Quote Originally Posted by Paul View Post
but the compilation contradicts the game!! so what if i come up with a theory that doesn't contradict the game, but contradicts the compilation (which wasn't really thought about much, big dollar signs gettin in the way of the design team, stoppin them from workin properly... )

plus, i mean surely any self respecting fan of FF7 rejects the compilation? i mean maybe some don't, but surely those are the exception rather than the rule.

surely the rule is still that FF7 the game is the final word? don't tell me the opposite is true... i couldn't live in such a sick, sick world.
If you cannot live in such a sick world, then kill yourself. Because this is the way the world is, you liking it or not.
It doesn't mater if it make sense or don't, and it doesn't mater if some parts of the Comp. contradict the game. It's still canon/official. You can say that the story is crap, or is full of plot-holes, or etc. But you cannot say it isn't canon, because you don't have the authority to decide this.

The Compilation is being created by the same people that made FFVII, so it is canon. You, Charcoal, Bolivar, Ryushikaze, etc. can cover your ears and go "lalalala i'm not hearing you!!" all you want, and it will not change anything. You guys don't work for SE and you didn't create FFVII, so what all of you think and belive about the story is not important, sorry.