Vinyl versus CD

[Breine]

Well, I have around 150 CDs and only one vinyl, but that doesn't mean that I necessarily prefer CDs over the old-school LPs. CDs have perfect sound, but then LPs have this very atmospheric sound to them.

[Madame Adequate]

Well, I have around 150 CDs and only one vinyl, but that doesn't mean that I necessarily prefer CDs over the old-school LPs. CDs have perfect sound, but then LPs have this very atmospheric sound to them.

I will never fathom the idea that imperfect is better than perfect.

[blim]

Well, I have around 150 CDs and only one vinyl, but that doesn't mean that I necessarily prefer CDs over the old-school LPs. CDs have perfect sound, but then LPs have this very atmospheric sound to them.

I will never fathom the idea that imperfect is better than perfect.

Perfection is over-rated, the feeling is more important. which is probably why i also prefer the sloppy production values of punk to over-produced pop music. And Cd's don't have perfect sound many of the harmonics are lost through digitization (is that a word?).

[fire_of_avalon]

That's the word.

Also, most bands actually do release LPs. The pressings are limited, and you typically have to go to a specialty store to find them. Most stores (especially big chains) don't sell them because there's not a lot of profit in them.

[Bunny]

Vinyl is a novelty, yeah. It's impractical, it wears out, it's big, it sound worse, and there's no way to play it in your car.

I'm pretty sure there is. I have no idea how to do it because my extent of car-based knowledge is pretty much "Car go vroom, don't go boom." But I'm fairly sure I saw it on television one time.

I prefer CDs for their ease. But listening to Rush on vinyl is an absolutely fantastic thing to behold.

[blim]

Nothing better than putting Christ:The Album by Crass on the turntable (or Led Zep II), rolling a fat one and pouring some wine.

Maybe the vinyl just doesn't reach the UK, or at least my crappy town.

[theundeadhero]

With older bands, the sound they were going for is played through the vinyl and that's the way they like it. Digitally remastering them changes it, making it imperfect. On every digitally remastered CD it says right there that since it was an analog production, things were lost in the digital reproduction. That's not perfection at all, or even close.

[allflowerz]

I'll take the vinyl, somethin about the whole package, I like cds but they get scratched real easy and dont seem as timeless.

[blim]

Its interesting that on another forum i frequent that is for musicians the same question is currently 100% in favour of vinyl

[Shadowdust]

With older bands, the sound they were going for is played through the vinyl and that's the way they like it. Digitally remastering them changes it, making it imperfect. On every digitally remastered CD it says right there that since it was an analog production, things were lost in the digital reproduction. That's not perfection at all, or even close.

I'd have to agree. I was going through my aunt's old vinyl collection she left at my grandparents, and I came across Bad Company~10 from 6. Fortunately, they still have a record player and I played it, though I have it on CD, it just felt different. Needless to say, it was awesome.

Even then, I had to vote for the third option as I am just thankful to hear music no matter where it comes from.

[El Bandito]

CD turntables are absolutely terrible compared to normal vinyl ones. There's just no replacement for the scratches and perfect sample loops you can achieve with vinyl.

That's the big reason for me that vinyl is still important.