Mafia X: Harry Potter and the LYNCHER WINS HURRAY! oh and town beat mafia I s'pose

Quote:

---

Whenever I'm awake the thread is either totally dead or people are just going "hmmm....this person is scummy....but so is this person! gee who to vote...maybe this other third person?" and then when I'm sleeping the thread explodes and I awake to find a million billion Myrtle role claims or the town doing something dumb like trying to lynch Snape and Hagrid. Or sometimes even intellegent posts.

---

This is exactly my situation.

Anyway, my reason for voting for Voldemort was to get some heat going, it wasn't anything serious but the fact that Myrtle was so quick to explain the decision has me wondering if they/he is just going along with the bandwagon to not look like scum.

I'm also suspicious of Snape not being targeted by Mafia(s) since she is a Record Keeper. At least one of the mafias would have targeted her by now. I understand you guys' suspicion of me, and maybe I'm not playing the most active game ever, but since we seem like we're at a standstill I'll try and contribute as much as I can.

If anyone has anything to ask me, then go ahead.

Oh, and let me get this out of the way.

##Unvote: Voldemort

Okay... so say that Buckbeak's night action went through and Snape was roleblocked... that still doesn't explain why Buckbeak was killed instead of Snape. Sirius was killed even with Buckbeak's protection/roleblock. It's not impossible for there to be a Mafia Hitman or a Mafia Ninja... which means that Buckbeak's protection wouldn't matter anyway. One would think that they would go after the majorly important roles, like Snape's, until Buckbeak started stopping the Mafia's night actions. We have yet to kill a hitman or ninja, so they could have easily just killed Snape and gotten it over with.

About Snape not being targeted:

He only just claimed yesterday, and since mostly everyone assumed that Buckbeak would be targeting him, it would make sense to off Buckbeak first, right?

@ Dumbledore:

Who do you think is the smartest person to lynch?

This question I keep thinking myself, so I might as well ask everyone else's opinion about it.

And of course, old time favorite: Who do you suspect the most?

and remember the mafia had a roleblocker, too, so Buckbeak was most likely blocked.

Luna:

Not necessarily... as I said, right now Buckbeak is protecting pro-town roles with night actions like investigation and such... Why would the Mafia want to stop that? Buckbeak may have been protecting our power roles, but he was also stopping the night actions.

Okay, got back sooner than I thought. ##Unvote: Hagrid, for now.

Harry, time till lynching?

They probably didn't know what Buckbeak was, I don't think he roleclaimed before Sirius died. Assuming we have two factions, the faction Sirius wasn't in was the one that killed him.

Severus Snape (2): Rubeus Hagrid, Remus Lupin, Moaning Myrtle
Rubeus Hagrid (1): Mr. Filch, Voldemort, Moaning Myrtle
Mr. Filch (1): Moaning Myrtle
Moaning Myrtle (1): Luna Lovegood
Voldemort (0): Albus Dumbledore, Moaning Myrtle

2 hours and 41 minutes.

Luna why lynch me?

ANYWAY. To put all that in one post:


The mafia wouldn't have targetted Snape last night because Buckbeak was probably blocking him and such. So they killed Buckbeak, leaving him with no protection. Sirius still died because the Prostitute may have been blocking Buckbeak that night. They most likely didn't know what his role was at that point, seeing how it was only night two.

My guess is that the Prostitute and Sirius were in seperate factions.



Myrtle: I am voting you for the same reasons I voted you the last...two? days. You're scum.

Remus I'm in the middle of answering your question. I just keep refreshing to see if posts are coming.

You'll facepalm when it's revealed I'm townie then.

Everyone would, Myrtle. They'd probably throw things at you, too.