EoFF ranks the tunes: Music of Final Fantasy

Thread Directory
Qualifying Round 1
Qualifying Round 2
Qualifying Round 3
Qualifying Round 4
Qualifying Round 5
Qualifying Round 6

-------------------
Hey look at all these threads ranking various aspects of the fandom. Are you like me and think THEY'RE ALL SO smurfING BORING???

Yes?

ok lets do something interesting then

PM me some nominations! For the sake of simplicity, throw in which Final Fantasy it's from, too. We have actually quite a lot of ground to cover, so I'm not going to limit nominations! Send me literally all the musics you like! 10 is a good number if you want/need a suggestion.

Anything less than 200 candidates is gonna be underwhelming, and also that's a lot of candidates so I'll hold a qualifying round between nominations and eliminations to weed out the jerks who just sent me entire OSTs. I have a plan, do not fear!

Hell yes. This is going to take some thought.

This would be a cool follow up to the current EoFF ranks, I think. I'll try and gather my nominations and send them your way today :)

Feel free to send in nominations as you think of them!

I already worked mine out. I got 60 :D

Yeah I just bashed out about 60 too. More people should take part in this, it's gonna be great.

60 noms and you didnt even go into side games! Those are a thing too, you know!

I've sent a few in, I'll try and think of more too!

Alright, just sent mine in :)

I agree we need more people jumping into this, come on free Kupo Nuts for all :p

5 people have submitted nominations so far!

199 Nominations
147 Unique track titles
1 Track submitted by everyone so far! (I'm gonna let it skip the qualifying round if it can keep that up)

Since there's enough nominees and a lot of ground to cover, expect the first Qualifying round to start within the next 12 hours. Nominations will remain open, of course!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WildRaubtier

1 Track submitted by everyone so far! (I'm gonna let it skip the qualifying round if it can keep that up)

---

You can just go ahead and give "One Winged Angel" a bye to the finals.

As a huge, huge FF music fan, I definitely need to get together a nomination list for you. But as a huge, huge FF music fan, I can't imagine it being less than 200 songs long.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by metagloria

I can't imagine it being less than 200 songs long.

---

so?

I will do what I can to get a list to you, Kent, this is a great idea.

EDIT: Do you have a plan to take care of the songs that appear in multiple titles? I mean, I hope we don't end up with two (or more) different Final Fantasy Theme songs in the later stages. Would be good to just figure out which is best early on, and then use that as the only one that goes into the knockout stage (assuming there is one).

Only just noticed your edit. You should have just double posted!

Not that it seems like its going to happen, but my reasoning is that each iteration is its own entity for the sake of this competition. Ergo, if both nominated versions of Battle on the Big Bridge (which may happen) or the victory fanfare (yeah right!) get through, they'll take up a single entry each.

Last call for nominations! Remember, they may be used for tie breaking purposes as well!

Oh wow, a bite :D

You know what that means? Nominations extended! Let's go for an even 300 entries! (There'll be 300 anyway, I'm just gonna look for more nominations of my own if no one else offers any)

Are you still thinking you're going to cut it down to like... 16 entries? Because I hope this one drags out a little longer, I like the idea of cutting it to about 50-70 (can be multiple choice at this stage still) and then having to make a lot of hard decisions on the way to a final. :D

At this point I'm struggling to normalise the votes while maintaining the obvious outliers. Case in point: To Zanarkand in the first poll, which outperforms every other song in every other poll. Problem is, Poll 1 had 18 voters and most have only 12, so when I normalise the votes it does pretty poorly, which is a bad outcome.

I've got a week to work on it still, though. Maybe I'll have to extend the field a bit!

I suggest going by percentages instead of quantity of votes.

Keep up the good work :up:

Then the polls which had a lower turnout (which I personally correlate with lower interest in that particular round's offerings) get higher representation! Bad outcome!

This is serious business!

I don't think it's to do with them not having any interest in any of the songs, more to do with people being lazy and participating less as rounds go on. This is a normal thing with these sort of events. You could of course try an "and/or" thing, where either x many votes OR x percentage means they qualify.

I think I've solved my problem. I'm going to invert the votes - ie subtract how many votes each track has from the total voters. That should solve my issue - popular songs get lower scores (good) and it doesn't matter how many people voted.

Here we go, the competition bracket is up! First thread up in an hour or so.

Attachment 63631

So many eliminations! Shame to see classics such as Liberi Fatali and the Chocobo & FF Themes cut out, but I guess the standard of music is just that damned high.

All but two songs are from FF5-7. :lol:

Are you doing a losers bracket so we get a 1st-3rd list?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Loony BoB

So many eliminations! Shame to see classics such as Liberi Fatali and the Chocobo & FF Themes cut out, but I guess the standard of music is just that damned high.

---

"Liberi Fatali" is the second-best track in the series. Objectively. This bracket means nothing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VeloZer0

Are you doing a losers bracket so we get a 1st-3rd list?

---

I suppose that's possible!

Hope 'Pandamonium' makes an appearance. Love the ominous, dramatic theme played by gorgeous pipe organ.