Printable View
I just beat the game yesterday, and I got to thinking. I've heard some people say that there are similarities between Ultimecia and Rinoa, even so far as to say that Ultimecia is Rinoa's future self. I didn't see any of that. Where are these supposed similarities?
It's because there aren't any.
Thanks, come again ^_^
I think there are some threads dealing with that,in this section..You should check them,they are really good..
Yeah, often "R=U" or "Rinoa and Ultimecia Theorem" or at least thats what i think its called, but it's pretty old and died out a whole ago
there's an editorial (which I can't find right now) that compares pictures with Ultimecia's face structure with Rinoa's...this is often used to argue with the R=U theory
Yes, but Ultimecia is said to have never loved. Rinoa + Squall = No reason for Ultimecia to be Rinoa's future self.
But how do you know it didnt turn out differently in Ultimecia's time.........Im actually all for the whole R=U thing. Im a fan for huge twists. Oh and about their faces, yep. They look alike :DQuote:
Originally Posted by timmy64
Face structure in a game with one face shape is pretty much crap:)
The similarity: Rinoa's outfit has wings. Ultimecia's outfit has wings. That's apparently enough to convince many that they are the same person.
That´s no real proof, I mean, EVERY sorceress in the game has some kind of wings. If you see a pic of Edea, she´s got 2 pieces of silk (I think it´s silk) on her back, so they can be her wings.Quote:
Originally Posted by Skyblade
Then Adel, look at the pic, and she has a couple of "wings" (though they´re like made of "bone" or something), but they´re there.
We all know ´bout Rinoa´s angel wings... so I´m not gonna discuss that point.
And finally, look at the pic of Ulti, even in her last form, she has wings on her back.
So if the theory of R=U is based mostly on the "wings part", it´s completely WRONG....
Thank you very much, but try again!!!
I like the idea. It would have given another great twist to the story.Quote:
Originally Posted by Slade
The only thing is, is that they didn't even mention this concept once throughout the game. Sure Rinoa becomes a sorceress of sorts, but there's no hard-core linkage between her and Ultimecia, except for Ultimecia taking over Rinoa, as she did with Edea and Adel.
What I'm saying is, its a great idea, it would have been an excellent fit to the story and added a great twist to the plot, but there's no concrete evidence to support Ultimecia being Rinoa in the future. Maybe square thought of it, but then threw it out the window due to Rinoa & Squall's relationship.
Normally if it were the case, it would be blatently displayed in some way during the game. Even though there are some points to support it (i.e. the wings, similar looking faces, and they're both sorceresses), it wasn't a part of the script, and therefore is not true.
Huzzah, this again. It's a disputed theory. I myself believe in it because it makes Ultimecia an actually interesting villain, instead of 'generic evil woman from future' Other people have explained it bette rthan I have, but some points.
The faces is indeed hard to assume anything off. However, Ulti has black feather wings, Rinoa has white feather wings. Ulti wears a red dress, Rinoa wears a blue dress. It's not enough to carry it on its own, but it helps.
The game takes some trouble to tell us that Sorceresses have a tendency to become corrupted by their power and become evil. So Rinoa 'becoming evil' isn't such a stress to believe.
Rinoa, in a romantic conversation with Squall says she wishes that 'time would stop this moment'. In a game where the villain wants time compression, I think the writers have a reason for that.
The ending movie has repeated flashes between Rinoa and Ultimecia, ending with Squall's eye opening widely with a tear. To me, that doesn't seme like a desperate 'I give up' expression but that of someone who realizes a 'Very Bad Thing'
Rinoa asks Squall to promise that if she ever goes evil, he will kill her. Nice irony, as Squall DOES do that (or well...at least assists)
There is no proof that would stand up in court now. But a lot of things that are either 'pure chance' or 'good, subtle (perhaps too much so) script writing' And I always prefer to go with the 'nice' option.
Both of their names end with the letter a. That means they're the same person. DUH!
Obviously
*scoffs at the naysayers*
A lot of people work Griever into to R=U theory. The fact that Squall gives Rinoa his Griever ring and that Ultimecia uses the Griever as a GF later convinces many that Rinoa/Ultimecia summoned Griever from the ring much like Doomtrain is summoned out of a ring.
But I gave up this argument a long time ago. I don't even know what I side I was on.
please, don't "bewitch" Rinoa :( .
