You know, the funny thing is, even though it's definitely rare, I was in the local Zellers four or five years ago and even though it was years after the game was released they had at least two dozen copies on the shelf. Likely old stock they were trying to move, but surprising none the less. If I hadn't already had my copy for a few years at that point I would have grabbed one. I still couldn't believe my eyes at the time though.
And in reply to roto's earlier statement its not always really the reviews that make it underrated but rather the lack of people that have played/know about it...as ive said earlier ive not seen very many people aware of Majora's Mask, eventhough you have.I'm goona put [strike]Beyond Good and Evil[/strike] Majora's Mask in here as well. I don't know what reviews are like for it, but it doesn't seem very well known to casual gamers even though it was bloody brilliant.
I know you may think that a game is only strictly underrated if the said game gets a bad review or fan response, but low sales and/or rarity/awareness may also be considered the definition of underrated...
Last edited by Fatal Impurity; 02-18-2007 at 06:02 PM.
But it sold incredibly well and it was well received by critics and fans. You say you don't know many people who have heard of it, but a lot of people obviously have considering its sales. If memory serves, it was a Players Choice game back when a game needed to sell a million copies to qualify for PC.
I wouldn't say Breath of Fire sucks, I played BoF III on the PSX and found it to be alright, pretty much on par with FFVII. Nothing spectacular overall, yet nothing I regret playing either.
Oh yah, another series I absolutely love but didn't see it get much fanfare during it's day, the Mega Man Zero games for GBA. I loved these games, they had everything that made MM awesome for it's time. Cool bosses, great platforming gameplay, secrets galore and an awesome storyline. I'd actually rank any of the MMZ games higher then the GBA metroid titles which I also love. Yet the only way you would know about them was if you were actually looking for a MM title, I really wish capcom and the industry would have given this series more fanfare then it actually got.
Let's see...
Skies of Arcadia: Nearly everybody (including myself) who has played it will say that this game is a masterpiece. Sure, it has a really clichéd story, but it does it so well that it makes most other RPGs look bad in comparision. The soundtrack was wonderful, but how it got butchered in the GCN remake is an unspeakable crime.
Okami: Almost everybody has complemented on this amazing game. I have not played it yet, myself. Because of this game's low sales causing Clover to dissolve, that's a real failure of the consumers.
Psychonauts: I haven't played this either, but nearly everybody who has played this likes its quirky nature. There's something wrong when a crappy Jaws GTA clone doubles the sales of this game.
Thing is, they were fully aware of the clichés when they made the game, so they worked with rather than against them. And they did a damn fine job, because even with them I found it one of the most worthwhile, engrossing, and enjoyable games around in plot as well as gameplay terms.
I think it just proves that the plot itself can be secondary to the telling. But then the best stories do tend to be "How" rather than "What".