Anniversary Mafia Game Thread - The Final Day

Printable View

Show 200 post(s) from this thread on one page

11-19-2012, 08:22 PM
[M] Greg - Hot Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Biggs

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Noctis

Anyway, I will mindlessly bandwagon with you all on Luneth if I have to, she's kind of dodgy, but I'd really prefer it if you helped me twat Blank. You can believe in me! I'm like fairies or magic!

Why so intent to bandwagon an inactive when you yourself hate that strategy:

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Noctis

anyway can I just say all this "HEH HEH HEH INACTIVES" is a potato

because

IT IS YOU GUYS

"Oh ho hum I will vote for an inactive to make them come out and post!"

Do you really think I'm like sitting there going "doop de doop de doop not gonna post! OHHHH NO! Someone voted for me! My one weakness!"

We all know it's ridiculous and anyone who spouts this as a good sensible tactic is trying to make you think they're good. Easy target, no-one can defend the inactives!

Just stop. In every mafia game ever.

uhhh... the hint was in the word "mindlessly" :greenie:
11-19-2012, 08:24 PM
[M] Dave – Stepdad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Noctis

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Wedge

They tried to kill you twice? Well, that seems ridiculous, more likely two killing factions tried to kill you and failed.

Oh really...? Haha. Cool.

Well, whoever it is that keeps trying to do it, HA FREAKIN' HA! is what I say. :bigsmile:

I know that thought crossed your mind, your snarkiness about pointing out the obvious doesn't help town, maybe not everyone thought of it, there are many new players in this game.
11-19-2012, 08:26 PM
[M] D'Anna

So why are you so sure people tried to kill you Noctis?
11-19-2012, 08:27 PM
[M] Greg - Hot Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Wedge

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Noctis

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Wedge

They tried to kill you twice? Well, that seems ridiculous, more likely two killing factions tried to kill you and failed.

Oh really...? Haha. Cool.

Well, whoever it is that keeps trying to do it, HA FREAKIN' HA! is what I say. :bigsmile:

I know that thought crossed your mind, your snarkiness about pointing out the obvious doesn't help town, maybe not everyone thought of it, there are many new players in this game.

It hadn't actually. Sorry, genuinely wasn't snark at you there, I am only snarking at the mafia right now.
11-19-2012, 08:28 PM
[M] Greg - Hot Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Biggs

So why are you so sure people tried to kill you Noctis?

It's a surprise. You'll know why when you lynch me tomorrow and find out my role!
11-19-2012, 08:29 PM
[M] D'Anna

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Wedge

There is nothing to report since I don't get the results of my own investigations. I am not going to say who I investigated on Night 2 yet because I am not sure if Kain was allowed to do his own night action before he died and I don't want someone to pop up and deceive the town and me by saying, "Oh, I got that report, Kain must have switched me with so and so and I must have been the true target." That would just muddle things up further. Plus, Serah said she never received the first report and she was obviously town aligned and wouldn't have any reason not to tell the town about a report on an already dead doctor, so this investigative ability is pretty bunk. Better for the real cop to do the investigating and find out who is for and against town.

There was also a Night 3. How interesting that you didn't mention it. Almost as if it didn't matter...
11-19-2012, 08:32 PM
[M] D'Anna

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Noctis

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Biggs

So why are you so sure people tried to kill you Noctis?

It's a surprise. You'll know why when you lynch me tomorrow and find out my role!

You're so sure I will win? What happened to your lifelong mafia goal?
11-19-2012, 08:34 PM
[M] Greg - Hot Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Biggs

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Noctis

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Biggs

So why are you so sure people tried to kill you Noctis?

It's a surprise. You'll know why when you lynch me tomorrow and find out my role!

You're so sure I will win? What happened to your lifelong mafia goal?

You will have 3-4 days' worth of utter insanity to lynch me on. A chimpanzee could lynch me. What could I possibly use against you? A whole day of the odd question here and there? I mean, there's meta evidence to suggest mafia but I'm not going to use that as it's not fair.