This may sound dumb......ok it does sound dumb but what if Squall actually IS Griever. He said something about if Rinoa ever turned bad he'd become her knight......perhaps she changed him when he became her knight. Its possible, i mean Darth Vader was Lukes father :eek:Quote:
Originally Posted by Mo-Nercy
What if Ultimecia was actually Selphie? I mean think about it. They have the same facial structure. Isn't Selphie really fond of the trains? What would happen in a world where there are no more trains? Would she not turn evil and seek to destroy the organization that ruined her beloved train system? Or what about the similarity in their costumes? I think we're overlooking some MAJOR similarities, people! R=S! It CAN'T be disputed!
lmao
I think that it probarbly is true, being as it is a game with a good story and a lot of sub plot, so..... yeah. It makes the story cooler.
I think someone proved very definitely that Ultimecia=Cid.
or maybe it was cid=selphie. something like that.
That must have been future esthar.Quote:
Originally Posted by rubah
http://db.gamefaqs.com/console/psx/ file/final_fantasy_viii_time_ultimecia.txt
Piecing together those two will hopefully have provided a direct link to mine and Squall of SeeDs FAQ on R=U and such things on Gamefaqs.
It's a result of 2+ years of discussion(including on this forum), and although it isn't 100% complete, I can safely say it contains the most plausible R=U theory as well as all the logical arguments to and for. I say that not because I think I've done such a great job, but because of the great job by all the people I've discussed this with.
But to sum up my FAQ, the R=U theory simply isn't plausible. Simply the fact that it isn't mentioned or even hinted to in the Ultimania Guide for FF8 should be enough to tell us this, but for more reasons, check out that FAQ.
PS: If that link refuses to send you to an FAQ, go to:
www.gamefaqs.com
Search for "Final Fantasy VIII" --> Go to FAQs/Guides --> Find my "Time/Ultimecia Plot FAQ" (NOT the "Plot Analysis", which is a load of crap).
I think Square may have meant to use this story of R=U but decided against it in the end but still left all the points hidden in the game. Ultimecias castle being located right were Rinoa and Squall promised to meet, Its one of few explanations as to why Ultimecia would actually want to compress time, They both have angel wings and the colour change from white to dark would easily mean the change of mind from good to evil, Theres the fact that she wields Griever which was a present Squall gave to her, and also I think they have the same hair colour. If you're really interested look for a bunch of threads in this forum that went over it in much greater detail with more evidence.
Wow Sir Bahamut, I spent a good half hour reading that faq. I must say it is very well done and stated many valid points, some of which I never even heard of. I especially liked the one about the Greek couple. (I closed the window so their names escape me) It was rather interesting. I also admire how you in no way connected to Griever, which is everyone else's huge argument. You simply said that the games says Ultimecia created Griever from Squall's idea of him and that's all. Once again, very well done.
I still however believe that R=/=U. Although after reading that I know where you people are coming from.
I just found some pics, to see if we can see the similarilties.....
Ultimecia- http://img64.echo.cx/img64/4972/ultimecia6ml.jpg
Rinoa- http://img64.echo.cx/img64/3482/rinoa3nh.jpg
Rinomecia???- http://img64.echo.cx/img64/7569/rinimecia9vc.gif
Well done!You really have made a great work there!Quote:
Originally Posted by Sir Bahamut
So long as she has Squall it is. That's what a Witch's Knight is there for: To be their stability and remind them of that part of them that is a normal human being.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rand Al'Tor
Time Compression wasn't used to stop that moment on the Ragnarok in time. It was used to compress all time into a single moment, or "existance at once." This was so that the Witch Embodiment in all of its incarnations would be forced into one instance. With SeeD killing the other bearers of the Embodiment as they passed through Time Compression, that released their incarnation of the Embodiment, and the power was then there for Ultimecia to claim.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rand Al'Tor
You skipped the reason that Squall's tear was there: It was him seeing the faceplate on the suit Rinoa was wearing in space shatter. He was seeing her die. That's why he shed that tear.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rand Al'Tor
Possibly. He's not necessarily even present in the battle any longer at that point. He can be absorbed into time the same as the others when they fall.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rand Al'Tor
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mo-Nercy
Griever is an idea in Squall's mind. Use Scan on Griever and you'll see that it says "In Squall's mind, the strongest GF." He was an idea that Ultimecia gave form to, drawing it from the strongest feelings of those she was fighting.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mo-Nercy
Of course there are similarities, but if you do the same thing with Rinoa and Selphie, Edea, or Ellone, you'll find that the similarities are there, as well. The same facial structure was used for several of the females in the game.Quote:
Originally Posted by Holy_Aeris
The game shows us why her castle was there, though: To slaughter the SeeDs. Squall and the others find their dead bodies strewn across the beach behind Edea's Orphanage. Ultimecia likely decided to wipe out her foes before casting Time Compression to settle a grudge.Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
We're already given an explanation in-game, though, when we use Scan on Ultimecia:Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
"A sorceress trying to change the world by compressing time and taking power from all sorceresses."
