Quote Originally Posted by PuPu View Post
Quote Originally Posted by jammi567 View Post
Quote Originally Posted by Masamunemaster View Post
Tifa all the way just because she is from the better FF title
Please say that that vote doesn't count, as it's a personalised reason, rather then looking at the skills of the two women and comparing them.
Jammi, I'm 99.9% sure you're only saying that just because the vote was against the FF8 character, from the game which you like so much. After all, some people's votes didn't even have reasons at all. I think even one of your votes was just to spite the other character which you didn't like.
He voted for Tifa, so I doubt that's the reason

Quote Originally Posted by RedXIII13 View Post
Selphie has Attack-Magic-Draw-Item, she uses all Basic to Intermediate Black Magic. Tifa has Added-Cut and Throw.
Throw is a Ninja skill. It's always difficult to gauge FF7 and FF8 characters, because apart from limits, they're basically all clones (except for Squall, if you want to be pendatic about the R1 trigger), so you shouldn't take any Materia or Junctioning into account.

Quote Originally Posted by PuPu View Post
Quote Originally Posted by jammi567 View Post
Quote Originally Posted by Masamunemaster View Post
Tifa all the way just because she is from the better FF title
Please say that that vote doesn't count, as it's a personalised reason, rather then looking at the skills of the two women and comparing them.
Jammi, I'm 99.9% sure you're only saying that just because the vote was against the FF8 character, from the game which you like so much. After all, some people's votes didn't even have reasons at all. I think even one of your votes was just to spite the other character which you didn't like.
He voted for Tifa, so I doubt that's the reason. In any case, I doubt Tifa will win by a single vote, so it doesn't matter.

I actually think Selphie would win this one. Her limit break is better, her weapon is superior, and she would probably have better combat training.