The only thing I have in my favour is if Blank gets lynched and is what I suspect him to be, and right now nobody else wants to ride that train. But it works both ways. If Blank is lynched and is town - I doubt it but in a mindsmurf mafia you can never be 100% sure - then I may as well just vote for myself tomorrow.
11-19-2012, 08:36 PM
[M] Trevor - Gay Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by Faris

I can't really see where they go. I can only see who they have targeted, but I do not know anything else. Sorry if my role is unhelpful at worst. Since Galuf is gone, my main target of choice is gone. I'll see what I can do in the future though, and I'm glaaad to have your vote of confidence, Refia.

Your role is quite helpful, but I think your playing it poorly. Which is why I think there's a decent chance your lying about it. I mean if I were a tracker I would probably investigate Wedge and see if he did any night actions in the night that weren't at a dead townies house, or something along those lines. Rather than watch the same old fart who shouldn't be any more suspicious than anyone else for 3 nights.

I would probably vote you now, but Rikku hiding under the radar bothers me a lot more, as well as I want to believe that your really an investigative role and that you and Wedge not dying in either night was either really well done protections/roleblocks, or hopes from the mafia that you are suspicious enough to get lynched and make us waste a day's kill.
11-19-2012, 08:41 PM
[M] D'Anna

I am 100% convinced that Faris is a tracker. Could be a mafia tracker, but not likely. Tracker is waaay too easy to prove since involved things only another member would know. For example, have Faris track Wedge and report back to us. If she picks the wrong players then Wedge can disprove it. You just can't keep up a false Tracker claim for very long. Much easier to claim something like Cop where false guesses can be explained by insanity.
11-19-2012, 08:42 PM
[M] Dave – Stepdad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Biggs

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Wedge

There is nothing to report since I don't get the results of my own investigations. I am not going to say who I investigated on Night 2 yet because I am not sure if Kain was allowed to do his own night action before he died and I don't want someone to pop up and deceive the town and me by saying, "Oh, I got that report, Kain must have switched me with so and so and I must have been the true target." That would just muddle things up further. Plus, Serah said she never received the first report and she was obviously town aligned and wouldn't have any reason not to tell the town about a report on an already dead doctor, so this investigative ability is pretty bunk. Better for the real cop to do the investigating and find out who is for and against town.

There was also a Night 3. How interesting that you didn't mention it. Almost as if it didn't matter...

I mentioned it in my earlier post, but since you missed it I will repost it here:

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Wedge

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Leon

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Setzer

Wedge - can you tell us who you investigated on N2/3? Who you sent the results to? You have given us a vague answer already today, but some specifics would have been nice.
I certainly hope that your inverstigation results come through today, since that's two investigations that just happened to lead to nothing. Unlucky, eh?

My guess is he is waiting for someone to come forward with a report so that he can determine if they are lying or not.

This. I am waiting to see what the person I sent the report to does with it.
11-19-2012, 08:44 PM
[M] D'Anna

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Noctis

You will have 3-4 days' worth of utter insanity to lynch me on. A chimpanzee could lynch me. What could I possibly use against you? A whole day of the odd question here and there? I mean, there's meta evidence to suggest mafia but I'm not going to use that as it's not fair.

The only thing I have in my favour is if Blank gets lynched and is what I suspect him to be, and right now nobody else wants to ride that train. But it works both ways. If Blank is lynched and is town - I doubt it but in a mindsmurf mafia you can never be 100% sure - then I may as well just vote for myself tomorrow.

So you're a mafia godfather trying to get the serial killer?
11-19-2012, 08:46 PM
[M] D'Anna

Wedge: Thanks. I did miss that. If the day end is close and no one has stepped up, can you at least reveal some of your information? There's no guarantee you'll be around tomorrow to continue baiting people.

I'll just step right up and say: I never received a damn thing. :(
11-19-2012, 08:48 PM
[M] Greg - Hot Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Biggs

So you're a mafia godfather trying to get the serial killer?

Correct.
11-19-2012, 08:48 PM
[M] Dave – Stepdad

I will do my best to enlighten town with what I know before I am offed, yes.

Show 200 post(s) from this thread on one page