As mentioned before, Griever was an idea that Ultimecia gave form to. As for Rinoa and Ultimecia having the same hair colour... no, they don't. Ultimecia's hair is white. Rinoa's is black. For that matter, though, even had they the same hair colour, with Adel, Ultimecia, Edea, and the 11 Witches encountered in Time Compression, we see physical deformities as it is.Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
Anyway, though, the FAQ Sir Bahamut linked to is the best place to go on the Internet to examine this matter. He and I have considered pretty much everything conceivable in our years of investigation as far as this matter goes.
Sorry but I dont get what you mean by that, I dont remember the game showing any explanation on why the castle was there.Quote:
The game shows us why her castle was there, though: To slaughter the SeeDs. Squall and the others find their dead bodies strewn across the beach behind Edea's Orphanage. Ultimecia likely decided to wipe out her foes before casting Time Compression to settle a grudge.Quote:
I think Square may have meant to use this story of R=U but decided against it in the end but still left all the points hidden in the game. Ultimecias castle being located right were Rinoa and Squall promised to meet...
I didnt realize that but thinking about it, I think that could back up R=U theory. I think trying to become all powerful and changing the world for unknown reasons is a poor excuse for the main villains motives.Quote:
We're already given an explanation in-game, though, when we use Scan on Ultimecia:Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
"A sorceress trying to change the world by compressing time and taking power from all sorceresses."
Actually now that I think about it, Im sure the japanese version said she frew Griever from Squalls mind as something Squall feared. Something along those lines. And I checked the picture I had in mind when I said they had the same hair colour. I was sure her hair was black and greay but its just grey.Quote:
As mentioned before, Griever was an idea that Ultimecia gave form to. As for Rinoa and Ultimecia having the same hair colour... no, they don't. Ultimecia's hair is white. Rinoa's is black. For that matter, though, even had they the same hair colour, with Adel, Ultimecia, Edea, and the 11 Witches encountered in Time Compression, we see physical deformities as it is.Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
Before teh castle when you're leaving Edea's place, there's bodies everywhere, is there not?Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
I can't remember because I haven't played that part in a long time.
Yeah,there were bodies of dead SeeD (Which looks EXACTLY like the White SeeD of Edea's!):eek: near Ulty's castle.
Firstly, if you've played many FF games, you'll know that the motives behind the villains are in most cases to destroy the universe/world simply because they are pure evil/mad/both. Off the top of my head I can mention:Quote:
I didnt realize that but thinking about it, I think that could back up R=U theory. I think trying to become all powerful and changing the world for unknown reasons is a poor excuse for the main villains motives.
FF1, FF3, FF5, FF6, FF7(arguable, depending on who you think the main villain really is), FF9(Necron). Is it really that farfetched that Ultimecia fits into the same category?
Secondly, no offense meant, but it's not really about what you think is a good motive. This isn't about anyones personal opinions, It's about what is the most plausible and logical conclusion based on what the game presents us.
That FAQ was awsome :D
I couldn't see it.:p
Not that no one cares......
Yes I remember that scene word from word but I dont see why that ties in with the castles location.Quote:
Originally Posted by rubah
Yes I do remember and have played all of those but 3.FF1 was pretty old and nes wasnt exactly the era of deep RPG's. An enemy who was trying to the destroy the world because he was the bad guy was acceaptable enough. FFV's villain as you said wanted to rule the world because he was the bad guy and Kefka was crazy. Spehiroth had a purpose and Jenova was an alien, You could look at her as a diesease to the planet. Kuja was the main villain of IX, he had a reason and Necron was a superior being whos purpose was to oppose Zidane for whatever reasons he stated. Considering the ammount of detail that went into the rest of VIII I do expect the villain to have a purpose for destroying time and living by herself for an eternity. She didnt even have a backstory of any sort. What Ultimecia wanted is more far fetched than the rest of them for no particular reason. And as for that second thing you mentioned, thats your opinion : P I think Rinoa being Ultimecia and, yknow actually having a reason for wanting to destroy the world is more logical than, you know not having a reason for destroying the world. So wait for my opinion before you preach to me about giving my point of view.Quote:
Firstly, if you've played many FF games, you'll know that the motives behind the villains are in most cases to destroy the universe/world simply because they are pure evil/mad/both. Off the top of my head I can mention:
FF1, FF3, FF5, FF6, FF7(arguable, depending on who you think the main villain really is), FF9(Necron). Is it really that farfetched that Ultimecia fits into the same category?
