I won't even bother repeating myself again...
Type: Posts; User: Charcoal
I won't even bother repeating myself again...
You know, we'll never reach an agreement because it's all a matter of opinion.
I've already explained several times why there is room for both. Now if your opinion is set, then alright, you've made up your mind. That doesn't make your opinion a fact, however. Like I said, there...
The possibility for what I suggest is there. All I ask is an alternative.
It's not just me who feel that way; many FFVII players think The Compilation ruined the story. I haven't heard many say LOTR suck and ruined The Hobbit. And that's part of what it's at. So of course...
Well The Hobbit & LOTR looks sync in terms of logic and flow to me. FFVII however don't. And it's not only me who has that opinion, I've seen many others. I'm quite sure there are far more...
Alright, the plot holes in DoC can only be fully revealed by a very accurate explanation considering every difference between the two games or else it won't be convincing enough because additional...
For the last time, I'm not saying you have to believe me. I say some of us stick to there being two versions because we don't want any unnecessarily retcon. And since SE has never denied that being a...
As a sequel to FFVII, AC doesn’t do much wrong. It’s just that it’s what you call an add-on, and some of us who were happy with FFVII proper don’t want stuff like that. Like I said in the first post...
Barret could've been in Cosmo Canyon when he/they (Biggs, Wedge, Jessie and maybe some randoms) started AVALANCHE, as far as I remember no visitors in Cosmo Canyon are forced into a sightseeing trip....
In the original game this clearly hints that Barret created AVALANCHE and that he, Biggs, Wedge and Jessie were the main men behind it. There might very well have been minor AVALANCHE supporters...
True, that is what Dirge of Cerberus is based on. And yeah, it's understandable; SE is supposed to make profits. But does that mean they have to ruin it for those of us who prefer Final Fantasy VII...
Oh, is that so? Well then, can't you explain to me how its possible that AVALANCHE - started by Barret in the original game, suddenly turns out to have been a huge organisation a couple years back in...
I don't say you have to believe me, I say make up your own opinion. If you think I'm wrong then fine, that's your opinion. You can't prove me wrong and I can't prove myself right, as there is no...
Again I'll bring up an old argument, Square Enix has never denied there being two versions of Final Fantasy VII and so the possibility is there. Its not official (yet?) though, so people have to make...
You seem to have forgotten one thing, I don't say The Compilation isn't canon, I'm just saying there are two versions of FFVII and so I can ignore The Compilation because when considered alongside...
It isn't (necessarily) relevant now either, the prequels/sequels were never part of FFVII in the first place. This is only something they've made up along the way and it causes plot holes. It is...
I've played the game and the reason we don't hear about it in FFVII is because SE - who is milking the whole concept - want to add all kinds of stupid twists that has got nothing to do with FFVII,...
And miraculously enough we never heard anything about this SL in the original game *cough*plothole*cough*. In FFVII people can't just disappear like that. Unless you accept the retcon that is. And...
I know different characters have different perspectives. The Compilation isn't only based on those though and so mistakes are made. I don't boycott The Compilation because FFVII didn't need any; I...
Let me quote myself:
FFVII has only become retcon because the whole concept is being milked. Some of us would prefer that not happening, and yes, in most cases that would result in fanon. My...
Probably. Still, was a bit of dramatic effect worth making a plot hole for :p ? Besides, in FFVII corpses fade - and so return to the lifestream - slowly over time. They don't just suddenly disappear...
Alright Ryu, you've made it clear. There is no point in discussing the matter with you. You don't believe there to be any alternative. You think there is only one canon - the official canon, and...
Like I said, some people are blinded because they can't handle more then one type of canon - the official one. Honestly, I don't know why I bother discussing this with you anymore. If Square Enix...
Then I'll try explaining it further :) .
The Compilation SE established is canon because it is official. However, it's also retcon. The problem with that is FFVII was a finished story already. It...