Well, Surprise surprise surprise.....
My favorite is VI. I'm certain this must come as quite a shock to you all.
You're all picking favorites, not bests.
Final Fantasy VI, is my favorite, but Final Fantasy Tactics is right up there with it and fighting for my loyalty and affection.
It's not a coincidence, it's just the idiot eye-candy hoaring masses love pretty shiny graphics, why do think there are so many suckers out there that got the Xbox 360 because of the graphics then find out that if they don't have HDTVs they'll never see all that glorious precious pixelated goodness; and of all the small quantity and limited genere of games, not to mention to get your full potential of the X360 you have to shell out even more clams (get it? Ah, whadda you know about comedy anyway...) for the X-Box Live features. And here's insult to injury, more than 50% of those units failed, or did not meet the needs of those that pre-ordered. HA HA Suckers! But I digress...
The only reason why a majority of people claim Final Fantasy VII as "The Best", even though there are no 'bests' there are only 'favorites', is because Final Fantasy did not become a 'craze' for the masses until the FMVs were introduced for a bunch of unimaginative eye-candy hoars. Most people only played to get to the next FMV instead of the next chapter of the story. Final Fantasy VII did however intergrate story and visually in the Final Fantasy tradition. And even now, most of their fans, complain now about it's 'outdated' graphics comapared to their precious Final Fantasy VIII which is the ultimate agitator of the "Generation Gap".
Final Fantasy VIII is the perfect example of too much concentration on visuals and less on the proper execution and development of story. I swear if it wasn't for the release of Final Fantasy Tactics at that time, I would have completely lost all faith in Squaresoft. FFVIII made me feel that something that was special to a small group of fans back in the First Gen days was suddenly ruined and sold-out to the masses that lack that one secret ingredient that Square always left up to the players: Imagination.
A lot of 2nd Gen, say this lame excuse of "The graphics are so lame and old", or "The stories are so old" without even playing them. Oh gimme a break. The only thing they love about FFVIII is the FMV and the over-the-top GF summons. Some complian that the battles in the 1 Gen FFs aren't detailed enough that they don't show the characters actually hit anything in the battles. I just ask them if they read a book with illustrations in it, and do the pictures move while you're reading the book? Okay, then, use your imagination, Doofus and Dullard. There's your required secret ingredient.
FFIX is an exception because at least the story, though I'll say, in my opinion, was pretty directionless. Too filled with sidequests but no direction to them.
The Saving Grace of 2nd Gen? Final Fantasy X. This was, in my opinion, the near-perfect and seemless intergration of story, visuals, and music, in short almost the perfect interactive cinematic Final Fantasy as it was in the past with the 1st Gen. From books to film.
FFX-2... Ugh... I'll only go there to say that the battle system and speed was it's only strong point.
So as much as I could put Final Fantasy I, IV, V, VI, VII, X, and Final Fantasy Tactics all on the pedestal of "THE BEST FINAL FANTASY" (echo), I can't. I can only do what I do in my game room... Put it on my "FAVORITE FINAL FANTASIES" shelf, and sigh a relief that I have them.
So get it through your head kids, there are not 'bests' there are favorites. So stop bickering with each other over nothing but your own freakin' fan-boy egos.
And that's pretty much all I have to say about that...