Secondly, no offense meant, but it's not really about what you think is a good motive. This isn't about anyones personal opinions, It's about what is the most plausible and logical conclusion based on what the game presents us.
I love you man.Quote:
Originally Posted by DJZen
Because the castle is directly above the Orphanage, where all of those fresh bodies are. Ultimecia hates SeeDs. She was about to complete her master plan and achieve ultimate power, changing all time as it had been known to be. Do you see the "2+2" part of this I'm getting at?Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
She wanted them dead because she hated them, so to settle her grudge before she initiated Time Compression, she killed them.
It's a very common thing for villains to do.
Ultimecia having no other reason than being evil and wanting power would arguably be a part of that detail. Final Fantays VIII plays off of the concept of fairy tales, you know? Witches, Princesses, Knights, undying true love, the perfect maiden (who also happens to be the Princess), these thiings represented with Squall, Rinoa, and Ultimecia. Whether there's a deeper meaning to it or not is irrelevant in light of the archetypes these characters are adapted from.Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
Hell, look at the Witch in Snow White. Her whole reason for the things she did was because Snow White was prettier than her. It doesn't take much to set the insane Witch ladies of a fairy tale off.
As for her being alone for eternity, that's not necessarily true. She could only exist in fully completed Time Compression because she was the one casting it. That doesn't mean she intended to let things remain that way forever. Use Scan on her final form. She was absorbing all time and space into herself. She was only using Time Compression to gather it all together and obtain the power she needed to do this. Note also that she told SeeD that they would be her slaves for eternity. No doubt she intended to remake the universe with herself as its God.
Her being greedy and wanting ultimate power as a result is more farfetched than Kefka deciding he wanted to kill everything -- but cause it to slowly suffer and succumb to despair first -- as a result of being crazy, or JENOVA and Sephiroth wanting to kill Gaia and absorb its Lifestream just to become more powerful?Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
Kefka certainly didn't need a reason other than that he thought it was fun, but anyway, Ultimecia wasn't trying to destroy it for the sake of destroying it. She wanted to become the universe. She wanted to be God.Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
Well firstly, If Im being paranoid and you dont know where Im comeing from with this Im sincerley sorry but its four in the morning and I get the feeling you're subtley patronising me in parts of your response and Im too tired to not kick up a fuss over it. Im saying what I genuinely think and I've explained why I think so, with that in mind if you are trying to irritate me knock it off.Well now I see what you're getting at and it makes sense but I dont remeber the game saying that the castle was transportable. I know it floats but it was tied down by chains. Yeah you could say theyre an anchor or something but I didnt feel the game made much suggestion that Ultimecia ever moved the castle. I felt she just left it parked in the same spot for most of the time. The corpses were fresh its fair to say but whos to say the SeeD's didnt come to her as opposed to vice versa?Quote:
Because the castle is directly above the Orphanage, where all of those fresh bodies are. Ultimecia hates SeeDs. She was about to complete her master plan and achieve ultimate power, changing all time as it had been known to be. Do you see the "2+2" part of this I'm getting at?Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
She wanted them dead because she hated them, so to settle her grudge before she initiated Time Compression, she killed them.
It's a very common thing for villains to do.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
FFVIII was packed with a fairy tale theme? Sorry I dont buy it and maybe its because its four in the morning but I dont see where your coming from with that.Quote:
Ultimecia having no other reason than being evil and wanting power would arguably be a part of that detail. Final Fantays VIII plays off of the concept of fairy tales, you know? Witches, Princesses, Knights, undying true love, the perfect maiden (who also happens to be the Princess), these thiings represented with Squall, Rinoa, and Ultimecia. Whether there's a deeper meaning to it or not is irrelevant in light of the archetypes these characters are adapted from.
Hell, look at the Witch in Snow White. Her whole reason for being so evil was because Snow White was prettier than her. It doesn't take much to set the insane Witch ladies of a fairy tale off.
