Also we can confirm now that Aerith's Knight is Faris. Freya is the Doctor and cannot be Faris.
Printable View
Also we can confirm now that Aerith's Knight is Faris. Freya is the Doctor and cannot be Faris.
The reason to doubt them is very simple - this is mafia. Trust no one.
Seven to eight characters were revealed - that leaves one or two people that can claim to be whatever they want for now. Then there are two characters whom we do not know which players they are. That leaves us with four people - out of eight - with identities that could be completely false.
Honestly I dunno how anyone can be suspicious of an old Oglop who went to space in Balamb Garden.
I don't have super compelling suspicions any way in particular right now other than FFNut whose reasoning seems to change with the direction of the wind, and I definitely don't think I would be able to take a reasonable guess at who the 2nd (non-murdering) Mafia member is. The only thing I know with confidence is that the killer was a female character, so I'm tempted to take a crack at lynching someone we suspect to be a female character.
...That paragraph sounded a lot more like a literal witch hunt than I had anticipated.
So just to sum up the votes we have thus far:
Shauna - 2/5 (FFNut, Fynn)
Scruffington - 1/5 (Aerith's Knight)
Freya - 0/5Aerith's Knight
Wait, there's a Cecil?
I mean, at least I assume the knight in white armor is Cecil.
Maybe White isn't literal? Could be like... just shining? Maybe it's Steiner!
It doesn't really matter at this point. I used Cecil as a shorthand, and we'll probably not know who it really is until the end of their game - or at least the end of the game for them ;)
##vote: Don Quixote
A mysterious benevolent voyager appears.
The man with red hair in purple clothing watches it curiously with a smile on his face, deciding on the best course of action. He decides to leave it be for the time being.