Anniversary Mafia Game Thread - The Final Day

Printable View

Show 200 post(s) from this thread on one page

11-21-2012, 03:46 AM
[M] Mike - Funny Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Relm

You can delete THAT and no one will hold it against you, fyi. xD

oh, leave it, funny at my expense is still funny.
11-21-2012, 03:47 AM
[M] Jeff - Single Dad

I've got no right to laugh at you, this is the first game of mafia I've played where I haven't posted on my EoFF account. Yet.
11-21-2012, 03:54 AM
[M] D'Anna

So here's my review of Setzer.

Day 1 - Made many poinltess posts and cast an inactive vote on Quina.

Day 2:

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Setzer

So, now that the first vote of the day has been cast, this is the point that we start wildly slinging accusations about, right? :shobon:

Anxious to get us to start going at each other's throats?

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Setzer

I personally don't see the thing against Cid, but it'll be something to keep an eye out for as the day progresses. I'm also not entirely convinced of Blank's bandwagoning in Day 1, seemed to be regular fare. Again, keeping an eye on things as people start to post more.

I'm also unsure if people are still just throwing votes out there for the lulz - I may just be a stick in the mud here, but now is time for serious talk, not voting for so-n-so because they voted for you. I'm looking at you Blank and Leila! :p This sort of thing doesn't help us determine anything - unless you had some legitimate reasoning behind your voting. If that is the case, I'd like to hear it, as I'm sure everyone else would too.

(Also it is bed time, I hope you all don't get too lynch crazy! :p)

Ooooh a defense of a known Mafia Godfather? Things are getting interesting. Note the mention of Leila too. Not sure he'd give up both of his buddies in this post, but you never know.

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Setzer

I am bad at this whole posting business. xD

Faris - Another silly roleclaim, eh? It wouldn't be mafia without a handful of claims a day! All we can do with this one is wait for Galuf's rebuttal. It could just be a claim of convenience though, she was under fire at the time of the claim... Time will tell. More than a little bit suspicious, I will admit.

Quistis - What about all these crazy role claims? I can just hardly believe that you have nothing to say about anything else that's happened during today. That the only thing you think is worthy of comment/suspicion occurred 3 pages ago. I do not 100% agree with the VOTE RIGHT NOW OR ELSE SCUM thing that Yuffie was shouting about, but I can understand why she did say this - voting can (and does) generate conversation. I don't get how that is enough to lay down a vote.

Leila - I'd like to hear more from you. We have the vote tally up, you said you would tell us something! :shobon: The only thing I can say about you is that your vote on Blank was at the tail end of the bandwagon, with the excuse of "He voted for me", which is not great. :p You have posted a fair bit today, but have said nothing, with promises of explanations later. This is no good to anyone!

Rydia - I'm not sure if she is scummy or just an overthinking townie or maybe she has something on Cid. Who knows at this point. I personally think it's that middle one and am willing to give the benefit of the doubt for just now.

Wakka - Somewhat suspicious with his claims of bus drivers out of nowhere, but I don't think it is any more crazy than Rydia's Cid-cop theory. However, his posting is a little bit all over the place, and that does worry me. Lots of activity with not much being said.

Not much time left today, eh? I feel that there has been plenty of suspicious behaviour today, but nothing to really cement my thoughts on a vote. I always think the best of people, which is super bad for this game. I should think you all scum until proven otherwise, eh? xD If I had to go with my gut...

##Vote: Leila

If only because of the lack of substance to her posts - everyone else despite how erratic their posts or their voting may be, do add something to the conversation. Essentially a joke vote and... nothing else from our friend Leila here.

We call this the "Look I'm being helpful by making a general list of people" post. Note that he is trying to deny Faris's claim and putting it to Galuf to come forward (knowing he never would).

Most of the rest of his posts haven't really said much. He's very non-committal though. Always short quips or general statements without really digging in.

Hmmm...
11-21-2012, 03:54 AM
[M] Walter - Smart Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Rydia

smurf wrong account

pretend I said that.

Of course. I figured it was you the moment of your wall of text. But, that's not part of this game. Let's bring our focus to Refia's role... do we really know if she is really aligned with mafia? Usually, as a spy, she should be, but there was no indication, just blue to indicate that her role was investigative, so we don't know if she was really scum. I guess we can find out once we finish this game
11-21-2012, 03:59 AM
[M] Mike - Funny Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Faris

Of course. I figured it was you the moment of your wall of text.