As for her being alone for eternity, that's not necessarily true. She could only exist in fully completed Time Compression because she was the one casting it. That doesn't mean she intended to let things remain that way forever. Use Scan on her final form. She was absorbing all time and space into herself. She was only using Time Compression to gather it all together. Note also that she told SeeD that they would be her slaves for eternity. No doubt she intended to remake the universe with herself as its God.
Kefka was crazy and personally I think hes lacking as a villain but besides that, yeah his only excuse was being insane. Sephiroth wanted to serve Jenova and I myself view Jenova as a diesease. I mean a sickness anyone will pick up will cause harm because that is its nature.Quote:
Her being greedy and wanting ultimate power as a result is more farfetched than Kefka deciding he wanted to kill everything -- but cause it to slowly suffer and succumb to despair first -- as a result of being crazy, or JENOVA and Sephiroth wanting to kill Gaia and absorb its Lifestream just to become more powerful?Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
Well I genuinely never had that pointed out to me, my impression of time compression was all existence would die and she would be alone for an eternity. She may have said the SeeD's would be her eternal slaves but I recall Rinoa saying only she (Ultimecia) could live in a world like that. Once she got off the Ragnarok. If I had to decide Id probably agree with you that Ultimecais quote should be taken more literal.Quote:
Kefka certainly didn't need a reason other than thought it was fun, but anyway, Ultimecia wasn't trying to destroy it for the sake of destroying it. She wanted to become the universe. She wanted to be God.Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
And now I shall sleep.
^^^may you have sweet dreams of floating castles, dead SeeD's and spammage will surround your post
no, Ultemecia never says "I picked this spot because of its amazing view" but I see where SquallofSeeD is getting at (i think? i'm normally confused by his posts) I guess Ulty figured, SeeD's started here (the orphanage) so I'll camp out here straight to the source, kill them all with time comphrehension/compression/compensation, whatever, and park my castle right over the beach
but when it comes down to it...no, the game does not specify the details of why Ulty picked that spot, or her decorations for that matter
I wasn't, though being tired myself, I see that I had written it in such a way that it could be construed as such. Sorry about that.Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
The fact that it floats is enough to suggest that it's mobile. As for your point about the SeeDs having, perhaps, mounted an assault upon Ultimecia there, it's possible, sure, though I personally find it more likely that the giant floating castle was floating about and then parked there while Ultimecia slaughtered her mortal enemies.Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
Why have a floating castle that has to be anchored with chains in the first place if you aren't ever moving it?
I didn't say that it's packed with it, but it certainly plays off of it. You'd absolutely have to be trying to ignore it not to see it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
What do the Forest Owls call Rinoa? "Our Princess":
Quote:
Zone
"Just take it easy. Here, let me introduce you."
"Looks like you already met Watts."
"I guess it's just our princess then."
Watts
"It's the princess' nap time, sir."
Zone
"Ahh, man..."
"Hey, Squall, sorry, but could you go get the princess?"
What do Zell and Quistis call Rinoa? "The Princess":
(Note: They even make a joke about the concept of a Prince's kissing awakening the sleeping Princess, a common theme of Fairy Tales.)
(On the Esthar side of the Horizon Bridge.)
The fact that Rinoa went into that coma in the first place was a play on the concept of the maiden of a Fairy Tale going into a deep sleep (see Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs or Sleeping Beauty).Quote:
Quistis
"Squall, you're late."
Zell
"Is the princess still asleep?"
Quistis
"She might wake up with a kiss from the prince."
Yes, only Ultimecia could live in the Time Compressed existance, however, Ultimecia was absorbing all existance itself into her own being. She wasn't destroying it, but reshaping it. She was becoming one with it all. She would essentially be the all-permeating force in the universe, because she would be the universe, with the power to shape it at her will. Thus, she would be God.Quote:
Originally Posted by Destai
And, yeah, I definitely think that Ultimecia's quote should be taken literally. She tells SeeD she's going to send them to a dimension beyond their imagination where she will rule and they will be her slaves:
She wasn't speaking of destroying them, though.Quote:
"Insolent fools!"
"Your vain krusade ends here, SeeDs."
"The price for your meddling is death beyond death."
"I shall send you to a dimension beyond your imagining."
"There, I will reign, and you will be my slaves for eternity.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA."
Quote:
And as for that second thing you mentioned, thats your opinion : P I think Rinoa being Ultimecia and, yknow actually having a reason for wanting to destroy the world is more logical than, you know not having a reason for destroying the world. So wait for my opinion before you preach to me about giving my point of view.
Sorry, but it sounded like you were embracing the R=U theory simply because you like the concept, which is clearly a logical fallacy.
