Printable View
i have noticed that there is no post counter. In my opinion the post counter doesnt promote spamming and i think it actually makes the message board more fun. I have been on other messag boards where if you spam you will have your post counter sent to 0 or banned for continual spaming, i think you should give the post counters another shot at least for a little while. And if it dosnt work out you can always take them off. please take this into consideration.
It's a case of "Been there and done that", unfortunately. I, for one, don't mind post counts, but they do promote spamming, regardless of how they are used. Since we decided to get rid of post counts a couple of years ago, things have been much nicer around here, as I'm sure the Knights will agree. Besides, people come here for discussion, not to see their post counter rise.
Nice suggestion, though. :)
Plus, in ANY kind of situation, I could all be like "Shut up, Rainecloud, my post count is higher than yours." And rest assured, I would. So don't do it, for the sake of everyone else, and me.
We've been over this around here a lot of times. I kind of like post counts, but I'm outnumbered. :p
People often argue that post counts aren't accurate anyway, since the board was reincarnated a couple times and old posts get pruned.
SILENCE! Post counts are useful to us as a scapegoat to distract the public from their REAL problems, like our crippling newbie shortage, and a corrupt government of incompetent Cid's Knights.
It has been my experience that post counts promote childish competitiveness. I know two guys on boards I posted on (or own, in the second case) who actually used their admin power to augment their post count so that it'd be higher than my own (I was the highest poster on both forums). Tell me that's not counterproductive.
How about we just ban everybody who cares about post counts?
There is a post count.
Just go into someones profile and click the little "All posts by this dude" thing.
I am happy to say that I have [strike]1030[/strike] 1031 posts.....BAM!
Can't I have a custom rank now? :eek:
Citizen Bleys, you sly dawg, you have over 2000! so does Shlupquack!
That isn't accurate either, TastyPies. Everytime the board is pruned, posts are lost.
Yeah. All that really matters is that I have the highest post count at all times, and I do right now (by just shy of 2000 posts), so all is well with the world. Once you come down to it, the fact that I post a lot in the Site Staff forums is what gives me my huge edge. If you want to compete with me, you have to do a lot of work. It's true, it's true. And I only just found this out now! I thought I hadn't been posting much lately. Guess I was wrong. Oh well.
But yeah, as RSL said, post counts actually don't mean jack. I don't care if they're put back or not, but I also think it would have just as many downsides as it would upsides. If not more. Then there's the politics involved with resetting post counts, and people get all snarky, and we have to shoot them. :(
I bet everybody who doesnt want post counts would want post counts if you could click a button and the count read your post count out for you. :smash:
Vun hundred and tventy vun! :count:
<3Quote:
Originally Posted by Loony BoB
Wouldn't we all :moomba: :DQuote:
Originally Posted by HOOTERS
^^^^Quote:
Originally Posted by Citizen Bleys
I hate post counters with a passion...Never leads to good so why bother. If you stick around long enough you will know how people post and who is a vet. and all. The custom rank thing kicks post counters a%$!
I have barely over 3000. If they were accurate, Bleys and I would both have easily over 10000. :pQuote:
Originally Posted by TasteyPies
Yeah, I doubt that I have more posts than some of the people that I'm supposedly "ahead" of.
It doesn't matter how many posts you have, but when you registered. So a person like Raistlin who barely even posts can still have some cred... wait, bad example.
And RSL would own everybody. So let's all just SHUT THE TROUT UP.Quote:
Originally Posted by ShlupQuack
That's it!Quote:
Originally Posted by Citizen Bleys
*makes Bleys an appointment for a rectal exam*
Next Tuesday be there at 8:00am for your ass-stick-ectomy.
OMG hes becoming Unne *runs*Quote:
Originally Posted by Citizen Bleys
well, I for one think that post counters are aweosme..they help seperate the REAL members from the newbs who only come in from time to time....also, is it really that hard to just set spammers post to 0 or ban them?
I disagree that it makes it easy to tell "real" members from people who don't post enough. Some people who post a lot are a pain in the ass, and some who haven't posted a lot are awesome. We want people to be judged on the quality of their posts, not the quantity.
I think not. I may be similar to Unne in a lot of ways, but I'll never give up drinking, swearing, or being Canadian. Never.Quote:
Originally Posted by DSL
Yup yup, that's how I feel.Quote:
Originally Posted by ShlupQuack
well, I disagree can't you just ban the people who can't handle the responsibility of holding a post counter?
Yes, we can. That's not the issue.
well, don't get me wrong I'm not trying to change your forum or sound like a jack-ass but just trying to give out different points of view...Quote:
Originally Posted by ShlupQuack
I remember a small forum where I and another member ran our post counts up verry high just to see the ranks...thats when the admin got angry and started making the higher up ones "ugly troll" and the such...thats when I stoped pharming topics...but my buddy didn't.. he soon had around 4000 posts and thats when the admin closed the forums all together. So..i'm satisfied with the "find all posts by this dude" option.
It seems like almost every forum I join falls to crap...
(in order)
:cry: www.newgrounds.com/forums was crap when I started...just peoplecalling each other ghey and OMG u r teh suk! my post is 300! yersis 67!
;) www.eyesonff.com I left after a month..can't remember why I just lost interest.
:cry: www.blackdragonsbors.com dosn't exist anymore (admin closed it)
:cry: http://gamesedge.conforums.com is now deserted
;) www.eyesonff.com came back and it has yet to go downhill
:eep: www.toonamiinfolink.com started going here a month or so ago...pretty slow paced, not alot of members
well, I am currently in two forums both seem promising...
Or not judged at all...Quote:
Originally Posted by ShlupQuack
I don't care about the post counts, but I can see how they would do more bad than good. Some people make posts saying 'this post is just to raise my post count' or 'postcount++' or something equally annoying. I'd rather take away the feature than keep it and ban people who abuse it. Less banning and work that way.
See, the problem with that different point of view is that it's wrong.Quote:
Originally Posted by 870621345
The problem with enabling post counts again is that I would be forced to kill you all and dance upon the ashes of your burning corpses. I'm exaggerating, but just barely.
That would be pretty neat to see!
well, I guess that it's good we don't have post counters becasue people would think tha I am writing this post to raise it...
FFIX Master is a BALLON head!
Suck it, commie.Quote:
Originally Posted by Del Murder
Unne got drunk at tGA. Does that count?Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark
Oh, and I don't give a damn about post counts. The only reason they're enabled at tGA is because I have absolutely nothing against banning everyone, and I think it's just a tad bit overzealous to get rid of them completely. I'd bet anything that Britt loved the idea. :p
http://forums.eyesonff.com/showthread.php?t=38129
I didn't notice before, but time to make fun :monster:
Why not create a spam forum where post counts are recorded and added to and the first one to reach 1000 posts becomes a mod?Quote:
Originally Posted by Arche
I forgot about that little document. And I really did want a Swearing Oldbies' Anime Forum, too.
I remember the days of postcount++. Wait, that was after postcounts got set to zero... I need to do that more often - spamming about Hungry Hungry Hippos gets a little hackneyed after a while.Quote:
Originally Posted by Flying Mullet
we need b back :p
Post counts dont bring anything to the table, its all about the quality of your posts. Besides people begin to get all stuck up over a lousy number. :rolleyes2 Just speaking from being from several different forums.