospect of me suspected her, but has also used inconsistent and faulty logic.

You're only proof that it's a lie was Preacher doesn't work that way, which the way a preacher works is irrelevant. Even after you realized what I was saying, you are still saying it's a long shot that I'm telling the truth.

And you've yet to say why my logic is faulty or inconsistant.
02-14-2011, 03:36 AM
[M] D'Anna

Wait...wait. Now I like that you guys are all happy for me and think I got the goods, but it seems you only want me to be King after I state neither of you would be lynched.
02-14-2011, 03:36 AM
[M] Harry - Dad's Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Captain Hitsugaya

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Kisuke Urahara

Why do you guys want me to be king?

Since you have it pretty much figured out. You do want Town to win, right?

Like he said!
02-14-2011, 03:37 AM
[M] Harry - Dad's Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Kisuke Urahara

Wait...wait. Now I like that you guys are all happy for me and think I got the goods, but it seems you only want me to be King after I state neither of you would be lynched.

I actually don't care. I just wanna go to sleep. And I can't until this is done.
02-14-2011, 03:38 AM
[M] D'Anna

Oh lord in heavens, truly I am Mafia because I targeted Rukia! I am ashamed! Forgive me, god!

I'm ignoring Rukia right now so I won't get more "Mafia-like."
02-14-2011, 03:38 AM
[M] D'Anna

Alright then, fair enough. Make me king!
02-14-2011, 03:39 AM
[M] Felix

No, You're Mafia because of all I've posted. NO claims of you being Mafia targeting me really matter. That's just what got me thinking about you've been doing all game. :p

Show 200 post(s) from this thread on one page