Alright, Im not allowed type messages after two pm anymore ><
edits: Am. No more all nighters for me.
I think in all probabilty her castle was mobile to begin with, and was designed to be used as a weapon against the Gardens (possibly it was one of the Gardens, but the architectural changes are too large to make that plausible). I think she took out the Gardens (which were mobile well before she gained power) first, then settled in to assault the final home of SeeDs: The Orphanage. Notice that Balamb Garden is no longer sitting comfortably in FH where you left it. In fact, Trabia is still in shambles, and neither Balamb nor Galbadia Garden are anywhere to be found in the Time Compressed world.
The Knight, The Evil Sorceress, The Princess, The Black Knight... Yeah, FFVIII had a major fairy tale theme going on. Oh, and don't forget the Knight in Shining Armor protecting the Sorceress from the marauding Dragon (Laguna's movie). :D
Oh, and bravo on casting Scan on Ultimecia. Not anything I ever bothered with, I admit. In fact, I forgot the spell completely by the endgame.
Yep... but Squall will die one day. (this means of course we get in the 'do Sorceresses have extended lives discussion)Quote:
Originally Posted by Squall of SeeD
It's not exactly the same, true. But I still say that, in a game where the villain's plot involves messing with time, the hero's romantic interest that has a potential to go evil ALSO expresses a wish to mess with time to stave off loss, combined with other stuff, if that happens, the writers ARE hinting.Quote:
Time Compression wasn't used to stop that moment on the Ragnarok in time. It was used to compress all time into a single moment, or "existance at once." This was so that the Witch Embodiment in all of its incarnations would be forced into one instance. With SeeD killing the other bearers of the Embodiment as they passed through Time Compression, that released their incarnation of the Embodiment, and the power was then there for Ultimecia to claim.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rand Al'Tor
Hm, yeah.... I drop that argument then.Quote:
You skipped the reason that Squall's tear was there: It was him seeing the faceplate on the suit Rinoa was wearing in space shatter. He was seeing her die. That's why he shed that tear.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rand Al'Tor
[uote]Possibly. He's not necessarily even present in the battle any longer at that point. He can be absorbed into time the same as the others when they fall. [/quote]Quote:
Originally Posted by Rand Al'Tor
Yeah, but him being most likely the strongest of the gang, it can generally be assumed he'll at least have fought her. Drama and Game are sometimes in opposition.
Logic was mentioned, and a always in the discussion, I make the case that in games like this 'can you logically assume it's true' is less important than in real life and 'does it make a cool story' is more important. After all, plot holes happen. So I agree that there is no definite proof that R=U, just some things I see as definite hints, but in the context of a video game, those hints are enough.
Yes, plot holes do happen. However, because we obviously don't WANT any plot holes, it goes to reason that the most plausible theory is the one that DOESN'T involve any plot holes. The theory that is both logical, hinted to, explains a lot and avoids plot holes is the better theory. The theory that relies on 'coolness factor' is clearly worse.Quote:
Logic was mentioned, and a always in the discussion, I make the case that in games like this 'can you logically assume it's true' is less important than in real life and 'does it make a cool story' is more important. After all, plot holes happen. So I agree that there is no definite proof that R=U, just some things I see as definite hints, but in the context of a video game, those hints are enough.
Saying that we should be looking for a 'cool theory' over a logical one is like saying Square don't think about the logic in their plot. As you said, Square do make the occassional plot hole, but on an overall basis, they spend a lot of time refining the plot.
And when it all boils down to the core arguments of R=U, they're simply not strong enough to make it a particularly plausible theory. I mean, it isn't even hinted to in the Ultimania Omega! In fact, the Ultimania says that sorceress have the same lifespans as normal people, which instantly disproves the theory anyway.
But anyway, all this can be found in my own and Squalls FAQ anyway, so if you want to continue the argument, you might as well read that through and argue against whatever's in there....
I just played a part of the game where Edea attempts to Sacrifice Rinoa, Now if Rinoa is Ultimicia, then why ohh why would she posses Edea to Kill Rinoa, It would be suicide and I don't think she would have done that.
GF.....Memory LossQuote:
Originally Posted by Dark Ekonis
like stated in the faq ultimecia uses or used GF's now its common knowledge that by junctioning GF's you lose your memories and as also stated she could go insane in a world without sqaull and her friends caus everyone in the whole FF8 world hates sorcerers so shed be hunted down and if somehow she survived al that she could very wel bnot remember anything bout her past and thus herself and sqaull