Superman Returns

[The Fat Bioware Nerd]

Does Superman have any good villians besides Luthor?...Because it seems like Batman has all of the good villians.

[Captain Maxx Power]

Needed more General Zod, ruler of Planet Huston!

[Slothy]

Does Superman have any good villians besides Luthor?...Because it seems like Batman has all of the good villians.

Quite a few; Brainiac and Darkseid being the best of them as far as I'm concerned. There certainly aren't many that could carry a movie aside from those two and Luthor. Although with that said, Darkseid would be very hard to pull off in a movie believably without it getting just a little too out there.

I also don't think they should go the Bizarro route for a number of reasons. Lex creating a clone of Superman is almost rediculous enough (strange to be saying about a comic movie, but being a movie there is some degree of realism required), but one that has powers that make no logical sense is worse. The fact that he isn't all that compelling typically is also a problem. Perhaps if they went the route that Alan Moore did in the last pre-crisis Bizarro story, or something along the lines of the Red Son Bizarro route I'd be ok with it.

[Del Murder]

A Darkseid movie would be pretty awesome but I don't know how you can pull it off. The problem with Superman, more than other comics I'd say, is that it takes a while to establish the characters. A two hour movie just doesn't do it.

[ljkkjlcm9]

Basically, there was so much wrong with the storyline that it upset many true superman fans.

THE JACKEL

[Ixcal]

Superman is a boring superhero in the first place...
And trying to give him any type of romantic relationship with Lois Lane is just stupid and illogical. Why? Watch Kevin Smith's "Mallrats"... Who wants to be in a COMPLETELY PERMANANT sexfree relationship?

Due to my dislike of this character I must admit I am biased in saying... the movie sucked. But from an unbiased view the movie... well, it still sucked.

[Bunny]

Hey guys that Doomsday would make a good Superman villian, don'tcha think?

[Slothy]

Superman is a boring superhero in the first place...
And trying to give him any type of romantic relationship with Lois Lane is just stupid and illogical. Why? Watch Kevin Smith's "Mallrats"... Who wants to be in a COMPLETELY PERMANANT sexfree relationship?

Due to my dislike of this character I must admit I am biased in saying... the movie sucked. But from an unbiased view the movie... well, it still sucked.

Your last sentence makes no sense since you obviously can't be unbiased. And the fact that you say Superman is a boring hero leads me to believe you know very little about the character. Honestly, I could just about write a book on just how he's not only interesting, but very relevant to the modern world, but I'm feeling pretty lazy right now.

And has anyone seen today's paper?

[PhoenixAsh]

SPOILERS AHEAD:



I wasn't impressed... It just seemed like the idea behind the "action" scenes was that there isn't a problem that can't be solved through lifting. Throughout the film all he ever seems to do is pick up or catch a variety of large objects.

He enters the public eye again by catching a plane, he then proceeds to save a woman by carrying a car, catching the Daily Planet globe, saving lois by lifting a ship, and then saving America by lifting an island made of kryptonite (which was in my opinion ridiculously stupid given even a small amount is meant to make him weak).

He even, despite being the ultimate good guy, decides to hit on a married woman. How? By carrying her around Metropolis.

Clark was underused, Lois was a bit of a bitch to him and her husband, Superman wasn't very iconic, Lex was an idiot, his assistants were cliche in a very bad way.

Retro is fine, but this crossed from "hey, that makes me nostalgic of the old films" to, "hey this is just a rehashed version of something we saw 30 years ago".

[Slothy]

He enters the public eye again by catching a plane, he then proceeds to save a woman by carrying a car, catching the Daily Planet globe, saving lois by lifting a ship, and then saving America by lifting an island made of kryptonite (which was in my opinion ridiculously stupid given even a small amount is meant to make him weak).

You're forgetting that he used almost every power he had while saving people in Metropolis during that earthquake. Really though, what do you want? Stuff like super breath and heat vision are only so useful. His flight, speed, and strength are the bread and butter of how he saves people.

As for the kryptonite island, you'll notice a few things in the movie. The first is that kryptonite doesn't instantly take away his powers (or he probably would have went splat when he landed on the island, or at least noticed it was made of kryptonite sooner). I liked this better than the typical, "using kryptonite against Superman=instant win" scenario. It was more like it took time for his body to process the kryptonite radiation and for it to really start affecting his powers. As for lifting the island; he obviously had large chunks of earth between him and the kryptonite, likely shielding him from much, if not all of the radiation until it started to grow down through and reach him. By that point he had likely done much of the work of getting the island to escape velocity, it was just a matter of exerting enough force to keep it going a little bit longer.

He even, despite being the ultimate good guy, decides to hit on a married woman. How? By carrying her around Metropolis.

She wasn't married.

[PhoenixAsh]

You're forgetting that he used almost every power he had while saving people in Metropolis during that earthquake. Really though, what do you want? Stuff like super breath and heat vision are only so useful. His flight, speed, and strength are the bread and butter of how he saves people.

I did remember that, but it seemed like they only had that scene just for the purpose of getting all of his other powers into the film. He never really used his speed that much, and nomatter how basic flight and speed are, using them to do the same thing for five or six scenes gets pretty dull. It wouldn't have been so bad if they hadn't dramatized it so much. Every time he lifts something they gave a long panned out shot of him just holding it.

As for the kryptonite island, you'll notice a few things in the movie. The first is that kryptonite doesn't instantly take away his powers (or he probably would have went splat when he landed on the island, or at least noticed it was made of kryptonite sooner). I liked this better than the typical, "using kryptonite against Superman=instant win" scenario. It was more like it took time for his body to process the kryptonite radiation and for it to really start affecting his powers. As for lifting the island; he obviously had large chunks of earth between him and the kryptonite, likely shielding him from much, if not all of the radiation until it started to grow down through and reach him. By that point he had likely done much of the work of getting the island to escape velocity, it was just a matter of exerting enough force to keep it going a little bit longer.

The island didn't shield him enough when he landed on it to stop him getting his ass kicked by Lex, I don't see why it should have then. It also just eliminated any kind of thought required to beat the bad guy. They threw up a seemingly impossible obstacle to overcome, then just had him overcome it anyway. No lateral thinking, no clever twist, no real battle, he just lifted it and problem solved. He didn't even beat Lex, Lex was beaten by bad luck and stupidity on his own behalf.

You're right though, I forgot Lois wasn't actually married. She was in a serious relationship with someone she was supposed to have had a kid with.