-
How much time is left of this Day?
-
Until like noon tomorrow. (EDT)
-
16 hours and 10 minutes (12:30pm EDT tomorrow).
-
I just don't know whom to kill now.
I still wouldn't mind killing Myrtle or Dudley, regardless of what Severus may or may not be. I'd prefer of the two, Dudley, only because his death can give information, and I'd prefer that over muting Myrtle.
-
Thanks. Just wanted to know if I'd be online before the Day ended, if it doesn't end in a Majority.
-
Why is Myrtle voting for herself?
-
Iunno. Trying to look like the jester, I guess.
-
-
Well balls. I come back and Snape flips something interesting.
This is another case of wanting to believe. I trusted Neville yesterday and got burned. I don't want to do that again, but...
this is another situation of "What does Snape have to gain?"
We know lynchee and lyncher are gone and there is 99.9% chance there would not be two of those in the same game.
Really, what do we have to lose by knocking off old DD? We might solidify one of our most powerful roles - and we can always leave Myrtle for tomorrow. If DD is the godfather, does that mean Myrtle is just a poor player, or does it mean might have an usurper, or something?
Though perhaps they could get taken out tonight and we'd still learn something.
Also - while Buckbeak's story has some holes, it's still plausible. I've been trying to think up situations, and if Beaky here was somehow blocked on night 2 that would explain everything. Yes, it's kind of a stretch, but it's another situation where I'm not getting bad vibes.
Lastly, if I may, I'd like to find Hagrid what he finds so scummy about myself? The only way to win is by working together, and if I can clear something up, that'd be great.
-
Hermione:
I've been thinking about Buckbeak's claim, as well. We still haven't totally ruled out a second Mafia. I've been reading up on the roles and the Mafia Hitman and the Mafia Ninja could both slip through protective roles. If we are dealing with a second Mafia, they would have no problem killing off members of the first. That's just my own specualtion, though.
-
Thing is, I don't think Dudley is the godfather. Two godfathers is rather strange. True, there has been multiple scum groups before but with crap like Jester and Lyncher/Lynchee that is too many groups at once.
I still think Myrtle is the best bet. Again I reiterate that Snape is either confused or purposefully spreading lies. You ask what he has to gain? Well causing confusion is a large gain for the mafia. But in all honesty I think he is either insane or some other weird crap caveat that causes his "findings" to be different in some way.
Otherwise his roll would be way too powerful.
Right now my top two suspects are Myrtle and Buckbeak.
-
Yeah. Two mafia's is still a possibility. In this game, especially, the trick is to keep an open mind.
That said, I'm not entirely sure what to do today.
-
Peter: My role is too powerful? I have no choice in who I investigate. In that aspect, the Cop is far better than me. Really, when it comes down to it, if I turn out to be Record Keeper when I'm night killed/lynched then you'll be screwed Pettigrew. If I don't then you'll be safe. But in all honesty, until proven differently, I think you're the Jester and trying to cover for yourself.
-
I'll just go ahead and vote now :p
##Vote: Dudley Dursley
-
Pettigrew:
We haven't yet confirmed that there is a Jester... Unless you know something we don't. So far, Myrtle has claimed Jester, but she has also claimed many other things. Don't forget that Mafias don't have to be larger... with the number of players in this game, two small Mafias wouldn't be too impossible. If we do, in fact, lynch Dudley we have the possibility of confirming that second Mafia unless the Godfather got replaced somehow... If Dudley isn't a Godfather, we can begin looking closer at Snape. Dudley only claims Vanilla, rather than a power role, so if he is telling the truth, we have little to lose... don't we?
