Voice acting as opposed to text.

Since FFX came out, Square/Square-Enix have started to use actual voices in their games rather than just text. Personally, I liked the games alot better without the voice acting. It gave it a much more origional feel, plus, ever time a character would talk, I would hear MY voice, so I kind of grew closer to the characters in that way. What do you think? Do you prefer the voice acting or the text better? There are obvious pro's and con's to both sides, so why do you like on better than the other?

Voices

The good things about voice acting are far to few.
I don't feel like I can make a connection when I hear their voices, as opposed to when I'm reading the text I'm totally hooked.
However, actually reading the lines makes me way more comfortable.
I feel more of a connection when I can make my own assumptions of how the characters actually would sound like.
So I guess...NO, I know that I like it much better without the voiceovers.

I prefer voice acting. Why?, because I don't really like having to read all the time (I'm not too fast with it).

Pros

• You hear the emotions the way they were intended.
• You don't have to read it.
• Auron's pre-Yunalesca battle speach...'nuff said :D.

Cons

• Sometimes, the actor isn't talented enough for the part, and his/her voice sounds robotic.

If the voice acting is done well, then there's no real reason not to have it. Text does have a certain charm, but it can be difficult to apply emotion to a character without actually hearing their voice.

i despise them. i prefer text

But of course many ppl like voices.

i,ve said many times...there is a simple solution to this problem, having the option of japanese/english vocals and turning the voices on and off.

hardly rocket science, why dont Square Enix use it???? :confused:

I don't know....I think I like the voice acting, as long as it's done well. I like being able to hear these characters talk---there's something about it...it makes them feel more realistic, or more of a personality maybe.

But I do like text, for the sake of being able to stop reading whenever I want, and do something else, like go to the bathroom, without missing anything.

Hrmm......they're both just swell. Yes.


:D

well, there are always good and bad points to voice acting, as there are with nething in a FF game.

i like aeris's theory of what should be done. i actually thought u can do that in FFX until i tried....but all you can do is turn off the subtitles, not the other way around... :mad:

but i do like voice acting when the voice acting is good and the actors play out an emotional/humorous scene really well ie luca scene when tidus finds out about his dad, home when you find that yuna's (SPOILER)gonna die,, auron's speach at yunalesca, and yuna's and tidus's voice acting in the ending fmv. also, nething humourous wakka or lulu says :D ITS ENTERTAINING :tongue:

but i don't like it when square speeds up the voices to match the lip synching (when yuna says "yes", etc.)

i too hear voices in my head when playing past ff, and thats good because you make those voices sound exactly how you want them to sound :D (NO, im not crazy :rolleyes2 ), and the automatically match the charcter designs because your brain MAKES the two match.

but, reading gets boring, no matter how interesting the game is. i can't play a final fantasy literally from dusk till dawn unless there's voice acting.

all in all, i agree with aeris's suggestion of what should be included to deal with this problem. some times i love it, other times i hate it :)

I wish FFVIII had voice acting just so I could see how the voice actor for Fake President Deling would handle lines such as, "HoW daRe YOU InSUlt tHe presIDent!!!"

I didn't think the voice acting in FFX was really that bad. I actually enjoyed it. It's fine as long as they have the text with the voice acting.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by aeris2001x2

ii,ve said many times...there is a simple solution to this problem, having the option of japanese/english vocals and turning the voices on and off.

---

Good voice acting like in KH = :D

Mediocre voice acting like in FFX = :mad: :eep:

I liked the voice acting in FFX, it was a good game to put voice acting in, but I prefer text in all the other games.

I think each has it's merits. Sometimes with text I'll get incredibly lazy and skim through it, either because I'm tired or because I'm annoyed with all the reading. But if a voice is bad it's hard to imagine it to be good. If they kept to the same quality as games like Lunar/Lunar 2 and Grandia it would be nice. But Square have always been about making things look nice.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Samuraid

Good voice acting like in KH = :D

Mediocre voice acting like in FFX = :mad: :eep:

---

Yes. I think I like the games are better without it. Maybe every once in a while in a cutscene or something isn't bad. KH did a really good job and I think the voice acting made it a more enjoyable game.

Metal Gear Solid and MGS2 beat out both, but since this is in General Final Fantasy, I guess I'll have to talk about FF :lol:.

Anyway, I didn't mind FFX(-2)'s voice acting too much. Tidus and Yuna's voice often sound like the actor/actress was embarrassed to do voice acting only, but hey, it wasn't all that bad.

I think the voice acting is fine as long as its in the new final fantasy games and as long as they sound good and suit the chracter.But if they do remakes of the old ones i don't want voices to be added because i already imagine what they sound like and if they didn't sound like that it would irritate me :irked:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jolts

Metal Gear Solid and MGS2 beat out both, but since this is in General Final Fantasy, I guess I'll have to talk about FF :lol:.

Anyway, I didn't mind FFX(-2)'s voice acting too much. Tidus and Yuna's voice often sound like the actor/actress was embarrassed to do voice acting only, but hey, it wasn't all that bad.

---

I agree with you, If metal gear solid didnt have voice, it wouldnt have had the emotional effect as it does now; same goes for FFX (expecially Auron's pre-yunalesca battle speach) when theres voice, it just sets you to a whole another level of interpreting what they mean...I mean GREAT I mean GREAT graphics dont work too well with text base speaking...(Imagin Aurons speach while hes in motion with text popping up? doesnt feel right)

And the reason text worked with FF7 is bc the graphics are mediocre. I mean the characters didnt show any emotion, so why should the voice?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by aeris2001x2

i,ve said many times...there is a simple solution to this problem, having the option of japanese/english vocals and turning the voices on and off.

---

is it hard to change the game in order to synch the lips for different languages?i mean, i understand that there not ever going to completely match up, but i believe KH did a good job of doing this (i think) so how come FFX didn't get the same treatment?time constraints? :confused:

Hmmm... count me as just another fogey who likes his dialouge in square blue boxes. Or that brown, stonish color you can select in FFVI. That's ok too. But there's something about the blue boxes... kinda like a security blanket-not-every-thing-is-wierd-and-scary sort of feeling.

I agree with Del and Aeris on this one. I like how KH only had it at select points, and having an option to turn it off would be cool for those of us who don't find reading chorish.

I'd take either one, but text has one problem. While you're reading the text, it's hard to see a character's actions because you are reading the speech. Other than that, it's good.

I've always liked text better, I think one of the reasons is because I sometimes find it hard to read along with someone while they are speaking, even when I am in class and someone is reading something aloud, my mind wanders all over the place.

Voices are better. I mean really who doesn't fall in love with Yuna just by how she talks and the emotions she shows while talking????O_o? Or chuckle when Rikku makes a joke???

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GhostlyWolf

I mean really who doesn't fall in love with Yuna just by how she talks and the emotions she shows while talking????

---

sorry i'm not a huge fan of stoners. I prefer my women to be *off* the wacky weed.