And not, say, at the start of Day 3 when I came out and said more or less "hey guys look I'm Bleys"?
11-21-2012, 04:02 AM
[M] Walter - Smart Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Rydia

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Faris

Of course. I figured it was you the moment of your wall of text.

And not, say, at the start of Day 3 when I came out and said more or less "hey guys look I'm Bleys"?

I think I may have missed that. :shobon:
11-21-2012, 04:11 AM
[M] Walter - Smart Dad

[QUOTE='[M] Leila;3168561']
Side note: Why haven't the mafia taken out Faris or Wedge yet if they're tracking/cop roles? Just a thought.
QUOTE]

Actually, I do want to say that you do have a great point. Judging from what you said, Wedge and I should have been gone, but it seems that either one or both of us could be scum. But first, let's take a look at our roles, I happen to be a Tracker, and Wedge has some sort of investigative powers but doesn't know his results, only the people he sends the report to. The mafia would have targeted Wedge the moment on the night following the moment he revealed his role... maybe it was convenient that he stuck around to distract town with false hopes allowing mafia to get what they want. What about me? All I know is who a person targeted, and nothing else, and I did help save Cid from dying when I revealed that he was Galuf's last target. I think the choice is clear between Wedge and myself.

##Vote: Wedge
11-21-2012, 04:16 AM
[M] Mike - Funny Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Faris

I did help save Cid from dying when I revealed that he was Galuf's last target. I think the choice is clear between Wedge and myself.

Unless you're mafia and were trying, successfully as it would happen, to deprive Psy of my protection
11-21-2012, 04:20 AM
[M] Walter - Smart Dad

I don't know. trout happens.
11-21-2012, 04:23 AM
[M] Mike - Funny Dad

It's a compliment either way; either you did save Cid, who is town if you are, or you played me like a fiddle.
11-21-2012, 04:56 AM
[M] D'Anna

Is this the lull point of the day where nothing happens?
11-21-2012, 05:15 AM
[M] Mike - Funny Dad

Some people haven't been on since the start of the game day.
11-21-2012, 05:55 AM
[M] D'Anna

Blank was a slippery one. I'll give her that.

For instance, she voted Galuf on Day 1 once Sazh was in the lead, a clever way to keep them from being linked.

Blank also had some interesting exchanges with Leila on Day 2, but it's too much to quote. At first they both voted for Yuffie, but then Leila quickly unvoted after getting pressured by Noctis. Then Blank switched her vote to Leila.
11-21-2012, 06:18 AM
[M] Dave – Stepdad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Faris

I've been tracking Galuf actually since Night 1 if he would strike again. For some reason, I didn't get a result on Night 2, but it turned out I did get one on the night he was killed, surprisingly. He targeted Cid.

I just realized that Faris did not see what Galuf did on night 2 and the reason was more than likely because the Mafia made an effort to role block him so they could poison Noctis unhindered. It takes 2 days for the poison to kick in and the person dies on the 2nd night meaning that since last night was night 4 then 2 nights before that was night 2. Cid is still in danger because he was visited by Galuf on night 3 and tonight will be 2 nights later as it will be night 5.
11-21-2012, 06:29 AM
[M] D'Anna

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Wedge

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Faris

I've been tracking Galuf actually since Night 1 if he would strike again. For some reason, I didn't get a result on Night 2, but it turned out I did get one on the night he was killed, surprisingly. He targeted Cid.

I just realized that Faris did not see what Galuf did on night 2 and the reason was more than likely because the Mafia made an effort to role block him so they could poison Noctis unhindered. It takes 2 days for the poison to kick in and the person dies on the 2nd night meaning that since last night was night 4 then 2 nights before that was night 2. Cid is still in danger because he was visited by Galuf on night 3 and tonight will be 2 nights later as it will be night 5.

That doesn't work because according to Faris, Galuf targeted Quistis on night 1, and she died on night 2. So that's one day to take effect. Noctis more likely died by a Mafia Ninja. Since we have a Tracker in play, a Ninja makes sense since they can't be tracked.

Show 200 post(s) from this thread on one page