Balthier Rocks is the 3rd judge.

After looking at the arguments, i have to say both were good.
Axel's description was focused on his good points, emotion and feeling, however, it seemed a teeny weeny bit biased.

Aerith's was good....a bit of topic, but still, was very strong.

However my vote goes to....CLEDARIUS

ff freak, it is too late to change.

Also, are you thinking of entering Tavvy?