to the starter of this big-ass thread:
Good job taking back some of the stuff you said. *takes back drunk comment I made earlier* Four points:
1) Game reviewers pretty much never finish the games they review: I can understand that if it's a magazine or something, but I don't think that cuts it in this setting. EoFF will (barring disaster) still be here after you've finished FF7. Finish the entire game, consider playing once more to get any stuff you missed the first time, and then review to your heart's content.
2) I personally thought this soundtrack was pretty good. Listen to Still More Fighting (boss fight theme) and try to tell me it isn't good. If you want a crappy soundtrack, I personally found FF9's ST annoying. (But then, I never was a huge fan of the game...)
3) The graphics: they were good for their time first ever to do 3d blah blah blah :blahblah: now for my point: I noticed that generally, crappy character-models (like Cloud "Hoof-Hands" Strife) move through excellantly done backgrounds. (Reach the end of disc 1, around a certain Aeris scene, and you'll see exactly what I mean.) However, practical things like items and paths and exits sometimes get lost in the detail (and I don't care what you say, Select doesn't show everything). Still, I thought graphics were pretty good.
3 1/2) As for the "time goes on, graphics get better and stories get worse" thing: I haven't played most of the newer ones, but with FF7 as my first and FF9 as my second, I think I see what you mean. FF9 was good, but IMHO, it just wasn't as good as VII. (FF9 had 4 discs to 7's 3, yet I went through them a lot faster--and not just because of gameplay.)
Finally: I think the reason many people (me included) jumped on you was because in several cases, you were disrespecting something they had many fond memories of. FF7 was my first big RPG, and I was wowed by it. Not to mention fond memories associated with the game, etc. (Though like I said earlier, choosing this forum on this website to air your poorly formed opinions was definately a mistake.) Attacking this game--and (without meaning to) those memories... that got people mad.
I've typed too much. *yawns*