Mafia IX: Ace Edition Game Over - Mafia Victory - Town of Failure Destroyed

Printable View

Show 200 post(s) from this thread on one page

06-19-2008, 01:09 AM
[M] Colette

In regards to being one of the first to post in the day: there's always going to be a "first poster of the day". I am a VERY active player, because I have no life.
06-19-2008, 01:11 AM
[M] Kurt - Cool Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Damon Gant

Nice of you to show up, Valant...and then disappear right away. :mad:

I didn't disappear.
06-19-2008, 01:12 AM
[M] Colette

ooooh....ok ^^
06-19-2008, 01:29 AM
[M] Colette

*sigh*

Only 11 players left. Very uneven atm in regards to the town:mafia ratio.

THINK LONG AND HARD BEFORE YOU MAKE YOUR FINAL VOTE, EVERYONE! We can't make any more mistakes.
06-19-2008, 01:43 AM
[M] Jeff - Single Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Valant Gramarye

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Damon Gant

Nice of you to show up, Valant...and then disappear right away. :mad:

I didn't disappear.

Thanks for contributing by explaining why you never ever vote or by claiming. Much appreciated. :tongue:

Looking at my vote tally thing, I think Maya comes off as pretty dodgy. The green and cyan voting days were the most crucial, I feel, as that was when Ema came out of hiding. Maya is the only person not to have voted on either day. I know Ema said something about her earlier but it could have been distancing.
06-19-2008, 01:43 AM
[M] Colette

I believe the split is 6 town and 5 mafia. Here's what I think:

[M] Bikini

Why? Simple. All she does is attack, attack, attack. "You're mafia unless you can tell me why your last two replacements said what they said." WTF?! There's no way in HELL anyone could do that, especially if they disagreed a lot with what was said...want proof?. I can prove it if Judge will let me tell you who I am on eoff.

[M] Trucy Wright

She posts exactly like how Ema did, and Ema ended up being mafia.

[M]Furio Tigre

Not sure what to think...Leaning towards Mafia because he's pulling the same Plum did, the sympathy card. It doesn't work twice, dude.

[M] Dick Gumshoe

Not sure what to think once again, but leaning towards town. I believe the Hider claim, but not enough for him to be completely town in my eyes.

[M] Phoenix Wright

Not sure what I think about him either. He seems friendly, but who knows.
06-19-2008, 01:45 AM
[M] Colette

Also, yes. Maya's actions are questionable too, because just like Ema and Trucy, she only shows up every now and then to vote, long post, gone. Laying low.
06-19-2008, 01:45 AM
[M] Colette

I'd post the rest of my list but damn if I can focus that long right now.
06-19-2008, 01:51 AM
[M] Mike - Funny Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Damon Gant

[M]Furio Tigre

Not sure what to think...Leaning towards Mafia because he's pulling the same :skull::skull::skull::skull: Plum did, the sympathy card. It doesn't work twice, dude.

It wasn't the sympathy card it was the your all dumbasses if you do this card (>^ _ ^.)>
>
My main person on my list currently is Bikini she certainly had sway over all of you easily to throw you all into the crapper by voting me. And she said she was positive about me being Mafia. I'm not though she Only got that from Ema being nice to me which I thought was weird but when you think about it I wasn't the target at the time so when she said it she didn't care wheter I lived or died.

Next on my list is Mr Valant. When we called you Pop! here you came. Finals and MSN are good excuses I'd say but the thing is you were waiting there because a few minutes after we mentioned you you were there.

That's all I got
06-19-2008, 02:05 AM
[M] Anise

1) Now I really suspect Gant. ORiginally he was saying me suspecting him so much was understandable, now he's throwing it back at me saying it was a Mafia tactic.

2) OF course I attack, attack, attack, thats how one finds Mafia.

3) And that was hardly the only reason Tigre. You have yet to contribute anything useful, in the beggining you voted for someone simply because they voted for you. In addition, when I brought up the Idea you came off as a person who just wanted to get people lynched earlier, you siad "Fair Enough" and left it at that. I mean really, WTF?

