Quote Originally Posted by rubah View Post
Foa I think it was (SPOILER)Dobby. She probably hit on him as one of those 'omg' moments and thought it was too perfect to pass up. At least, I could see myself doing that xD
(SPOILER)I actually feel it was tonks. Dobby was there to show the goblin guy, whatever his name, that harry was a different wizard so that he would help harry break into gringott's. Lupin died to walk with Harry to sacrifice himself. Tonks seemed like the most random death, but in the end I think they did that because Harry was their kids godfather, so it'd be like Harry became like Sirius was to the kid. That's how I saw it, because at one point Harry thought to himself he'd be like another Sirius for the kid, and when both Lupin and Tonks died, he really was like that.

as for why harry lived, well from what Dumbledore was saying was that part of it was because he embraced death

and to whoever asked how the killing curse backfired on Voldermort, he was using the Elder wand, the wand that Harry was the master of. Because Harry was the master of it, he could not lose a duel in which the wand was being used, so the wand could not kill harry, and backfired to kill Voldermort.

correct me if I'm wrong, but I feel that's correct

THE JACKEL