Printable View
As a result of making it to the Minigames in a recent episode of Lets Play FFX HD #shameless plug it got me thinking that most of these minigames are dumb.
Which one is the worst. Vote in the comments (Ha, catchphrase from our lets play which you should totally watch)
Toss up between Lightning Dodging and Butterfly Catching. smurf all of those noises.
butterfly catching and lightning doding were both terrible. I voted lightning dodging.
Blitzball is actually amazing and doesn't belong on this list.
Blitzball because it was the only mandatory one and I HATED IT
how typical of a girl to not like sports
pah
Don't make me push you
Let's blitz over it :|
:|
Actually, this is my exact reasoning. I would hate it regardless, but it's the only mini-game that you're forced to play.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pumpkin
Snow also hates dodging Lightning so he just doesn't:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iZSoM5RjBWM
I was going to say Chocobo Dodger, but I beat that. I've never beat Lightning Dodging. I got to 83 and almost broke my Vita though.
Butterfly catching. Love Blitzball, rarely had trouble with Chocobo Racing, and Lightning Dodging is only a problem because it takes so long. I can never do butterfly catching right though, no matter how many times I try.
Where's my "all of the above" choice? FFX seriously had the worst collection of mini-games in the series though X-2 certainly tried to give it a run for its money. I've never actually gotten Wakka's ultimate weapon completed though, largely because I don't have time to play poorly balanced water sports tournaments for hours on end.
Blitzball.
Blitz
Ball.
I HATE THEE FOREVER
Well I've finished FFX multiple times, all the minigames completed so I may be kind of biased now but really the worst one is either Cochobo dodger or Monster Hunting if you are really unlucky.
While I didn't like the mechanics behind BB, I didn't mind playing it. Sure getting Wakka's ultimate weapon and Auroch's reels took decent amount of time, it wasn't that frustrating for me.
Considering that I like battles a LOT in FFX, monster hunting wasn't really a problem for me sans few exceptions like when you have whole area cleared and you are just waiting for the last tonberry to show up. That sucks allright.
Lighting Dodge... I never done it the "legal" way. A.K.A. dodging random flash screens. I always did this one through those "lighting will always strike" areas and thus I never really had a problem with this one.
Butterfly Cathing sure can suck the first ten - twenty times but once you realize that the butterflies do not change their position at all, it can become very easy so I never had a serious problem with this one either.
Well since I have to choose, the very worst for me was always the Chosobo catcher since I had to run it really good AND wait for great "map".
I would rather dodge lightning 500 times than catch butterflies. That is the main reason I have only powered up Kimahri's ultimate weapon once.
Neither my friend (who can do anything) nor I have ever successfully completed butterfly catching. Everything else sucks, but we can do it.
I lied, Blitzball doesn't suck, you suck, Blitzball is the best. Also monster catching is awesome and I wish it was in every FF.
Lightning Dodging. I can enjoy all other minigames but Lightning Dodging. If it just hadn't required you to do them in a row it would've been fine, albeit even more of a stupid waste of time.
Monster Catching was an awesome sidequest.
Blitzball is one of the most fun minigames in the series. Next to Triple Triad and maybe Chocobo Hot & Cold.
Butterfly Catching is mostly memorization, but I personally never had issues with it. It sucks that you can leave the screen afterwards and lose your winning run. But the minigame itself is okay.
Catcher Chocobo is fun. Maybe it's because I played this game a lot as a kid before I even knew about the special reward for getting 0:0.0, maybe because it's so algorithmic and theoretically predictable that I can blame just about all my failures on my own lack of skill, maybe it's because I just love chocobos. But this minigame is pretty damn fun for me.
But I cannot defend Lightning Dodging. I just can't. Which is why I don't do it. Problem solved.
Blitzball. I simply hate it!
Actually none of them are too bad. Lightning dodging can be done within 20 minutes or so, but I do agree that it's not a very engaging minigame. I think it took me an hour or so for the butterfly catching the one and only time I've done it. Compared to common RPG grinds that's not that bad in terms of time investment.
I'd rather have these quests than a 1/1000 chest spawn, or farming a certain monster praying for the RNG to cooperate.
Wow, very surprised at all the hate for Blitzball. Not only was it the finest minigame in FFX, but arguably in the whole series. The only one that could rival it is Triple Triad imo.
Back to the topic, I'd say Lightning Dodging. Never had much of a problem with Chocobo Racing or Butterfly Catching, but the lightning was just so damn tedious.
Chalk me down to the "Blitzball is awesome" crowd.
Lightning Dodge for the lose.
Lightning Dodge. Easy. Butterfly catching is difficult, but ultimately possible. Blitzball's only problem is time. Soooo much time taken up.
