Best Story
Final Fantasy VIII
Worst Story
Final Fantasy X-2
Best Gameplay
Final Fantasy XII
Worst Gameplay
Final Fantasy II
Best Characters
Final Fantasy VIII
Worst Characters
Final Fantasy XII
Best Character
Squall
Worst Character
Brother
Best Voiceovers
Final Fantasy XII
Worst Voiceovers
Final Fantasy X and X-2
Best Fanbase
Final Fantasy VIII
Worst Fanbase
Final Fantasy IX and X-2
Best Sidequests
Final Fantasy VIII and XII (Though the latter had a bit too many, but most were good.)
Best FF character in KH
Squall/Leon
Worst FF character in KH
Aerith
Best Overall New Generation
Final Fantasy VIII
Worst Overall New Generation
Final Fantasy X-2
Best Overall Old Generation
Final Fantasy I (The only one I've completed.)
Worst Overall Old Generation
Final Fantasy II (Didn't complete it, but the game mechanics made it unenjoyable for me.)
Best Overall FF
Final Fantasy VIII
Wost Overall FF
Final Fantasy X-2

It's interresting to note that the other message board I belong to (FFWA) seems to like FF8 a lot more and hate FF9 a lot more. Seems to be the opposite here.