Mafia X: Harry Potter and the LYNCHER WINS HURRAY! oh and town beat mafia I s'pose

Ok, WOW the Snape roleclaim is BIG.

But I believe it, Snape was against Dudley for a while now, it could indicate Snape knew and was seeing if he could lynch Dudley without having to give info away.
I'm lynching Dudley I knew he was scummy, and now we almost have proof its time to hang 'im.

##Unvote: Myrtle
##Vote: Dudley

P.S I did notice he was very quick to defend himself earlier, and on the first day, when I reread it again he was very sensitive when people had the slightest suspicion of him.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by [M] Buckbeak

I come back to find I'm in hot water, not good. I just want to know what makes me/us look so suspicious?

---

I believed Snape a little bit and wanted to test out his plan. Yeah, that's it, the suspect we have some plan going on.

As far as I see it, lynching Dudley is the only viable course of action, Buckbeak I'm no longer suspicious of you anymore but your roleclaim was just sudden at the time and seemed strange, thats okay now though. :)

I agree with everyone, Dudley might be the safest lead we've had all game long. Snape's roleclaim sounds very real. Plus, most of the roles seem to fit. (I say most, because the Jester doesn't) And if it doesn't, we know just who to lynch, because I seriously doubt a Insane record keeper(if that is even possible with exact role description).

Either he lies, or he doesn't. There is no sanity involved.

I suggest that Buckbeak protects Snape anyway, seeing as Snape would be a most likely target. If Dudley is confirmed, everyone will rally around Snape, seeing as he is the only confirmed townie. Plus, it could stop a nightkill. Very useful in my eyes.

Let's see what the lynch will bring, hopefully, a dead godfather.

##Unvote: Myrtle
##vote: Dudders

Myrtle has been behaving a little better, and Buckbeak I'm still not sure of. I've questioned the hippogriff some time ago and there are definite holes in his answers.

Thank you. :)

But Buckbeak don't jail snape he needs to make an investigation doesn't he? And if you role block him he can't... Correct me if I'm wrong.

I finally read through all the pages you wrote when I was asleep ;)

I guess the biggest thing happening was of course Snapes roleclaim, so I´ll just go referring to that an make some things clear. Essentially I do believe most of his claim. DD beeing the Godfather just seems possible to me. Seeing his old posts he has always been very quick with his votes when someone seemed suspicious or was bandwagoned. Also his first post after Snapes claim was to try an make us suspicious about his role.

I am really not sure, what to think about the Pettigrew-is-the-Jester theory. He just doesn´t look like beeing obsessed with us lynching him. Like Hagger said it also occured to me while reading that Snape himself seemed to be after us lynching him to test his claim.

As for my own role.. well, Snape is right!

I guess

##vote: Big D

would be the right thing to do today to further prove Snapes evidence.

Majority lynch! lets sit back and start planning for the next day.

Also people need to stop calling Dudley DD, its confusing because it sounds like your all talking about Demon Dude. xD

I was also playing with the idea of Buckbeak protecting Snape. True, he cannot make an investigation tonight, but this would in addition prove, if BB´s claim was thoroughly right.

It would waste what would possibly be a huge breakthrough however, I think let snape investigate Buckbeak then it proves TWO people are innocent.

WAIT... How come Snape didn't get shot if he investigated Filch?

I asked myself that question too. I am not really sure if investigating counts to targetting. But how else could he have found out? He has to have targetted me somehow to find out about my role. Or am I wrong?

He must have, thats mighty strange ....

Like I said before, a missed investigation is better than a dead proved townie and already having the mafia he investigated.

If Buckbeak really is a Jailkeeper(which I'm still not sure of) then protecting Snape is the best course of action.

We may not have the investigation, which is random and might not be helpful at all, but we wouldn't lose a proved townie.

Plus, he can just start up the investigations when the heat(so to say) is off.

I, for one, do not want to see Snape at the bottom of the pond tomorrow.

And an investigative role that learn the entire role is a great asset.

But we're wondering how Snape didn't die after he investigated a paranoid gun owner, anybody targetting a paranoid gun owner should die, right?

Sorry if I'm annoying you with all my posts by the way, I do tend to post alot. :moomba:

I didn't target him. My role says I randomly investigate somebody. This means that I don't actually target them specifically, although I was wondering about how I survived myself. It may have been a mistake on Harry's part, or because I don't target them, it doesn't count.

Sorry for the recent inactivity, but Denmark knows what's up so I won't be replaced.

As for whatever is going on right now though, It took me a while to catch up and I have to say that Snape's roleclaim is pretty big and I think if Buckbeak is the Jail Keeper, then they should protect Snape. Then we'll have two confirmed townies. If Snape is nightkilled even though he was under Buckbeak's "protection" then we can take down Buckbeak the next day for a mafia kill.