I loathed the lightning dodge. I gave up and said "piss on it...I'm done"
Normally when its hard for me to get something I want. I turn to using cheats. I don't see anything wrong with it as most FF games are not online so its not hurting anyone and I just want to have fun.
On the PS2 version I used a Game Shark or a Code Breaker to get all Celestial Weapons. I used a Save Editor or Hyperkin's Game Genie PC mod tool for the PS3 version.
Lightning dodging. Get out.
also I loved Blitzball
I'm very suspicious that Lightning Dodging is used as a form of torture in some dictatorships.
In all seriousness though, lightning dodging isn't a mini-game. A game is meant to be fun. How is dodging (and failing) 200 strikes IN A ROW a fun use of my time?
Butterfly catching is also dull as hell, but at least it is not as difficult as lightning dodging. Chocobo dodger is worse and is very hard, but at least it isn't so soul-crushing as lightning dodging because of the Chocobos. I've completed Chocobo dodger once, and was intensely happy after it.
I used to hate Blitzball, not helped by the poor introduction to the mini-game with the Luca Goers. But once you get used to it and know who the good players are to scout, it actually becomes mildly enjoyable. I only ever play it enough to get Wakka's stuff, though. Finally, monster hunting gives a run for lightning dodger's money. It isn't so bad at first, until you realize to get really far into it, you basically have to max the majority of your stats, and that gets tedious.
Agree. Having done most of them recently for the first time, none of them caused me as much grief as I thought they would. Exaggerations all round. Blitzball is the most time consuming, and that is a fantastic minigame that I am happy to pour hours into.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pete for President
Chocobos and butterflies. That's all I got. The rest was tolerable, even doable and sometimes interesting. The chocobos and butterflies were just rage-inducing.
Yup, this.Quote:
Originally Posted by BlasterDarkRen
The mini-games in FFX (barring Blitzball) are definitely the worst I've experienced.
The most irritating minigame in FFX is Lightning Dodging - I'm not even trying, because I find it pretty stressful and... C'mon! 200 times IN A ROW for Venus Sigil, really?! XD
Even these Chocobo minigames are less frustrating than that! XD
And hey, I love Blitzball - that's my favourite part of FFX. <3
This poll requires an 'All of the above' option...
Yeah, I agree with you. :PQuote:
Originally Posted by Silent Warrior
I didn't like any of the minicames really, it is one of the weaknesses of the game imo. If I had to pick one I'd say Lightning Dodging is the worst.
Blitzball is pretty legit in FFX, because Tidus and Wakka are Blitzers, so lack of Blitzball would hurt the game IMHO.Quote:
Originally Posted by Egami
About the rest of minigames... yeah, they shouldn't be included there.
I don't know about Chocobo riding in previous games, but I think that Chocobo training should be easier. XD
Oh, not saying it shouldn't have been included and it does ties in well with the story; it just could have been more fun to play imo.Quote:
Originally Posted by TheZanmato
Yes, it could, I agree. It's pretty screwed in FFX-2... I just hate this game generally, but this aspect of game is the worst one.Quote:
Originally Posted by EgamiOh, not saying it shouldn't have been included and it does ties in well with the story; it just could have been more fun to play imo.Quote:
Originally Posted by TheZanmato
In ffx I hate Blitzball so much,
In the x-2 I'll say giving a massage to Leblanc^^;
I finally got some "No Encounter" gear, got to 13 before I was zapped..... Haven't made another attempt yet.Quote:
Originally Posted by Egami
The chocobo game led me to some actual bodily harm, so that one.
ive rarely been as angry at a video game as when i did the chocobo one dodging birds. it was the worst.
i also hated the butterfly one.
the lightning one i found strangely relaxing.
i hated the mini-games in this game, overall
The lightning one took too much time. 200 is a lot and it's time consuming for what I considered to be a very piss poor return on investment.
The lightning one is the worst, by far. Boring, too much time invested, too easy to lose, no way to track progress, no way to save, no engagement, no fun. Chuck it in the bin and move on.
I did this legitimately exactly once. When I went to replay on the HD version, I cheated and ran a computer script to dodge for me, and just walked away from the game for a couple of hours.
There’s a bypass though. In one exact spot the Lightning always strikes when you approach. Using that exploit, you can do it pretty fast and relatively stress-free.
No such exploit for the Chocobo minigane tho
See i never had issues with the chocobo minigame. But the lightning? :argh:
It's been over three years since I made this post and I'm still really smurfing angry about it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Psychotic
Man am I ever grateful for the save editor for the Steam version. If I ever replay this game I'll never actually have to do those minigames again.
I would say the Chocobo Catcher was the worst for me, I didn't curse as much during the Lightning Dodge though and it was a pain in the ass.
Personally, Lightning Dodging. I never even bothered with the Chocobo one, though, so maybe that one's even worse.