one more thing, Xiahou why haven't you voted for Guan? if you are what you say you are then his story does not make any sense, and that would make him scum. or do you know something we don't?
##Vote: Xiahou Dun
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_uqNpu6E0Dc...1600/snape.jpg
Guys, I fear I may have just messed up the entire mafia game for everyone, please give me a moment to think.
Will the game end?
Find out Next time on... MAFIA!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Lu Meng
This is a lot of stuff to come back to. I know it's not very many posts, but they are long and in depth. Well, Guan Yu's are. As I see it, Lord Dun is trying to grasp at anything he can to stand up to Yu's words. I'm not saying he's scum but his story just seems to be made up as he goes.
Why would you call your role useless? Being able to save someone who we know is Innocent, or have an important role, like Cao Cao seems to be pretty beneficial to me.
I have not lied back Sima. I've only spoken when I had something to say. And now that I'm being made to pass for something that I'm not is where I really need to speak!
I did not use my role because it's a very risky one. It means certain death to me, and I don't really want to die. I want to keep on playing. Besides, I'm sure there's a doctor alive, since my role is flawed.
And I believe I can vote whenever I want to right? What does that prove anyway?
I think it's you who are grasping at everything and blaming it on me.
I think I'v fixed things... we'll see. If I ruined this for you guys I will put the word homo across my avatar for a month
ROFL. I'm not saying you should have used it. I'm saying its not useless, as you claimed it to be.
If you want to stay alive then it is useless.
This is how I reasoned :
- If I don't protect then I can only die by mafia targeting me.
- If I DO protect then I can die either from mafia targeting me or from mafia targeting the person I protect. So I'm more likely to die this way.
Well that's fine when you're only looking out for number 1. I'm just saying that if you have a role that wins when the town wins then you would want to ensure the most powerful people stay alive so that the town wins. Not just protect your own booty.
Like I said before, it's not that I'm saying you are scum. It just seems bit... uhh... Dismantled?
I have read everyone's argument and I find Gaun Yu's argument well presented and more persuasive. In fact, other than Zhen Ji, he's the only one who has made any sense!
##Vote: Xiahou Dun
No that's not it. You're only believing him because he claimed cop!
Zhao Yun claimed cop and no one believed him.
Yeah but Zhao Yun contradicted his claims. He claimed an investigation on a night that did not exist.
I'm saying that in my claim vs Guan's, Guan's wins because the cop is more believable.
You've all criticized my role but never did you question Guan's.