For the same reason I hold Dan Marino and Barry Sanders to a much lower regard as football players than people like Trent Dilfer
You've got to be kidding me. I agree that winning a Super Bowl is a big deal and 99% of quarterbacks won't be remotely considered legends without a ring (Marino is a notable possible exception), but <i>Dilfer</i> over Marino? The same Dilfer that went like 6 or 7 games in the regular season <i>without a touchdown?</i> That's just insane. Marino was so much better than Dilfer, it's not even funny.