4) If we're all Claiming, Vanilla town here. :p
06-19-2008, 02:08 AM
[M] Anise

5) I'm flattered you say I have sway over people. :bigsmile:
06-19-2008, 02:11 AM
[M] Mike - Funny Dad

Hello shi-Valant
06-19-2008, 02:12 AM
[M] Mike - Funny Dad

Quote:

Originally Posted by [M] Bikini

5) I'm flattered you say I have sway over people. :bigsmile:

Yea seriously first it was you then within minutes I was 2 votes from the noose
06-19-2008, 02:13 AM
[M] Jeff - Single Dad

As you all love her so much, let me have a look at Bikini.

Kept very low on Day 1 and 2.

Day 3, comes in and votes for Luke when the scores are 5-5 between Godot and Plum. Luke had been suspected the previous day and at the time had 0 votes. Bikini then switches to Plum, despite never even having mentioned her before, on the premise of "saving Godot." Reinforces the belief that she was on Godot's side with these posts in the discussion thread.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bikini

I am sorry Godot. I failed you. :cry:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bikini

I really did try to save you. You were the only one to treat me like a real lady. :cry:

Seems a bit desperate for everyone to see that she was against the doctor being lynched. Nothing wrong with being against that, but there is everything wrong with playing it up, and there is everything wrong with voting for someone who is now confirmed town for no reason.

Day 4, she was all over Luke again and also suspected Damon for not wanting to be held accountable for his predecessor's actions. Nothing too wrong there, except for still being on Luke but eh. Then the :skull::skull::skull::skull:storm happens.

Quote:

cause I can't see a Mafia pulling Role blocker out on us unless he is a Prostitute, and can thus prove he can block roles much like a Roleblocker.

A very interesting quote, made before Ema posted her claim. Perhaps they had already discussed that Ema could claim her role as prostitute and have it proven.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bikini

And finally, on the whole Roleblocker situation, there are so many different reasons it could have played out like it did, I have the strongest urge not to touch this one, but it needs to be touched.

And I think Jean is the man to do it.

Pretty much urges Jean to sort the roleblocker thing out, presumably to follow whatever the guy said but that's just a presumption.

Now then, what was the spanner in Ema's works? What ruined her plan? The cop claiming in defence of Will. The mafia had no idea that was going to happen. Bikini seemed quick to pour distrust onto Lamiroir.

Quote:

And I'm very hesitant to believe that Cop Claim

Quote:

I'm all for continuing discussion on it after the alleged Cop posts responding to me, but I'm not sure I'll be inclined to change my vote to either one, as Luke is still my topic suspect, as there is not real way to know if Ema is guilty right now.

If this is a face Roleclaim, we're taking the bait.

If it's real, there's still a chance of a second roleblocker, and I'd like to wait a night to give the supposed Cop another investigation to try and gauge a bit more trust in her.

"Alleged cop" "supposed cop"! I love it! But later on when everyone else seems to believe Lamiroir, ie, casting doubt on her did not work, Bikini does a 180 and seems to trust her.

Day 5, posts bare minimum reason for voting for Miles

Quote:

Just read others reasoning to vote Edge. I'll re-read everythign soon o try and get a better Idea of what the hell you people are doing today.

As momentum starts to build against Ema, she quickly switches to Ema, again for minimal reasoning.

Quote:

AFter reading again, I can't see a reason to stick with Edge.

So, since I believe Will over Emma,

She explains further when asked but I dunno it seems to me she just wanted to quickly get in on the Miles and Ema bandwagons in a vote first, ask questions later way.

Next day, votes Gant.

Quote:

And Sorry Gant, but you past two players have been far to suspicious for my tastes.

Doesn't even explain why they have been suspicious! Quickly u-turns onto Plum with no reasoning again.

Quote:

Oh screw this.

And now I think this is today

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bikini

So, for now I'll vote Tigre. Kalvier made a lot of good points earlier about him, and given Tigre was originally my #2, I see no reason not to vote for him now.

Well, I didn't really make a lot of good points against the guy, just the one. Again with the minimal reasoning.

So there you go, that's my analysis of Bikini. Is she scummy? Oh yes she is. But that's nothing really. YOU'RE ALL GOD DAMN SCUMMY. Every damn last one of you is a suspicious bastard and it is driving me slowly insane.
06-19-2008, 02:16 AM
[M] Dave – Stepdad

This is hard >.<

Show 200 post(s) from this thread on one page